How We Pick
This page explains how WeldGearLab turns a pile of listings into a shortlist. Two things first: we do not run our own trials or take our own measurements, and the “Lab” in our name is not a laboratory. Everything below is research on published information.
Shop types we write for
The hobby garage. A home welder with a 120V outlet, a few hours a week and thin to medium steel. Input voltage, wire or rod support and what is in the box carry the most weight here.
Farm repair. Rusty, thick, outdoors and often far from a shop. We look at stick and flux core capability, duty cycle at a stated amperage and portability.
The small fab shop. Daily production on 240V. We check rated output, duty cycle, consumable supply and whether parts are easy to get.
Shortlist rules
- Only products you can buy in the United States, in the category and range of the guide.
- A listing with no meaningful specifications, or an unidentifiable seller, is left out.
- Each guide builds its own set of products. We list six where we can explain six, not thirty.
- Duty cycle is restated as welding minutes per ten at the stated amps, so machines rated at different outputs can be compared fairly.
- We note what a machine asks of your space: 120V or 240V, a gas cylinder and regulator, or an air supply.
The Gear Score
Every product we recommend carries a Gear Score between 9.2 and 9.8, one decimal. The same five criteria apply inside a category, and the weights are fixed.
| Criterion | Weight | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Performance | 35% | Amperage range, duty cycle at a stated amperage, input voltage, processes and rated thickness for welders; cut and sever thickness for plasma cutters; viewing area, shade range and sensors for helmets. |
| Build | 25% | Materials, construction, box contents, serviceability and parts supply. |
| Value | 25% | What the product gives for the money in its range, including extras you must add. |
| Safety listing | 10% | A stated CSA, UL or ETL listing for powered gear, or ANSI Z87.1 or CSA Z94.3 for eye protection. |
| Warranty | 5% | Length, scope, exclusions and who pays return freight. |
The weighted total is placed on the 9.2 to 9.8 range, so more points always means a higher score. A product never scores above one ranked higher in the same guide. If a maker does not publish a warranty term or a safety listing, that criterion scores zero, because nobody can compare a spec the maker never shared. Where safety does not apply, such as a hand tool, the product is scored over the other criteria and scaled, so it is not marked down for a certificate it could never hold. Where a performance figure is missing, we say it is not stated.
Not part of our method
- Welding with the machines, or measuring them. Thickness and duty cycle figures are manufacturer rated and labeled that way.
- Paid placement or any influence from a brand on a score.
- Prices in article text.
- Claims that a helmet, glove or respirator protects beyond its stated rating.
Products change. We revisit guides when a model changes generation. Write to [email protected] when a welding spec on our pages does not match the listing. See also the Editorial Policy and the Safety Disclaimer.
