Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Electric vs Propane Melting Furnace: Which One Should You Buy?

Electric and propane melting furnaces heat metal differently, and the furnaces listed here are electric only. How the four electric furnaces differ on power, top temperature, crucibles and kit, and how to pick one.

Electric vs Propane Melting Furnace: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1VEVOR 2-Speed Electric Chain Hoist 2200 lbsVEVOR 2-Speed Electric Chain Hoist 2200 lbs9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2VEVOR Portable Propane ForgeVEVOR Portable Propane Forge9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3MMasters 3 Burner Propane Forge KitMMasters 3 Burner Propane Forge Kit9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4TOAUTO 3KG Gold Melting Furnace TGF3000 1400W 2000FTOAUTO 3KG Gold Melting Furnace TGF3000 1400W 2000FView on Amazon
  5. 5PYY Electric Melting FurnacePYY Electric Melting FurnaceView on Amazon
  6. 6MMasters 3KG Gold Melting Furnace 1500W 2102°F PID ControlMMasters 3KG Gold Melting Furnace 1500W 2102°F PID ControlView on Amazon
  7. 7VEVOR 3+1kg Electric Melting FurnaceVEVOR 3+1kg Electric Melting FurnaceView on Amazon
  8. 8Gold Melting Furnace 1800W PID Control 2192°F with 3KGGold Melting Furnace 1800W PID Control 2192°F with 3KGView on Amazon

A melting furnace turns scrap and small castings into pourable metal, and the fuel decides how it behaves on the bench. For an electric vs propane melting furnace, the heat source is the difference: electric furnaces heat with a coil and a digital controller, while propane furnaces burn gas under the crucible, and the furnaces listed in this guide are electric only: no propane furnace is listed here. The electric furnaces below run from a small jewelry melter to a full kit with crucibles, mold, tongs and gloves. Pick by power, top temperature and batch size, and check the power supply before ordering.

Other welders and gear to compare

This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Electric vs propane melting furnace: the difference in one paragraph

The difference is the heat source. An electric furnace heats with a resistance coil around the crucible and holds the temperature with a digital controller, so there is no open flame and no fuel tank to refill. A propane furnace burns gas under the crucible, which heats fast and works away from mains power but needs a tank, a burner and an open flame. The furnaces listed in this guide are electric only, so the rest of this guide picks the electric furnace by power, top temperature, crucible size and kit, and says where gas fits in the choice.

Side by side

Furnace Power Max temp Crucibles Kit Warranty
TOAUTO TRF3000 Resistance Furnace 1800W 2102°F 1KG and 3KG Mold, tongs, gloves 1 year
SimpMelts Digital Melting Furnace 1500W 2192°F 2KG and 3KG Tongs, ingot mold 1 year
HOZYZO Electric Melting Furnace Kit 1800W 2012°F 1KG and 3KG 5-in-1 mold Not stated
VEVOR Electric Melting Furnace 1350W 2102°F 3KG ceramic Not stated Not stated

The furnaces are listed in ranked order, from the fullest kit to the smallest melter. Power and top temperatures are as each listing states them.

The electric furnaces in this guide

TOAUTO TRF3000. An 1800W resistance furnace on 110V with a top temperature of 2102°F and a PID controller with an LED display. The kit holds a 3KG graphite crucible, a 1KG graphite crucible, a 10-hole ingot mold, tongs, gloves and an instruction manual. The maker states copper melts in 25 to 35 minutes, twice as efficient as the previous version, and the hexagonal base keeps the furnace steady. It weighs 16.53 lb and carries a 1-year warranty.

SimpMelts digital furnace. A 1500W furnace with PID control and a bright LED display, reaching up to 2192°F, the highest top temperature here. The kit holds a 2KG graphite crucible, a 3KG graphite crucible, crucible tongs and a steel ingot mold. High-resistance HRE alloy coils work with a reinforced ceramic liner for steady heat. It suits gold, silver, copper, aluminum and brass, and is not intended for steel, cast iron, wet material, sealed objects or unknown scrap. It measures 18.0 inches by 18.0 inches by 14.0 inches and carries a 1 year warranty.

HOZYZO electric furnace kit. An 1800W furnace on 110V with PID digital control up to 2012°F, or 1100°C. The kit holds a 1KG graphite crucible, a 3KG graphite crucible and a 5-in-1 graphite ingot mold. An enlarged stable base prevents tipping, dual heavy-duty handles help with carrying, and a heat-insulation safety mesh guards the user. It measures 8.0 inches by 8.0 inches by 12.0 inches and is made for tabletop use in garages, workshops and home studios.

VEVOR electric melting furnace. A 1350W furnace with smart temperature control and a digital panel, reaching up to 1150°C, or 2102°F. The 3KG ceramic crucible outlasts traditional graphite, per the maker, and a protective mesh adds durability. It suits gold, silver, copper, aluminum and more, for jewelry, small ingots and DIY metal projects. It measures 10.63 inches by 9.84 inches by 14.96 inches and is designed for spacious, well-ventilated areas.

When electric is the better choice

  • Ventilated bench work. No open flame and no fuel tank, with a digital controller holding the temperature, in a well-ventilated workshop.
  • Small, repeatable batches. The PID controllers on the TOAUTO, HOZYZO and SimpMelts hold steady heat for jewelry and ingots.
  • Standard household power. The TOAUTO and HOZYZO run on 110V household power, with no propane or open flames required.
  • Clean setup. No burner to light and no tank to store, which suits a home studio or garage bench.

How to pick by power and temperature

Power and top temperature are the first two figures to compare. The TOAUTO and HOZYZO run at 1800W, the SimpMelts at 1500W and the VEVOR at 1350W. Top temperatures run from 2012°F on the HOZYZO to 2102°F on the TOAUTO and VEVOR and 2192°F on the SimpMelts. The TOAUTO states copper melts in 25 to 35 minutes. Match the top temperature to the metal, and check the power supply before ordering.

How to pick by crucible and kit

Crucible size limits the batch. The TOAUTO and HOZYZO kits hold a 1KG crucible and a 3KG crucible, so a small jewelry batch and a larger ingot pour use different crucibles. The SimpMelts kit holds a 2KG crucible and a 3KG crucible. The VEVOR holds a single 3KG ceramic crucible. The TOAUTO adds a 10-hole ingot mold, tongs and gloves, the HOZYZO adds a 5-in-1 ingot mold, and the SimpMelts adds tongs and a steel ingot mold.

Power supply and placement

Electric furnaces need mains power and air. The TOAUTO and HOZYZO run on 110V household power. The VEVOR is designed for spacious, well-ventilated areas, and the SimpMelts belongs in a properly ventilated workshop. Place the furnace on a stable, level and heat-resistant surface, and use dry tools and dry metal only.

Use as directed. Work outdoors or with strong ventilation, and use a full face shield and leather PPE with dry tools and molds only. Never melt unknown or sealed scrap, and never add wet metal or overfill the crucible. Never touch hot accessories, move the furnace while hot or leave it unattended, and allow all parts to cool fully before storage. See the OSHA welding overview.

FAQ for welders

What is the difference between electric and propane melting furnaces?

An electric furnace heats with a resistance coil and a digital controller, with no open flame and no fuel tank. A propane furnace burns gas under the crucible, which heats fast and works away from mains power but needs a tank and a burner. No propane furnace is listed in this guide, so the furnaces here are electric only: pick by power, top temperature and batch size.

How hot does an electric melting furnace get?

The furnaces here state top temperatures from 2012°F to 2192°F. The HOZYZO reaches 2012°F, or 1100°C. The TOAUTO and the VEVOR reach 2102°F, and the SimpMelts reaches 2192°F, the highest top temperature here. Match the top temperature to the metal before ordering.

What metals can I melt in an electric furnace?

The furnaces here list gold, silver, copper and aluminum, and the SimpMelts adds brass. The VEVOR suits gold, silver, copper, aluminum and more, for jewelry, small ingots and DIY metal projects. The SimpMelts is not intended for steel, cast iron, wet material, sealed objects or unknown scrap containing hazardous coatings.

What size crucible do I need?

Crucibles here run from 1KG to 3KG. The TOAUTO and HOZYZO kits hold a 1KG crucible and a 3KG crucible, and the SimpMelts kit holds a 2KG crucible and a 3KG crucible. Use the smaller crucible for small trial pours, jewelry casting and precious metal work, and the larger crucible for ingot making and clean scrap recycling.

Do I need ventilation for a melting furnace?

Yes. The VEVOR is designed for spacious, well-ventilated areas, and the SimpMelts belongs in a properly ventilated workshop. Work outdoors or with strong ventilation, and use a full face shield and leather PPE with dry tools and molds only.

Related: electric vs propane forge, sand casting vs investment casting, propane vs coal forge, best 2 burner forge, best forge burner kit for knife making, best propane forge for blacksmithing, metal casting, and forges and anvils.

More buying guides