Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Propane vs Coal Forge: Which One Should You Buy?

A propane forge and a coal forge compared on heat, setup and fuel, with 4 listings as concrete examples.

Propane vs Coal Forge: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1VEVOR 6KG Propane Melting Furnace KitVEVOR 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2MMasters Mini 1 Burner Propane Forge KitMMasters Mini 1 Burner Propane Forge Kit9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 310x12 Inch Welded Blacksmith Firepot 2600F Rated10x12 Inch Welded Blacksmith Firepot 2600F Rated9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Blacksmith and Heating Coal Anthracite Nut CoalBlacksmith and Heating Coal Anthracite Nut Coal9.6/10View on Amazon

Verdict. Propane vs coal forge comes down to setup and fuel. Pick propane for fast, clean heat with little setup: a burner, a gas line and a tank get the fire going. Pick coal for a traditional firepot and solid fuel: the firepot takes nut coal, a blower feeds it air, and the ash dump clears the ash.

A forge is a fire with a job: heat steel until it moves under the hammer. The choice comes down to fuel, and propane vs coal forge is the decision a new smith faces: propane burns from a tank through a burner, while coal burns in a firepot fed by a blower. This comparison puts propane listings against coal listings on heat, setup, fuel and weight, using what each listing states.

WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The forges

VEVOR 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit

VEVOR 6KG Propane Melting Furnace Kit

VEVOR9.6/10 Gear Score
i
The Gear Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 6kg propane melting furnace that reaches 2700°F in 6.5 to 8 minutes, with a stainless steel body, a 30 psi regulator and a 6kg crucible.

Pros

  • Reaches 2700°F in 6.5 to 8 minutes
  • 6kg crucible melts 13kg gold, 7kg silver, 6kg copper or 1.8kg aluminum
  • Stainless steel body with 1.2 in insulation cotton
  • Complete kit: furnace, burner, crucible, tongs, pipe, fire brick and manual

Cons

  • A melting furnace, not a forging forge, so it suits casting first
  • Crucible is a consumable with a 2 to 3 times average service life
  • No warranty term is stated on the listing
  • Propane tank is not in the box
MMasters Mini 1 Burner Propane Forge Kit

MMasters Mini 1 Burner Propane Forge Kit

Molten Masters9.6/10 Gear Score
i
The Gear Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 1 burner propane forge rated to 2600°F, with 1 inch insulation, a fire brick and heat-resistant gloves in the box.

Pros

  • Rated to 2600°F for knife making, blacksmithing and farrier work
  • 1 inch insulation and a fire brick for dual protection
  • Heat-resistant gloves included for safe handling
  • Sets up by connecting the gas hose and burner

Cons

  • No warranty term is stated on the listing
  • No weight is stated on the listing
  • Ceramic fiber blanket needs a rigidizer or coating before use, per the safety note
  • Hose needs disconnecting after use to avoid heat damage
10x12 Inch Welded Blacksmith Firepot 2600F Rated

10x12 Inch Welded Blacksmith Firepot 2600F Rated

Bonbo9.6/10 Gear Score
i
The Gear Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A welded 10 by 12 inch coal firepot in 1/2 inch plate steel, rated to 2600°F, with a clinker breaker and a weighted ash dump.

Pros

  • 1/2 inch plate steel, welded inside and out
  • Rated to 2600°F with a clinker breaker and weighted ash dump
  • Air inlet pipe and ash dump are one piece, bolted to the firepot
  • Fits forging hammers, punches, tongs and knives

Cons

  • Needs a 9/16 inch socket or wrench to connect the ash dump and clinker breaker
  • Needs at least a 10.5 by 12.25 inch rectangular hole to mount
  • No blower is included; it needs a hand crank blower
  • About 40 pounds assembled, so it suits a fixed bench, not a portable setup
Blacksmith and Heating Coal Anthracite Nut Coal

Blacksmith and Heating Coal Anthracite Nut Coal

CZ Grain9.6/10 Gear Score
i
The Gear Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 20 pound bag of anthracite nut coal, screened to a uniform nut size for even airflow in hand-crank and blower-assisted forges.

Pros

  • Uniform nut size for even airflow and predictable burn
  • Low ash and fewer clinkers than lower-grade coal
  • Dense, high-carbon coal with strong ignition and a long-lasting burn
  • Suits blacksmith forges, farrier work and shop forges

Cons

  • Fuel only: it needs a firepot and a blower to burn
  • No temperature figure is stated on the listing
  • No burn time in hours is stated on the listing
  • Nut coal suits select coal-burning stoves only, not every stove

Other welders and gear to compare

Side by side: propane vs coal forge

Gear Score Fuel Max heat Weight
VEVOR 6KG Propane Furnace 9.6/10 Propane 2700°F 19.4 pounds
Molten Masters Mini Forge 9.6/10 Propane 2600°F Not stated
Bonbo 10×12 Firepot 9.6/10 Coal 2600°F About 40 pounds
CZ Grain Anthracite Coal 9.6/10 Coal Not stated 20 pounds

These numbers are the manufacturer’s ratings exactly as each listing gives them, recorded on 14 November 2026. No listing here states a CSA, UL or ETL listing, and no listing states a warranty term.

Heat

On stated heat, the VEVOR furnace lists the highest figure at 2700°F, reached in 6.5 to 8 minutes. The Molten Masters forge lists 2600°F, and the Bonbo firepot is rated to 2600°F. The CZ Grain coal listing states no temperature.

Setup

The propane side sets up from a burner and a gas line: the Molten Masters forge connects the gas hose and burner, and the VEVOR furnace comes with a 30 psi regulator and a propane pipe. The coal side sets up the firepot first: the Bonbo firepot needs at least a 10.5 by 12.25 inch rectangular hole, and a 9/16 inch socket or wrench connects the ash dump and clinker breaker. The coal listings call for a hand crank blower or a blower-assisted forge.

Fuel

Propane comes from a tank: the VEVOR furnace is made for a standard propane tank with a 30 psi regulator. Coal comes by the bag: the CZ Grain listing is 20 pounds of anthracite nut coal, screened to a uniform nut size for even airflow, with less ash and fewer clinkers than lower-grade coal. The VEVOR crucible is a consumable with a 2 to 3 times average service life.

Size and weight

The VEVOR furnace weighs 19.4 pounds. The Molten Masters forge measures 12.9 by 5.1 by 6.3 inches, and its listing states no weight. The Bonbo firepot weighs about 40 pounds assembled, with inside dimensions of about 10 by 12 by 3.5 inches. The CZ Grain coal comes as a 20 pound bag. See the best 2 burner forge roundup for larger propane forges.

Choose propane if

  • You want to start fast with a burner, a gas line and a tank.
  • You melt metal: the VEVOR furnace melts copper, aluminum, gold and silver.
  • You want a compact forge for knives and farrier work.
  • You want no ash or clinkers to clear.

Choose coal if

  • You want a traditional firepot built from plate steel.
  • You already run a blower, or you want a hand crank blower.
  • You forge hammers, tongs and knives in a firepot.
  • You want fuel by the bag: 20 pounds of nut coal.

How the scores work

Both sides are scored out of 10 on performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty.

Product Gear Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
VEVOR 6KG Propane Furnace 9.6 30 21 21 n/a 0
Molten Masters Mini Forge 9.6 30 21 20 n/a 0
Bonbo 10×12 Firepot 9.6 29 22 20 n/a 0
CZ Grain Anthracite Coal 9.6 28 20 21 n/a 0

Displayed scores fall between 9.2 and 9.8: the weighted point total is mapped onto that band in a straight line, so earning more points always lifts the score. Unpowered items with no stated safety features skip the safety line, and their score comes from the 90 points that are left.

Before you strike an arc. Forges run outdoors or with strong ventilation, with a CO alarm and a fire extinguisher close, and never leave one lit. Wear safety glasses, leather gloves and flame resistant clothing.

FAQ for welders

Which is hotter, propane or coal?

The listings do not answer that directly. The VEVOR propane furnace lists 2700°F, while the Molten Masters forge and the Bonbo firepot both list 2600°F, and the CZ Grain coal listing states no temperature. The Bonbo figure is the firepot’s stated maximum, not the heat of the coal.

Does a coal forge need a blower?

The Bonbo firepot is made for use with a hand crank blower, and the CZ Grain coal suits hand-crank and blower-assisted forges. The propane listings need no blower.

Can a propane forge melt metal?

The VEVOR furnace is a melting furnace: it lists a 6kg capacity and melts 13kg gold, 7kg silver, 6kg copper or 1.8kg aluminum. The Molten Masters forge is listed for knife making, blacksmithing and farrier work.

How heavy is a coal firepot?

The Bonbo firepot weighs about 40 pounds assembled, with inside dimensions of about 10 by 12 by 3.5 inches.

What fuel does a propane forge use?

A standard propane tank, per the VEVOR listing, with a 30 psi regulator.

Related: best propane forge for blacksmithing, gas forge vs coal forge, best anvil for blacksmithing, and the forges and anvils hub. Also see the propane vs charcoal forge. Also see our forge meaning. Also see our coal forge vs charcoal forge.

More buying guides