Annular Cutter vs Twist Drill Bit: Which One Should You Buy?
S&F STEAD & FAST sells a 5/8 inch annular cutter in a 2 inch cutting depth and the same diameter in a 1 inch cutting depth. Here is how they compare on depth, shank, flutes, pilot pin and what the listings leave unclear.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Annular Cutter with Pilot Pin, 5/8" x 2"9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Annular Cutter with Pilot Pin, 5/8" x 1"9.6/10View on Amazon
Verdict. In this annular cutter vs twist drill bit comparison, the scored picks are both S&F annular cutters. Pick the 2 inch S&F cutter for deeper 5/8 inch holes in metal, and pick the 1 inch S&F cutter when the work is a single layer and the stated 118 degree cutting angle matters.
A steel plate needs a clean hole for a bolt, and the choice on the bench is which tool makes it. This annular cutter vs twist drill bit comparison looks at what the listings state, using S&F annular cutters as the concrete examples on the annular side.
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
The two cutters

Annular Cutter with Pilot Pin, 5/8" x 2"
A 5/8 inch M2AL high speed steel annular cutter with a 2 inch cutting depth, a 3/4 inch Weldon shank, a pilot pin and a plastic case.
Pros
- 5/8 inch diameter with a 2 inch cutting depth
- M2AL high speed steel with 5 spiral flutes
- 3/4 inch Weldon shank with 2 flats for secure clamping
- Pilot pin and plastic case included
Cons
- Arbor for drill press use is not included
- No warranty term is stated
- One cutter and one pilot pin in the case
- Needs a magnetic drill, or an extra arbor for drill press use

Annular Cutter with Pilot Pin, 5/8" x 1"
A 5/8 inch M2AL high speed steel annular cutter with a 1 inch cutting depth, a 3/4 inch Weldon shank, a 118 degree cutting angle, a pilot pin and a plastic case.
Pros
- 5/8 inch diameter with a 118 degree cutting angle
- M2AL high speed steel with 5 spiral flutes
- 3/4 inch Weldon shank with 2 flats for secure clamping
- Pilot pin and plastic case included
Cons
- Single layers only; not designed for multiple layers
- Arbor for drill press use is not included
- No warranty term is stated
- One cutter and one pilot pin in the case
Other welders and gear to compare
SALI 2 pcs Annular Cutter Diameter 11/16 Inch with WeldonCheck price on Amazon
SALI 2 pcs Annular Cutter Diameter 7/8 Inch with Weldon ShankCheck price on Amazon
SALI Annular Cutter Diameter 1-1/2 Inch with Weldon Shank 3/4"Check price on Amazon
SALI 2 pcs Annular Cutter Diameter 9/16 Inch with WeldonCheck price on Amazon
SALI 2 pcs Annular Cutter Diameter 5/8 Inch with Weldon ShankCheck price on Amazon
SALI 6 pcs Annular Cutter Diameter 1/2 Inch with Weldon ShankCheck price on Amazon
Side by side
| S&F 5/8 In Cutter, 2 In Depth | S&F 5/8 In Cutter, 1 In Depth | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cutting diameter | 5/8 inch | 5/8 inch | Same diameter on both listings |
| Cutting depth | 2 inch | 1 inch | The main difference between the two |
| Shank | 3/4 inch Weldon, 2 flats | 3/4 inch Weldon, 2 flats | Same shank on both listings |
| Material | M2AL high speed steel | M2AL high speed steel | Same material on both listings |
| Flutes | 5, spiral | 5, spiral | Same flute count on both listings |
| Cutting angle | Not stated | 118 degrees | Only the 1 inch listing states an angle |
| Pilot pin | Included | Included | One pilot pin in each case |
| Arbor for drill press | Not included | Not included | Extra arbor needed for drill press use |
| Layer limit | Not stated | Single layers only | Only the 1 inch listing states a layer limit |
| Weight | 4 ounces | 3.2 ounces | Each weight from its own listing |
| Warranty | Not stated | Not stated | Neither listing states a warranty term |
All specs here repeat what the maker rates and the listing prints, copied down 29 October 2026. Neither listing states a warranty term or a CSA, UL or ETL listing.
Annular cutter vs twist drill bit: how they cut
The listings here pair the annular cutter with a pilot pin and a 3/4 inch Weldon shank for a magnetic drill. The scored picks below are both annular cutters, one in each cutting depth. What separates the two S&F cutters is cutting depth, plus the cutting angle and layer guidance that only the 1 inch listing states.
Cutting depth
Both cutters share a 5/8 inch diameter, but the depths differ: the first listing states a 2 inch cutting depth and the second states a 1 inch cutting depth. Diameter, material, shank and flute count match across the two listings, so depth is the headline difference. Pick a cutting depth that covers the thickness of the work, and remember that the 1 inch listing limits its cutter to single layers.
Shank and fit
Both listings state a 3/4 inch Weldon shank with 2 flats for secure clamping, and both name the same magnetic drill brands: Alfra, BDS, Dewalt, Fein, Euroboor, Hougen and Ruko. Both cases hold one annular cutter and one pilot pin. Neither case holds an arbor, so a drill press setup needs an extra arbor that is not included in either pack.
What each listing leaves unclear
Neither listing states a warranty term, so both score zero on warranty. The 2 inch listing states no cutting angle, while the 1 inch listing states 118 degrees. The 1 inch listing states a single-layer limit, while the 2 inch listing states no layer guidance.
Choose the 2 inch cutter if
- You cut 5/8 inch holes with a magnetic drill and need the deeper cut.
- You want the same shank, material and flute count with more depth.
- You already have an arbor if you plan drill press use.
- A stated warranty term is not a deciding factor for you.
Choose the 1 inch cutter if
- Your work is a single layer of metal.
- You want the stated 118 degree cutting angle in the listing.
- You cut 5/8 inch holes with a magnetic drill.
- You follow the low feed rate guidance when engaging the bit.
FAQ for welders
What is the difference between an annular cutter and a twist drill bit?
The listings here cover the annular cutter side: both pair the cutter with a pilot pin and a 3/4 inch Weldon shank for a magnetic drill. The two listings differ in cutting depth, 2 inch against 1 inch, and only the 1 inch listing states a cutting angle and a single-layer limit.
Which S&F cutter cuts deeper?
The 2 inch cutter states a 2 inch cutting depth, against a 1 inch cutting depth on the other listing. Both share a 5/8 inch diameter, the same M2AL high speed steel, the same shank and the same flute count.
Can these cutters run on a drill press?
Both listings say an extra annular cutter arbor is needed for drill press use, and that the arbor is not included in either pack. Both cutters are made for magnetic drill presses, with the same brands named as compatible.
Can the 1 inch cutter drill multiple layers?
No. The 1 inch listing says to drill single layers only, and that this series is not designed for drilling multiple layers. It also advises a low feed rate when engaging the bit, rising to the recommended rate once the bit is about 2-3mm in.
Do these cutters come with a warranty?
Neither listing states a warranty term. Both cases hold one annular cutter, one pilot pin and a plastic case, and neither case holds an arbor.
Related: annular cutter vs hole saw, magnetic drill vs benchtop drill press, and best drill bits for steel.
Scoring, line by line
Both cutters are scored on performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty. Safety scores zero on both, since neither listing states a CSA, UL or ETL listing, and warranty scores zero on both, since neither listing states a warranty term.
| Product | Gear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S&F 5/8 In Annular Cutter, 2 In Depth | 9.6 | 28 | 21 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
| S&F 5/8 In Annular Cutter, 1 In Depth | 9.6 | 27 | 21 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
A pick’s weighted total decides where it lands between a 9.2 floor and a 9.8 ceiling, and a bigger total never produces a smaller number. Where safety does not apply (unpowered gear with no listed safety features), it is left out and the remaining 90 points make up the score.
Before you drill. Secure the workpiece firmly before drilling, and check that the magnetic drill grips it firmly. Confirm the shank fits your magnetic drill, since both listings use a 3/4 inch Weldon shank, and remember that a drill press setup needs an extra arbor. Keep the pilot pin with the cutter, and use a firm steady pressure through the cut.




