Jigsaw vs Reciprocating Saw for Metal: Which One Should You Buy?
Jigsaw vs reciprocating saw for metal: the Milwaukee M18 jigsaw against the FULLYEA cordless recip saw, compared by power, blades, box and warranty.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Milwaukee M18 FUEL D-Handle 10T Metal Blade Jigsaw9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
FULLYEA Reciprocating Saw Cordless9.4/10View on Amazon
Verdict. Pick the Milwaukee M18 jigsaw for controlled cuts in metal with a blade made for it and a stated Limited Lifetime Warranty; pick the FULLYEA reciprocating saw for fast cuts with two batteries, a charger and four blades in the box.
Cutting metal with a handheld saw comes down to the cut you need to make. The jigsaw vs reciprocating saw for metal question is really about control against speed: the Milwaukee listing promises clean, accurate cuts and a D-handle made for intricate work, while the FULLYEA listing promises powerful and fast cutting with a stepless speed control. This comparison puts the Milwaukee M18 FUEL D-Handle jigsaw against the FULLYEA cordless reciprocating saw, using only what each listing states.
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
The two saws

Milwaukee M18 FUEL D-Handle 10T Metal Blade Jigsaw
An 18V brushless D-handle jigsaw with a 10T carbon steel metal blade, sold as a bare tool. The listing promises clean, accurate cuts across wood, metal and other materials, with full M18 battery compatibility.
Pros
- 18 volt brushless motor, stated for consistent power and extended runtime
- 10T carbon steel metal blade included in the box
- Ergonomic D-handle grip shaped for intricate cuts
- Limited Lifetime Warranty stated, the strongest term here
Cons
- Bare tool: no battery included, so M18 batteries are on you
- No stroke length stated
- No speed figure stated
- No blade-change detail stated

FULLYEA Reciprocating Saw Cordless
A 21V cordless reciprocating saw with 0-3500 SPM, two 2.0Ah batteries and four blades in the box. It has a 28mm stroke, a tool-free blade change and an LED light.
Pros
- 0 to 3500 SPM stepless speed control on the trigger
- Two 2.0Ah batteries and a fast charger included
- Lever-actuated tool-free blade change
- LED light and portable tool box in the box
Cons
- Warranty states limited with no term
- Plastic handle
- Only 1 of the 4 blades is for metal
- No weight stated
Side by side
| Milwaukee M18 Jigsaw | FULLYEA Recip Saw | Takeaway | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gear Score | 68 | 56 | Different totals |
| Side | Jigsaw | Reciprocating saw | Different saw types |
| Power | 18 volts, brushless | 21 volts, 0-3500 SPM | Different power setups |
| Blade | 10T carbon steel, metal | 4 blades, 1 metal, 28mm stroke | Both cut metal |
| Batteries | Bare tool, M18 compatible | 2 x 2.0Ah included | Battery setup differs |
| Box extras | Not stated | Charger, LED light, tool box | FULLYEA lists more extras |
| Warranty | Limited Lifetime Warranty | Limited warranty, no term stated | Terms differ |
All specs here repeat what the maker rates and the listing prints, copied down 22 October 2026. Neither listing states a weight or a duty cycle.
Jigsaw vs reciprocating saw for metal: power and speed
The Milwaukee runs on 18 volts with a brushless motor, and the listing states no speed figure. The FULLYEA runs on 21 volts with a 0 to 3500 SPM stepless speed control. Because only one listing states a speed, this is not a win for either side on paper: the Milwaukee’s brushless motor is the efficiency story, the FULLYEA’s 3500 SPM is the stated speed story.
On voltage the two sit close: 18 volts for the Milwaukee against 21 volts for the FULLYEA. The Milwaukee’s brushless motor is the efficiency claim in its listing, promising extended runtime and consistent power, while the FULLYEA’s listing makes no motor claim beyond the variable speed trigger. So the real contrast is a brushless motor with no stated speed against a 0 to 3500 SPM trigger with no motor claim: pick the story you trust, because the listings do not let you compare the two directly.
Blades
The Milwaukee ships with a 10T carbon steel metal blade and lists metal and wood in its surface recommendation. The FULLYEA ships with four blades: three wood blades and one metal blade, with a 28mm stroke and a tool-free blade change. For metal work specifically, the Milwaukee’s included blade is the metal one; the FULLYEA gives you one metal blade out of four. See our best jigsaw blade for sheet metal and best reciprocating saw blade for metal picks for replacements.
Blade changes split the two as well. The FULLYEA uses a lever-actuated, tool-free blade change, so a swap needs no extra tools and the listing says it saves time and effort. The Milwaukee listing states no blade-change detail at all, which is why it sits in the cons: check the manual on arrival so the first blade swap does not stall the job.
Batteries and what is in the box
The Milwaukee is a bare tool: no battery is included, though it is fully compatible with M18 batteries. The FULLYEA includes two 2.0Ah batteries, a fast charger, an LED light and a portable tool box, and it is also listed as compatible with Makita batteries. If you already own M18 batteries, the Milwaukee’s bare-tool format is not a penalty; if you are starting from nothing, the FULLYEA’s full kit is the better value.
On size, the FULLYEA’s spec table lists 10.94 by 3.07 by 4.5 inches with the LED light at the front for dark corners of the shop. The Milwaukee lists no dimensions worth quoting; its handling story is the D-handle grip, described as comfortable for intricate cuts and extended use.
Warranty
The Milwaukee states a Limited Lifetime Warranty. The FULLYEA states a limited warranty with no term. On the listings as written, the Milwaukee’s warranty is the stronger one.
The gap between the two warranty lines is worth spelling out. The Milwaukee listing names a Limited Lifetime Warranty as its warranty type; the FULLYEA listing names a limited warranty with no term attached. Neither listing prints the full warranty text, so read the manufacturer’s warranty page before you buy if the term matters to you. On paper alone, a named lifetime term beats an unnamed limited one, which is why the Milwaukee takes the warranty points here.
Bare tool or full kit
The Milwaukee arrives as a bare tool: the box holds the saw and the 10T blade, and the battery is on you. That is only a penalty if you own no M18 batteries; if your shop already runs M18 tools, the bare tool slots straight into the lineup you charge every night. The FULLYEA is the opposite proposition: saw, two 2.0Ah batteries, fast charger, four blades, manual and portable tool box in one purchase. It is also listed as compatible with Makita batteries, which matters if your shelf already holds those. Count what you own before you compare the two, because the cheaper-looking box is not cheaper if it needs batteries you do not have.
Choose the Milwaukee M18 jigsaw if
You want controlled cuts in metal with a 10T carbon steel blade made for it, you already own M18 batteries, and you value the stated Limited Lifetime Warranty. The D-handle grip is built for comfort during intricate cuts. It is the pick for metal-first work: the included blade is the 10T metal blade, not a wood blade doing a favor.
Choose the FULLYEA reciprocating saw if
You want fast cuts with a 0 to 3500 SPM speed control, and you want everything in the box: two 2.0Ah batteries, a charger, four blades and a tool box. The LED light helps in dark corners of the shop. It is the pick for fast, rough metal cutting where speed beats finesse: 3500 SPM, a 28mm stroke, and a fresh battery always on the charger.
Before You Strike an Arc
- The Milwaukee is a bare tool: have a charged M18 battery on hand before the first cut.
- The FULLYEA box includes two 2.0Ah batteries and a fast charger; charge both before the job.
- Check the fitted blade: the Milwaukee ships with the 10T metal blade, while the FULLYEA ships with one metal blade among three wood blades.
- The FULLYEA’s lever-actuated blade change needs no extra tools; the Milwaukee states no blade-change detail, so check its manual on arrival.
- Confirm the FULLYEA’s LED light works for dark corners before you start cutting.
FAQ for welders
Can a jigsaw cut metal?
The Milwaukee listing pairs this jigsaw with a 10T carbon steel metal blade and lists metal in its surface recommendation, so this one cuts metal with the blade it ships with.
What is the stroke length of the FULLYEA saw?
28mm, per the listing.
Does the Milwaukee come with a battery?
No. It is sold as a bare tool and is fully compatible with M18 batteries.
What comes in the FULLYEA box?
The saw, two 2.0Ah batteries, a fast charger, three wood saw blades, one metal saw blade, a user manual and a portable tool box.
Does the FULLYEA work with other batteries?
The listing says it is compatible with Makita batteries, and it ships with two of its own 2.0Ah batteries.
Which has the better warranty?
The Milwaukee states a Limited Lifetime Warranty; the FULLYEA states a limited warranty with no term.
Related: jigsaw vs hacksaw for metal, reciprocating saw vs hacksaw for metal, portable band saw vs jigsaw and metal nibbler vs jigsaw.
Scoring, line by line
The Gear Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. The Milwaukee leads on build and warranty; the FULLYEA leads on value with its full kit. How we pick explains the weights.
| Product | Gear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Milwaukee M18 Jigsaw | 9.5 | 28 | 22 | 18 | 0 | 4 |
| FULLYEA Recip Saw | 9.4 | 26 | 20 | 22 | 0 | 0 |
A pick’s weighted total decides where it lands between a 9.2 floor and a 9.8 ceiling, and a bigger total never produces a smaller number.




