Cast Iron vs Steel Ingot Molds: Which One Should You Buy?
Cast iron and steel ingot molds both serve the home foundry, and the right pick comes down to shape, capacity and what each listing actually states.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Nelyrho 200 Troy Ounce Cast Iron Ingot Mold9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Ingot Mold, 6in Steel Pyramid Mold for Metal9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
100 oz Troy Ounce Cast Iron Loaf Bar Ingot Mold9.6/10View on Amazon
Verdict. For cast iron vs steel ingot molds, pick cast iron for bar and loaf ingots: the Nelyrho holds 200 troy ounces with a tapered interior and a raised four-foot base, and the Bonbo holds 100 troy ounces with tapered side walls and 4 support feet. Pick the steel Tesllightt pyramid if you want a 5mm steel mold with a stated 0.8L capacity and a 5.3 pound weight. The Nelyrho states the largest troy-ounce capacity and the only stated warranty.
Pouring your own ingots starts with a mold that holds its shape, releases the cooled bar and sits steady while you pour. Cast iron and steel both show up in home foundry molds, and the choice comes down to the shape you pour, how much metal each pour holds and what the listing actually states. This comparison puts cast iron vs steel ingot molds side by side.
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
The three molds

Nelyrho 200 Troy Ounce Cast Iron Ingot Mold
A cast iron ingot mold that holds up to 200 troy ounces, with a tapered interior, a handle and a raised four-foot base, and a 1 year warranty stated.
Pros
- Holds up to 200 troy ounces, the largest troy-ounce capacity stated here
- Tapered interior lets the cooled ingot release on its own
- Raised four-foot base lifts the mold off the bench
- 1 year warranty stated in the listing
Cons
- No weight stated, so you cannot judge how heavy it is to lift when full
- Pours bars only, not loaf bars or pyramid ingots
- Must be cleaned, dried and preheated before the first pour
- Must wait for the pour to cool before demolding, so turnaround is slower than a mold you empty soon after solidifying

Ingot Mold, 6in Steel Pyramid Mold for Metal
A 5mm steel pyramid ingot mold measuring 6 x 6 x 5.3 inches, with a 0.8L capacity, four steel support bars and a stated weight of 5.3 pounds.
Pros
- 5mm thick steel with a polished inner surface for easier release
- Stated holds for four metals: about 6.4 kg brass, 12.9 kg gold, 6.9 kg silver and 1.8 kg aluminum
- Four steel support bars steady the base during the pour
- Weighs 5.3 pounds, the only weight stated here
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- Pours pyramid ingots only, not bars or loaf bars
- Needs a coating on the surface and seams before each use
- The ingot must come out soon after solidifying; waiting until it cools fully makes removal hard

100 oz Troy Ounce Cast Iron Loaf Bar Ingot Mold
A cast iron loaf bar ingot mold that holds up to 100 troy ounces, with a 3 inch non-slip handle, 4 support feet and tapered side walls with 2 release points.
Pros
- Holds up to 100 troy ounces for a single loaf bar pour
- Tapered side walls and 2 release points help the cooled bar come out
- 3 inch non-slip handle and 4 support feet for steady handling
- Solid cast iron build stated for heat resistance and repeated high-temperature use
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- No weight stated, so the heft of a full pour is unclear
- No cavity size stated, only product dimensions of 5.0 x 4.0 x 3.0 inches
- 100 troy ounce capacity is less than the 200 troy ounce Nelyrho
Other welders and gear to compare
3 Sizes High Purity Graphite Ingot Mold Set for Metal CastingCheck price on Amazon
Reversible Wire Plate Ingot Mold Reversible Jewelry IngotCheck price on Amazon
Ingot Mold Four Sided Gray Cast Iron Ingot Mold for WireCheck price on Amazon
100 oz Cast Iron Ingot Mold for Gold/Silver/Copper Melting &Check price on Amazon
100 Troy Ounce Cast Iron Ingot Molds with Handle for MetalCheck price on Amazon
25 oz Ingot Mold Cast Iron Loaf Mold for Melting Gold SilverCheck price on Amazon
Side by side
| Nelyrho 200 oz Cast Iron Ingot Mold | Tesllightt 6in Steel Pyramid Mold | Bonbo 100 oz Cast Iron Loaf Ingot Mold | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gear Score | 65 | 58 | 57 |
| Side | Cast iron | Steel | Cast iron |
| Capacity | 200 troy ounces | 0.8L | 100 troy ounces |
| Dimensions | Cavity 6.26 x 2.95 x 2.13 in | 6.0 x 6.0 x 5.3 in | 5.0 x 4.0 x 3.0 in |
| Material | Cast iron | 5mm steel | Cast iron |
| Handle | Handle included | Not stated | 3 in non-slip handle |
| Base | Raised four-foot base | Four steel support bars | 4 support feet |
| Release | Tapered interior | Polished inner surface | Tapered walls, 2 release points |
| Weight | Not stated | 5.3 lb | Not stated |
| Warranty | 1 year | Not stated | No warranty stated |
All specs here repeat what the maker rates and the listing prints, copied down 20 November 2026. Only the Nelyrho states a warranty term, and only the Tesllightt states a weight.
Cast iron vs steel ingot molds: capacity and size
Capacity is where the two cast iron molds separate. The Nelyrho holds up to 200 troy ounces, and the Bonbo holds up to 100 troy ounces. Both state troy ounces.
The steel Tesllightt states its capacity differently, at 0.8L, with stated holds of about 6.4 kg brass, 12.9 kg gold, 6.9 kg silver and 1.8 kg aluminum at one time. The listings give no shared unit between the steel mold and the cast iron molds, so a direct capacity comparison across the two sides is not possible from what the listings state.
On size, the Nelyrho lists a cavity of 6.26 x 2.95 x 2.13 inches, and the Tesllightt measures 6 x 6 x 5.3 inches. The Bonbo lists product dimensions of 5.0 x 4.0 x 3.0 inches and no cavity size, so its pour size is less clear.
Material: cast iron or steel
Both molds on the cast iron side are listed as cast iron. Bonbo states its mold is made from solid cast iron, with claims of good thermal conductivity and heat resistance, plus wear and impact resistance and resistance to cracking and deformation. The Nelyrho is listed for casting gold, silver, copper, aluminum, brass and iron.
The Tesllightt is 5mm thick steel, and the maker claims excellent heat resistance, impact resistance and wear resistance, with a polished inner surface. The Bonbo makes the same three claims for its cast iron, while the Nelyrho listing makes no such claim, so the listings give no clear material winner; the real difference is shape and stated capacity. See our graphite vs silicon carbide crucible comparison for the other half of the melting setup.
Release and demolding
Release is where the makers disagree on timing. The Nelyrho has a tapered interior and tells you to wait for cooling before demolding, since the metal shrinks as it cools. The Bonbo uses tapered side walls with 2 reinforced convex release points and the same shrinkage idea, and warns against tapping the mold forcefully.
The Tesllightt takes the opposite line: remove the ingot as soon as the metal has solidified and gained basic strength, and do not wait until it is fully cooled, since that can make removal very difficult. It also calls for a high-temperature lubricant, anti-seize paste or graphite coating on the mold surface and seams before each use.
Handles, feet and bases
Both cast iron molds come with a handle and feet. The Nelyrho has a handle and a raised four-foot base, and the Bonbo has a 3 inch non-slip handle and 4 stable support feet, which the maker says insulate high temperature from the ground. The Tesllightt has no handle stated; its base is upgraded with four steel support bars to keep the mold steady during the pour.
Warranty
The Nelyrho is the only mold here with a warranty term stated: 1 year. Bonbo states no warranty, though it offers a 30 day return for a refund. The Tesllightt listing states no warranty term at all.
Choose the Nelyrho 200 oz cast iron mold if
- You pour bars and want the largest troy-ounce capacity stated here.
- You want a handle and a raised four-foot base on a cast iron mold.
- A stated 1 year warranty matters to you.
- You are happy to wait for the pour to cool before demolding.
Choose the Tesllightt 6 in steel pyramid mold if
- You pour pyramid ingots rather than bars or loaf bars.
- You want the stated holds for brass, gold, silver and aluminum in one listing.
- You want a 5mm steel mold with a stated weight.
- You will coat the mold before each use and take the ingot out soon after it solidifies.
Choose the Bonbo 100 oz cast iron loaf mold if
- You pour loaf bars and 100 troy ounces covers your pour.
- You want a 3 inch non-slip handle and 4 support feet.
- You want tapered walls with release points for an easy release.
- You accept no stated warranty term, with a 30 day return instead.
Before You Strike an Arc
- Work outdoors or with strong ventilation when melting and pouring, and keep a fire extinguisher close.
- Check that the mold is clean and completely dry, then preheat it before the pour.
- Wear a full face shield, leather gloves and flame resistant clothing for the pour.
- Never melt unknown or sealed scrap.
FAQ for welders
Which is better, a cast iron or a steel ingot mold?
Neither side wins on the listings alone. The cast iron molds here pour bars and loaf bars, while the steel mold pours a pyramid, so shape decides first; the Nelyrho then states the largest troy-ounce capacity and the only stated warranty.
How much metal does the Nelyrho ingot mold hold?
The maker states it holds up to 200 troy ounces, with a cavity of 6.26 x 2.95 x 2.13 inches. It is listed for gold, silver, copper, aluminum, brass and iron.
Do I need to preheat an ingot mold before pouring?
The Nelyrho and Tesllightt listings both say to preheat the mold and make sure it is completely dry before use. The Bonbo listing does not state a preheat step.
When should I take the ingot out of the mold?
It depends on the mold. The Nelyrho tells you to wait for cooling before demolding, while the Tesllightt says to remove the ingot as soon as it has solidified.
Do any of these ingot molds come with a warranty?
The Nelyrho states a 1 year warranty. The Bonbo and Tesllightt listings state no warranty term; Bonbo offers a 30 day return for a refund if you are not satisfied.
Related: best cast iron ingot molds, best steel ingot molds, best metal casting furnace, best gold melting furnace, and electric vs propane melting furnace.
Scoring, line by line
Each mold is scored on performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty, with the weights published on our How We Pick page.
| Product | Gear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nelyrho 200 oz Cast Iron Ingot Mold | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | n/a | 2 |
| Tesllightt 6in Steel Pyramid Mold | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
| Bonbo 100 oz Cast Iron Loaf Ingot Mold | 9.6 | 28 | 21 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
A pick’s weighted total decides where it lands between a 9.2 floor and a 9.8 ceiling, and a bigger total never produces a smaller number. Safety points apply to gear that runs on power or lists safety features. Without either, we score out of 90 instead of 100.




