Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Portable Band Saw vs Jigsaw: Which One Should You Buy?

Three portable band saw listings compared on cut capacity, power, weight and warranty, plus how to judge a jigsaw listing the same way.

Portable Band Saw vs Jigsaw: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1DEWALTDEWALT9.5/10View on Amazon
  2. 250 Piece Contractor Jigsaw Blades Set with Storage Case50 Piece Contractor Jigsaw Blades Set with Storage Case9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3WEN Portable Band Saw for MetalWEN Portable Band Saw for Metal9.5/10View on Amazon
  4. 4MAXXT 2-in-1 Band Saw with Table Saw BaseMAXXT 2-in-1 Band Saw with Table Saw BaseView on Amazon
  5. 5VEVOR Portable Band SawVEVOR Portable Band SawView on Amazon
  6. 6PowerSmart Portable Band SawPowerSmart Portable Band SawView on Amazon
  7. 79 Inch Benchtop Band Saw for Woodworking9 Inch Benchtop Band Saw for WoodworkingView on Amazon

The portable band saw vs jigsaw question comes up when you need to cut metal away from the bench and the tool has to travel to the work. The short answer: a portable band saw makes straight, clean cuts in pipe, strut and bar stock, while a jigsaw handles curves and cutouts in sheet and plate. This guide compares the two by what each does best, works through three band saw listings as concrete examples, and shows how to read a jigsaw listing with the same checklist.

Other welders and gear to compare

This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Portable band saw vs jigsaw: the difference in one paragraph

A portable band saw runs a toothed band in a continuous loop through two wheels, cutting on the straight run between them. You hold the work or the saw and push through pipe, angle and bar stock in straight lines. A jigsaw drives a short blade up and down, which lets it turn corners and cut curves, circles and cutouts that a band saw cannot follow. The band saw wins on straight cuts in structural shapes; the jigsaw wins on shape.

Side by side

Portable band saw Jigsaw Takeaway
Cutting action A toothed band runs in a loop A blade moves up and down Straight cuts vs curves and cutouts
Cut capacity (stated) 5 in on the DEWALT DCS376B; the 2729-20 states a 5 in blade length, not a cut capacity No jigsaw listing here; check stated depth of cut Check the stated depth of cut
Power (stated) 18V, 20V MAX or 11A 120V Not stated here Match power to the work
Weight (stated) 13.6 lb, 14.5 lb or 21.9 lb by listing Not stated here Lighter saws travel to the work
Warranty (stated) 5 years on the 2729-20; limited, no term, on the others Not stated here Compare the stated warranty terms
Blades (stated) 70-tooth HSS, or 24-tooth HSS or metal Not stated here Check tooth count and blade material

All three listings in this guide are portable band saws; no jigsaw listing was provided, so the jigsaw column says what to check rather than what a listing states. Cut capacities below come from the band saw listings only.

The three band saws in this guide

We scored the three listings on what their spec tables state. The Milwaukee 2729-20 leads on the stated warranty and a brake feature, the DEWALT DCS376B follows on brushless build and jobsite features, and the Milwaukee 6232-21 trades weight for corded power.

1. Milwaukee 2729-20 M18 Fuel Deep Cut: An 18-volt cordless deep cut band saw, tool only, with a brake feature stated and 180 watts in the table. It lists a 21.24 by 12.58 by 12.66 in size, a 13.6-pound weight, a 5-inch blade with 70 teeth in high speed steel, and a 5-year tool warranty, the longest stated term of the three. The bullets are thin, but the warranty and the brake put it first.

2. DEWALT DCS376B 20V MAX XR: A 20-volt cordless band saw, dual-handed and sold as tool only, with a 5-inch cutting capacity and a stated 4-inch cut in Schedule 40 pipe and double strut. The listing states a DEWALT-built brushless motor, dual switch activation as a protect feature, and an integrated hang hook, with a 22.4 by 11 by 6.27 in size and a 14.5-pound weight. The blade is 4 inches with 24 teeth, and the warranty is limited with no term stated.

3. Milwaukee 6232-21 Deep Cut: An 11-amp, 120-volt corded band saw with a brushless motor and 1320 watts in the table. It is the heaviest of the three at 21.9 pounds and 21.44 by 7.07 by 14.39 in, with an 18.11-inch blade, 24 teeth and a metal blade material. The bullets state the amperage and that it is manufactured in China, and the warranty is limited with no term stated.

When the portable band saw is the better choice

  • Pipe, strut and bar stock. The DEWALT listing states a 5-inch cutting capacity including 4-inch Schedule 40 pipe and double strut, the core work for a band saw.
  • Straight, repeatable cuts. The band runs in a loop and cuts on a straight line, which suits cutoff work in a fab shop or on a job site.
  • Carrying the saw to the work. The Milwaukee 2729-20 weighs 13.6 pounds and the DEWALT 14.5 pounds, light enough to carry to the work.
  • Cordless convenience. Two of the three listings are battery tools, 18-volt and 20-volt MAX, for work away from an outlet. See our best cordless band saw guide.

When the jigsaw is the better choice

  • Curves and cutouts. A jigsaw blade turns corners, so it handles shapes a band saw cannot follow.
  • Sheet and plate work. For cutting openings and profiles in flat stock, the jigsaw is the natural pick.
  • Lighter tool for light work. Check the stated weight against the cordless band saws here, 13.6 pounds on the Milwaukee 2729-20 and 14.5 pounds on the DEWALT, before you decide.
  • Tighter budgets. Compare the listing price against the band saw options in our entry-level portable band saws roundup.

How to read a jigsaw listing

No jigsaw listing was provided with this guide, so this section is a checklist. When you open one, look for the same fields used above: stated depth of cut, blade type and teeth per inch, strokes per minute, orbital action, weight and warranty term. Compare those against the tool you are replacing the way the band saw listings compare above. The jigsaw side is not better or worse on any spec here, because no jigsaw listing stated one.

Band saw kick and blade care. A band saw blade can grab the work if you push too hard, so clamp the stock and let the blade do the cutting. Wear safety glasses and gloves, keep the blade guard in place, and disconnect the battery or unplug the saw before changing blades. See the OSHA welding overview and our safety disclaimer.

FAQ for welders

Can a portable band saw cut curves?

Not really. The band runs in a straight line between the wheels, so it cuts straight. For curves and cutouts, a jigsaw is the right tool; see our jigsaw vs hacksaw for metal comparison.

What size pipe can these band saws cut?

The DEWALT DCS376B listing states a 5-inch cutting capacity and a 4-inch cut in Schedule 40 pipe and double strut. The Milwaukee listings state blade lengths of 5 inches and 18.11 inches rather than a cut capacity.

Are cordless band saws strong enough for steel?

The two cordless listings here are an 18-volt and a 20-volt MAX saw, and the Milwaukee 6232-21 is an 11-amp corded saw at 1320 watts. The listings state the power figures; match the saw to the thickness you cut most.

Which band saw has the longest warranty?

The Milwaukee 2729-20 states a 5-year tool warranty. The DEWALT and the Milwaukee 6232-21 state a limited warranty with no term.

How heavy are these saws?

The Milwaukee 2729-20 is 13.6 pounds, the DEWALT DCS376B is 14.5 pounds, and the Milwaukee 6232-21 is 21.9 pounds. The corded saw is the heaviest by a clear margin.

Related: best portable band saw for metal, best cordless band saw, jigsaw vs hacksaw for metal, and the metal fab tools hub.

More buying guides