Annular Cutter vs Hole Saw: Which One Should You Buy?
Annular cutter vs hole saw: how they cut, when each wins, and four annular cutter examples.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Annular Cutter with Pilot Pin9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
EZARC Carbide Hole Saw Heavy Duty9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
Annular Cutter with Pilot PinView on Amazon - 4
SALI 2 pcs Annular Cutter Diameter 7/8 Inch with Weldon ShankView on Amazon - 5
SALI 2 pcs Annular Cutter Diameter 5/8 Inch with Weldon ShankView on Amazon - 6
SALI Annular Cutter Diameter 1-1/2 Inch with Weldon Shank 3/4"View on Amazon - 7
1-9/16"x2 HSS Annular Cutter,Diameter 1-9/16",Cutting DepthView on Amazon
An annular cutter and a hole saw both cut round holes in metal, but they do it differently: an annular cutter shaves a ring and leaves a solid slug, while a hole saw saws the full circle and leaves a hole full of chips. For a magnetic drill on thick steel, the annular cutter is the right tool; for a hand drill on thin sheet, the hole saw usually is. This guide compares them for home and farm metalwork, with four annular cutter examples from current listings.
Other welders and gear to compare
Annular Cutter with Pilot PinCheck price on Amazon
SALI 2 pcs Annular Cutter Diameter 7/8 Inch with Weldon ShankCheck price on Amazon
SALI 2 pcs Annular Cutter Diameter 5/8 Inch with Weldon ShankCheck price on Amazon
SALI Annular Cutter Diameter 1-1/2 Inch with Weldon Shank 3/4"Check price on Amazon
1-9/16"x2 HSS Annular Cutter,Diameter 1-9/16",Cutting DepthCheck price on Amazon
This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
Annular cutter vs hole saw: the difference in one paragraph
An annular cutter has cutting teeth only on the rim of a hollow cylinder. It removes just the ring of metal and leaves a solid slug. A hole saw has teeth around a cup and removes the entire disc as chips. Annular cutters run on magnetic drills; three examples here state a 3/4 inch Weldon shank, and the VEVOR set states a Weldon shank without a stated size. Hole saws run on hand drills with an arbor.
Side by side
| Factor | Annular cutter | Hole saw | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cuts | A ring; leaves a solid slug | The full disc; leaves chips | Cutter removes less metal |
| Depth in examples | 1 to 2 inch | Not stated | VEVOR set reaches 2 inch |
| Drive | Magnetic drill, Weldon shank | Hand drill, arbor | 3/4 in shank stated in three examples; S&F and SALI note the arbor is not included |
| Pilot | Pilot pin, included with these examples | Pilot drill bit | VEVOR set has two pins |
| Best for | Thick steel, clean holes | Thin sheet, hand drills | Single layers only per S&F |
All specs here repeat what the maker rates and the listing prints; hole-saw practice is general shop guidance. Always secure the workpiece before drilling.
When an annular cutter is the better choice
- Thick steel on a mag drill. The VEVOR set cuts to a 2 inch depth and the others to 1 inch.
- Clean, burr-free holes. The S&F and SALI listings state edges designed for smooth, reamed, burr-free holes.
- Less metal removed. Cutting only the ring removes less metal than sawing the full disc.
- Repeatable holes. The pilot pin centers each cut, and the VEVOR set includes two pilot pins for six cutters.
When a hole saw is the better choice
- Hand drill work. Hole saws fit a standard drill chuck; annular cutters need a magnetic drill or a special arbor.
- Thin sheet. On thin material a hole saw works with a hand drill.
- Occasional holes. One hole saw needs no mag drill or special arbor.
- Wood and plastic. Hole saws cut non-metals; annular cutters are metal tools.
The gear: four annular cutters
VEVOR 6-pc set. Six Weldon shank cutters from 1 to 2 inches in diameter with a 2 inch cutting depth, in M2AL high-speed steel, with two pilot pins and a portable case. The set pick: every common size in one foam-lined case, and the only example with a 2 inch depth.
SALI 2-pc set. Two 7/8 inch cutters with a 1 inch cutting depth and 3/4 inch Weldon shank, in HSS, with one 1/4 by 3 inch pilot pin and a plastic case. The pair pick: a common bolt-hole size with a spare cutter in the box.
Evolution CC625. A 5/8 inch cutter with a 1 inch depth of cut in M2AL high speed steel, with a 3/4 inch Weldon shank and a free pilot pin. The single pick: one size, one cutter, for the mag drill you already own.
S&F Stead and Fast 5/8 inch. A 5/8 inch cutter with a 1 inch cutting depth in M2AL HSS, with a 3/4 inch Weldon shank and pilot pin, in a sturdy plastic case at 3.2 ounces. The spare pick: the same common size as the Evolution with usage guidance in the listing.
Choosing the cutter size and depth
Pick the diameter from the hole you need, not the machine you own: the examples cover 5/8 inch (Evolution and S&F), 7/8 inch (SALI) and 1 to 2 inches (VEVOR set). The Evolution, S&F and SALI cutters each cut to a 1 inch depth, and the VEVOR set cuts to a 2 inch depth, which matters for thick plate and tube. Three examples here state a 3/4 inch Weldon shank, so check that your magnetic drill accepts it before ordering; the Evolution listing states it fits most standard magnetic drill presses, the S&F listing names compatible brands including Alfra, BDS, Dewalt, Fein, Euroboor, Hougen and Ruko, while SALI lists Alfra, BDS, Dewalt, Euroboor, Hougen and Ruko. A pilot pin is not optional: it centers the cutter and ejects the slug. The Evolution ships with a free pilot pin, the S&F and SALI each include one, the SALI pin measures 1/4 by 3 inches, and the VEVOR set includes two pins sized 6.34mm by 103mm for six cutters. The Evolution, S&F and VEVOR listings state M2AL high speed steel, the SALI listing states M20AL high speed steel, and the listings name metal and stainless surfaces.
How to use one without breaking it
The S&F listing gives the technique: use a firm steady pressure throughout the cut, drill single layers of material only, and use a low feed rate when the bit first engages, increasing once it is about 2 to 3mm in. Secure the workpiece firmly before drilling. On a drill press instead of a mag drill, you need an extra annular cutter arbor, which the S&F and SALI listings both note is not included.
FAQ for welders
Can I use an annular cutter in a hand drill?
Not directly: they use a Weldon shank for magnetic drills, and three of the examples here state a 3/4 inch size. On a drill press you need a separate annular cutter arbor.
What sizes do these examples cover?
From 5/8 inch (Evolution, S&F) and 7/8 inch (SALI) up to 1 to 2 inches in the VEVOR set, with 1 inch depth except the VEVOR 2 inch.
Do annular cutters need pilot pins?
Yes for centering: the Evolution includes a free pilot pin, the S&F and SALI include one each, and the VEVOR set includes two.
Annular cutter or hole saw for thick steel?
Annular cutter on a mag drill: it cuts only the ring and leaves a solid slug, while a hole saw saws the full disc.
Can annular cutters drill stacked plates?
The S&F listing says no: drill single layers of materials only, to avoid premature cutter failure.
Related: bench vise vs welding vise, types of welding clamps, and welding tables and carts.




