Spot Welder vs MIG Welder: Which One Should You Buy?
Spot welders pinch sheet metal; MIG welders lay continuous beads. Two handheld spot welders compared on power, current and capacity.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Battery Spot Welder9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
035" V Groove Drive Roll Kit Compatible with Miller9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Spot Welder Dent Puller Machine Body Repair Dent Removal9.5/10View on Amazon - 4
Stark USA 220V Portable Spot WelderView on Amazon - 5
FEMEROL Plasma Cutter Welder Combo 200A Gas MIG/GaslessView on Amazon - 6
HIZONE 8 in 1 200A Plasma Cutter Welder ComboView on Amazon - 7
WELDPRO 140A MIG Welder 110/220VView on Amazon - 8
LOTOS MIG225 225A MIG WelderView on Amazon - 9
150A 3-in-1 Synergic MIG Flux Core Spot Welder 120V PortableView on Amazon
Spot welder vs MIG welder is a joining-method question: a spot welder fuses sheet metal with pinched resistance welds, while a MIG welder lays a continuous bead with wire and gas. One honest note: both listings here are handheld spot welders, so the MIG side is answered from the distinction. This guide answers the question directly and compares the two spot welders on power, current and capacity.
Other welders and gear to compare
Stark USA 220V Portable Spot WelderCheck price on Amazon
FEMEROL Plasma Cutter Welder Combo 200A Gas MIG/GaslessCheck price on Amazon
HIZONE 8 in 1 200A Plasma Cutter Welder ComboCheck price on Amazon
WELDPRO 140A MIG Welder 110/220VCheck price on Amazon
LOTOS MIG225 225A MIG WelderCheck price on Amazon
150A 3-in-1 Synergic MIG Flux Core Spot Welder 120V PortableCheck price on Amazon
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
Spot welder vs MIG welder: the short answer
Pick a spot welder for factory-style sheet metal joints: pinch, squeeze, weld, done, with no filler wire and no gas. The Stark listings here are handheld spot welding guns for sheet metal and automotive repair. Pick a MIG welder for continuous seams, thicker material and out-of-position work, where a wire-fed bead beats a pinch weld. For auto body panels, the spot welder matches the original factory joints; for fabrication, the MIG is the versatile machine.
What the listings tell you
Two Stark USA handheld spot welders. The 55009: 110 volts, 1.5KVA rated input, 5500A maximum output current, 1/8-inch capacity, 6-inch throat depth, copper tips. Note its spec table lists 6600 watts against the bullets’ 1.5KVA; the bullets win, so ignore the wattage figure. The 55010: 220 volts, 2.5KVA rated input, 6750A maximum output current, 1/8-inch capacity, copper electrode tips plus an extra pair, 28.9 pounds, 2500 watts. Both are 18.5 inches long with a lever handle. Neither listing states a warranty term or a safety certification.
Power and current
The 55010 is the stronger machine: 2.5KVA and 6750A against 1.5KVA and 5500A on the 55009. Both state 1/8-inch welding capacity for sheet metal, carbon steel and aluminum per the 55010 listing. The trade is the outlet: the 55009 runs on 110 volts, the standard household circuit, while the 55010 needs 220 volts. For a home garage without a 220V outlet, the 110V machine is the practical pick; for heavier sheet metal work with 220V available, the 55010’s extra current is the stated advantage.
Handling and extras
Both are handheld spot welding guns: pull the lever, apply pressure, press down. The 55009 lists a 6-inch throat depth for reaching into panels. The 55010 lists copper electrode tips with an extra pair included for multiple uses, plus welding rod and a user manual in the box; the 55009 includes a manual. The 55010 weighs 28.9 pounds; the 55009 states no weight. Our MIG vs TIG for stainless steel comparison covers process choice.
The gear: two spot welders, ranked
1. Stark USA 55010 (220V). The stronger spot welder: 2.5KVA, 6750A, 1/8-inch capacity, copper tips with an extra pair included, 28.9 pounds. Needs a 220V outlet.
2. Stark USA 55009 (110V). The household-circuit pick: 1.5KVA, 5500A, 1/8-inch capacity, 6-inch throat depth, copper tips. Runs on 110 volts.
Outlet and power: the 110V vs 220V decision
The outlet question decides which of the two listings fits your shop. The Stark 55009 runs on 110 volts with a stated 1.5KVA rated input and 5500A maximum output current. The Stark 55010 needs 220 volts with a stated 2.5KVA rated input and 6750A maximum output current. Both sides state their power clearly, so the trade is stated, not assumed: the 110V machine is the household-circuit pick, and the 220V machine is the stronger stated machine for a shop with 220V available. One listing oddity: the 55009 spec table states 6600 watts against the 55010’s 2500 watts, which sits oddly next to the KVA and amperage figures; this guide uses the stated KVA and amperage figures for the power comparison and reports the wattage as stated.
What comes in the box
The box contents differ by model. The 55010 includes welding rod and a user manual, plus an extra pair of copper welding tips for multiple uses; the listing describes twisting the tips off and screwing the new ones on when they are ready to be replaced. The 55009 includes a manual only, with no extras stated. Both listings describe durable copper welding tips, with the 55010 calling them copper electrode tips for carbon steel, aluminum and sheet metal fabrication. Model numbers are 55009 and 55010, and both listings state industrial use as the specific use for the product.
Reach and handling
The 55009 is the reach pick on paper: it states a 6-inch throat depth, which neither listing explains further but which the 55010 does not claim. Both machines are stated at 18.5 inches long with a lever handle, and both are described as lightweight and compact with an attached handle for transport between job sites. The 55009 states a plastic handle; the 55010 states a plastic or rubber handle. Weight is stated on one side only: the 55010 weighs 28.9 pounds, and the 55009 states no weight. Both are stated as portable. Operation is the same per the listings: pull the lever, apply pressure, and press down on the lever.
Capacity and materials, per the listings
Both listings state 1/8-inch welding capacity. The 55010 names the materials: carbon steel, aluminum and sheet metal fabrication. The 55009 names sheet metal and automotive repair among its applications, with metal fabrication, electronics repair and auto body welding described across both listings. Neither listing states a warranty term or a safety certification, so the stated build is the copper tips, the lever design and the stated electrical figures. For the MIG side of this comparison, our portable MIG vs portable stick welder comparison and MIG vs TIG for stainless steel cover the wire-fed machines these listings are not.
FAQ for welders
Can a spot welder replace a MIG welder?
Not fully. A spot welder makes pinch welds in sheet metal; a MIG welder lays continuous beads and handles thicker material and more positions. They are different machines for different joints.
What thickness can these spot weld?
Both Stark listings state 1/8-inch capacity, for sheet metal, carbon steel and aluminum per the 55010 listing.
Do I need 220V for spot welding?
The 55009 runs on 110 volts; the 55010 needs 220 volts. The 220V machine states higher current at 6750A against 5500A.
Do these come with extra tips?
The 55010 includes an extra pair of copper welding tips. The 55009 listing states copper tips with no extras mentioned.
Related: portable MIG vs portable stick welder, best MIG wire for home garage.
| Model | Verdict | Input | Max current | Capacity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stark USA 55010 | Stronger pick | 220V, 2.5KVA | 6750A | 1/8 in |
| Stark USA 55009 | 110V pick | 110V, 1.5KVA | 5500A | 1/8 in |




