Gas Forge vs Coal Forge: Which One Should You Buy?
Gas and coal forges compared on heat, fuel, air and what comes in the box, with two Yoursme gas forges, a Simond coal forge and a bag of bituminous coal as examples.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Portable Propane Forge, Triple Burner 2700℉9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
2 Burner Propane Blacksmith Forge Kit9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Simond Store Blacksmith's Forge with Hand Blower9.5/10View on Amazon - 4
Coalforsaleonline Blacksmithing & Heating Coal9.5/10View on Amazon
Verdict. Choose a gas forge for a regulator and a stated temperature: the Yoursme 3-burner states 2700°F and 240.000 BTU. Choose a coal forge for the hand-blower routine: the Simond forge runs on a hand blower, and the coal bag holds 25 lbs of bituminous coal.
A blade blank and a bar that needs bending both start the same way: with a forge hot enough to move steel. This gas forge vs coal forge comparison puts two Yoursme gas forges against a Simond coal forge and a bag of bituminous coal, on what each listing states.
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
The forge picks

Portable Propane Forge, Triple Burner 2700℉
A triple-burner portable propane forge with a stated welding temperature of 2700°F, 240.000 BTU DFP burners, double doors and a full kit.
Pros
- Stated welding temperature of 2700°F with 240.000 BTU DFP burners
- 3 burners that run as 1, 2 or 3, with an air choke valve on each
- Double doors and a 1 in ceramic fiber blanket
- Full kit: 3 firebricks, regulator, 6.5 ft hose, tongs and gloves
Cons
- No warranty term stated
- No weight stated in the listing
- Needs a standard propane tank, supplied separately
- No stated chamber size in the listing

2 Burner Propane Blacksmith Forge Kit
A dual-burner portable propane forge with a stated maximum heating temperature of 2600°F, an oval chamber, a 1 in ceramic fiber blanket and V-Bit tongs and gloves.
Pros
- Stated maximum heating temperature of 2600°F
- Oval chamber with dual burners
- 1 in ceramic fiber blanket with a ceramic firebrick floor
- V-Bit tongs and leather welding gloves included
Cons
- No warranty term stated
- No weight stated in the listing
- Stated 1.5 MPa combustion pressure sits apart from the pressure figures the other gas listing states
- No hose stated in the listing

Simond Store Blacksmith's Forge with Hand Blower
A vintage-style coal forge with a hand blower and pedal-type handle, in a steel body.
Pros
- Hand blower with a pedal-type handle
- Steel furnace body built for high temperature forging
- Portable and compact at 11.02 pounds, per the listing
- Simple to assemble with clear directions
Cons
- No warranty term stated
- No stated maximum temperature in the listing
- No coal or fuel stated in the box

Coalforsaleonline Blacksmithing & Heating Coal
A 25 lb bag of bituminous coal in 1.5 in to 2.5 in chunks, for a consistent, long-lasting burn.
Pros
- High BTU nugget-size coal for a consistent, long-lasting burn
- 25 lbs of bituminous coal in a sturdy box
- Chunk size of 1.5 in to 2.5 in, per the listing
- Suited to forges, stoves and model railroading, per the listing
Cons
- No warranty term stated
- Fuel only, not a forge
- No stated burn time in hours in the listing
- One bag size, 25 lbs, in this listing
Other welders and gear to compare
LSMIITTH Propane Forge Burner with RegulatorCheck price on Amazon
Simond StoreCheck price on Amazon
Gas forge vs coal forge: side by side
| Yoursme 3-Burner Forge | Yoursme 2-Burner Forge | Simond Coal Forge | Coalforsaleonline Coal | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gear Score | 61 | 58 | 55 | 54 |
| Side | Gas forge | Gas forge | Coal forge | Coal forge |
| Max temperature | 2700°F | 2600°F | Not stated | Not stated |
| Burners / air | 3 burners, 1, 2 or 3 in use | 2 burners | Hand blower | Not applicable |
| Fuel | Standard propane tank | Propane | Coal | Bituminous coal, 25 lbs |
| Weight | Not stated | Not stated | 11.02 pounds | 25.0 pounds |
| In the box | 3 firebricks, regulator, hose, tongs, gloves | V-Bit tongs, welding gloves | Forge with hand blower | 25 lbs coal, 12 x 12 x 6 in box |
| Warranty | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated |
Ratings in this table are the makers’ own claims taken from each product page (13 November 2026). No listing here states a CSA, UL or ETL listing.
Heat and temperature
Heat is the clearest split. The Yoursme 3-burner states a welding temperature of 2700°F from DFP burners rated at 240.000 BTU, and the 2-burner states a maximum heating temperature of 2600°F. Neither coal-side listing states a temperature.
Fuel and air
Gas forges run on propane: the 3-burner works with a standard propane tank, which the buyer supplies. On the 3-burner, an air choke valve regulates the air mixed with the propane, and the operating pressure range is 1 to 25 PSI. The 2-burner uses a regulator to control the flow of air and gas. The Simond forge hooks up to a hand blower with a pedal-type handle, and the coal bag holds 25 lbs of bituminous coal.
Weight and portability
Neither gas listing states a weight. The Simond coal forge states 11.02 pounds, while the coal bag states 25.0 pounds in a 12 in x 12 in x 6 in box. A coal setup means carrying the forge and the fuel; a gas setup means carrying the forge and a propane tank.
What is in the box
The 3-burner comes with the fullest kit here: 3 firebricks, a regulator with manometer, a 6.5 ft hose, 2 door handles, 2 clamps, a brush, tongs and gloves. The 2-burner comes with V-Bit tongs and gloves. The Simond forge lists no box contents beyond the forge and hand blower.
Choose a gas forge if
- You want a stated temperature: 2700°F on the 3-burner, 2600°F on the 2-burner
- You want a regulator to control the heat, with an air choke valve on the 3-burner
- You want tongs and gloves included
- You have a standard propane tank
Choose a coal forge if
- You want a hand blower and pedal-type handle for air
- You want a portable forge at 11.02 pounds
- You already have coal
- You want a simple forge with no gas fittings
Before You Strike an Arc
- Run a forge outdoors or with strong ventilation, with a CO alarm and a fire extinguisher close
- Never leave a lit forge unattended
- Check the Simond height figures on arrival: the dimensions state 8.0 in and the size field states 18 in
- Check the gas fittings and hose before the first heat, and supply a standard propane tank
- Keep the coal dry in its box
For forge safety, see OSHA machine guarding guidance and CPSC carbon monoxide guidance.
FAQ for welders
Can a gas forge reach welding temperature?
The 3-burner Yoursme listing states a welding temperature of 2700°F from its DFP burners. The 2-burner states a maximum of 2600°F without naming welding temperature, and neither coal-side listing states a temperature.
Do gas forges need a propane tank?
Yes, for the 3-burner: the listing says it works with a standard propane tank, which you supply. The 2-burner is a propane forge as well, though its listing does not name the tank.
What coal does a coal forge burn?
The coal bag here is 25 lbs of bituminous coal in chunks of 1.5 in to 2.5 in, in a 12 in x 12 in x 6 in box. The listing calls it high BTU coal for a consistent, long-lasting burn in stoves and forges.
Is the Simond forge portable?
The listing calls it portable and compact, and states a weight of 11.02 pounds. It runs on a hand blower with a pedal-type handle, so there is no gas tank to carry.
How do you control the heat in a gas forge?
On the 3-burner, an air choke valve on each burner controls the air mixed with the propane, and a regulator with a manometer sets the pressure across 1 to 25 PSI. On the 2-burner, a regulator controls the flow of air and gas.
Related: propane vs MAPP gas, MAPP gas vs propane brazing torch, gasless vs gas MIG welder, and the How We Pick page.
Scoring, line by line
The picks are scored on performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty, with the weights published on our How We Pick page.
| Product | Gear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yoursme 3-Burner Forge | 9.7 | 32 | 21 | 21 | n/a | 0 |
| Yoursme 2-Burner Forge | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
| Simond Coal Forge | 9.5 | 28 | 20 | 19 | n/a | 0 |
| Coalforsaleonline Coal | 9.5 | 27 | 19 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
The lowest score we show is 9.2 and the highest is 9.8; every point total is spread proportionally across that span, so extra points mean a higher figure. Safety points apply to gear that runs on power or lists safety features. Without either, we score out of 90 instead of 100.




