Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Graphite vs Silicon Carbide Crucible: Which One Should You Buy?

The crucibles here are all silicon carbide graphite rated to 1800°C, so this guide weighs graphite against silicon carbide and shows how to match capacity and size to your furnace.

Graphite vs Silicon Carbide Crucible: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Nelyrho 6KG Graphite Crucible with Pouring Spout for MeltingNelyrho 6KG Graphite Crucible with Pouring Spout for MeltingView on Amazon
  2. 2Nelyrho #25-25KG Graphite Crucible for Melting MetalNelyrho #25-25KG Graphite Crucible for Melting MetalView on Amazon
  3. 3Nelyrho #0.5-0.5KG Graphite Crucible for Melting MetalNelyrho #0.5-0.5KG Graphite Crucible for Melting MetalView on Amazon
  4. 4Nelyrho #2-2KG Graphite Crucible with Pouring Spout forNelyrho #2-2KG Graphite Crucible with Pouring Spout forView on Amazon
  5. 5Nelyrho 3KG Graphite Crucible with Pouring Spout for MeltingNelyrho 3KG Graphite Crucible with Pouring Spout for MeltingView on Amazon
  6. 6Nelyrho #B6-7KG Graphite Crucible for Melting MetalNelyrho #B6-7KG Graphite Crucible for Melting MetalView on Amazon

A crucible holds molten metal, so the material decides whether the pour goes well or the crucible cracks mid-heat. Graphite and silicon carbide are the materials in the name, and the crucibles in the gear below mix them. Graphite vs silicon carbide crucible is the choice between these materials, and this guide compares them on what the listings here state, then shows how to match capacity and size to your furnace.

Other welders and gear to compare

This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Graphite vs silicon carbide crucible: what the listings sell

Every crucible in the gear below is silicon carbide graphite, not pure graphite and not pure silicon carbide. The maker of each one states the same heat limit, 1800°C, and the same metals: aluminum, gold, silver, copper and brass. The differences are capacity, size, spout and life against clay crucibles, and those are the marks to compare.

Graphite vs silicon carbide crucible side by side

Graphite Silicon carbide Silicon carbide graphite
What it is Carbon Silicon and carbon A blend of both, per the listings
Heat limit in the listings Not stated Not stated 1800°C
Life against clay crucibles Not stated Not stated 2 to 5 times longer, per CANALHOUT and LRYYFC
Pouring spout Not stated Not stated Nelyrho and LRYYFC have one
Metals listed Not stated Not stated Aluminum, gold, silver, copper, brass
Furnace fit Not stated Not stated Furnaces and kilns, per the listings

The table shows the gap in the listings: heat limits and life figures are stated for the blend, not for pure graphite or pure silicon carbide on their own. Judge the blend on its own figures, and check the capacity and size against your furnace before ordering.

What graphite brings to the blend

Graphite is the carbon in the blend, and the listings tie the graphite in it to durability and to handling repeated melts. Glazon states high-density graphite construction that handles repeated heating and cooling and helps reduce cracking. Nelyrho states heavy-duty graphite construction with longer service life than standard clay crucibles. Glazon and Nelyrho tie their graphite construction to durability, so read the maker’s own words on cracking before ordering.

What silicon carbide brings to the blend

Silicon carbide is the ceramic in the blend, and the heat limit is stated for the blend as a whole. Nelyrho, CANALHOUT, Glazon and LRYYFC all state 1800°C for their silicon carbide graphite crucibles. CANALHOUT and LRYYFC state 2 to 5 times longer life than a normal clay crucible. The 1800°C figure is stated for the blend, so match that figure to your furnace.

How to match a crucible to your furnace

Capacity comes first: the Nelyrho holds 6KG, the CANALHOUT holds 1050 mL, the Glazon holds 1200 mL at 12kg, and the LRYYFC is a 12KG crucible. Then check the size against the furnace opening: the Glazon states a 5.9 inch outside diameter, a 4.4 inch inside diameter and a 7.4 inch height, and tells you to check the furnace opening for proper fit. The Nelyrho states a 5.9 inch height and a 4.7 inch width. A crucible that does not fit the opening is the wrong crucible, whatever its capacity.

Pouring matters too: the Nelyrho and the LRYYFC have a pouring spout for controlled pouring. Melt outdoors or with strong ventilation, with dry tools and molds only, and wear a full face shield and leather PPE. Never melt unknown or sealed scrap. For the clay side of the choice, see our graphite vs clay crucible guide.

Crucibles for your furnace

The crucibles below are the gear for this guide. Each one gives its material, its capacity and its heat limit, so you can match it to your furnace. See the knife casting guides for more casting gear.

The Nelyrho is a 6KG silicon carbide graphite crucible with a pouring spout, with a stated heat limit of 1800°C (3272°F). It holds about 700 mL, stands 5.9 inches high and 4.7 inches wide, and weighs 3.2 lb. The maker states that it suits propane furnaces, gas furnaces, kilns, ovens and coal stoves, and that the spout allows controlled pouring.

The CANALHOUT is a 10Kg silicon carbide crucible with a stated heat limit of 1800°C (3272°F) and a capacity of 1050 mL. The maker states 2 to 5 times longer life than a normal clay crucible, and shows it beside a 330 mL beverage can. The maker gives 10 kg and 12.3 kg for this crucible; check before ordering.

The Glazon is a 12kg silicon carbide graphite crucible with a stated heat limit of 1800°C (3273°F) and a capacity of 1200 mL. It states a 5.9 inch outside diameter, a 4.4 inch inside diameter and a 7.4 inch height, and tells you to check the furnace opening for proper fit. The maker states high-density graphite construction that handles repeated heating and cooling.

The LRYYFC is a 12KG silicon carbide graphite crucible with a pouring spout, with a stated heat limit of 1800°C (3272°F). The maker states 2 to 5 times longer life than a normal clay crucible, and a 1-year warranty. It measures 5.4 inches by 5.4 inches by 6.7 inches.

Crucible Material Capacity Heat limit Spout
Nelyrho 6KG Crucible Silicon carbide graphite 6KG, about 700 mL 1800°C (3272°F) Yes
CANALHOUT 10Kg Crucible Silicon carbide graphite 1050 mL 1800°C (3272°F) Not stated
Glazon 12kg Crucible Silicon carbide graphite 12kg, 1200 mL 1800°C (3273°F) Not stated
LRYYFC 12KG Crucible Silicon carbide graphite 12KG 1800°C (3272°F) Yes

FAQ for welders

Is a silicon carbide graphite crucible the same as a graphite crucible?

No. The crucibles here are silicon carbide graphite, a blend of both materials. Pure graphite and pure silicon carbide are different materials, and the listings here state figures for the blend only, such as a heat limit of 1800°C.

What temperature can these crucibles handle?

1800°C, per the listings. Nelyrho, CANALHOUT and LRYYFC state 1800°C (3272°F), and Glazon states 1800°C (3273°F). Match that figure to your furnace before ordering.

How long does a silicon carbide graphite crucible last?

CANALHOUT and LRYYFC state 2 to 5 times longer life than a normal clay crucible, and Glazon states high-density graphite that handles repeated heating and cooling. Check the crucible before each melt and replace it when it shows cracks.

What size crucible do I need?

Match the capacity to the pour and the size to the furnace opening. The Nelyrho holds 6KG, the CANALHOUT holds 1050 mL, the Glazon holds 1200 mL at 12kg, and the LRYYFC is a 12KG crucible. The Glazon states a 5.9 inch outside diameter, so check the furnace opening for proper fit.

Do these crucibles have a pouring spout?

The Nelyrho and the LRYYFC have a pouring spout for controlled pouring. Check the spout on the crucible you pick before ordering.

Can I melt gold and silver in these crucibles?

Yes, per the listings. All four state aluminum, gold, silver, copper and brass. Melt outdoors or with strong ventilation, with dry tools and molds only, and never melt unknown or sealed scrap.

Related: the graphite vs clay crucible guide, our best forge burner kit for knife making picks, and the metal casting hub. Also see our o1 vs 1095 knife steel. Also see our sand casting vs investment casting. Also see our g10 vs micarta knife scales. Also see our 1095 vs 52100 knife steel. Also see our best wood for knife handles.

More related guides (12)

More buying guides