Best High Carbon Steel Sheet Metal (2026): 5 Cold Rolled Sheets Compared
Five cold rolled carbon steel sheets compared on size, gauge, pack count and the carbon grade each maker states.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Best OverallXIOBTQT 12 x 16 18 Gauge9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Largest Single SheetYaocom 12 x 18 16 Gauge9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Deburred EdgesKickFry 12 x 99.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Pre-Drilled HolesWENHUALI 12 x 6 Pre-Drilled9.5/10View on Amazon
A flat sheet of steel on the bench is where brackets, patches, panels and small fabricated parts start. You lay out the part, cut it, drill it, bend it and weld it, so the sheet has to arrive flat and clean, in a size and thickness that suit the job. This guide compares the best high carbon steel sheet metal picks we could score from what each maker states: sheet size, gauge, pack count and carbon grade.
A clear point before the picks: none of these makers states a high carbon grade. The sheets below are stated as mild carbon steel, low carbon steel, or carbon steel with no grade named. If your project needs a stated high carbon grade, check the grade with the maker before you order. If you need flat cold rolled sheet for fabrication work, these are the stated options, scored on size, gauge, pack count and surface finish.
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
Quick picks
- Best Overall XIOBTQT 12 x 16 18 Gauge: 4 sheets at 12 x 16 inches in 18 gauge cold rolled carbon steel, stated burr-free and ready to weld, cut, bend and paint. Check price on Amazon
- Largest Single Sheet Yaocom 12 x 18 16 Gauge: A 12 x 18 inch sheet in 16 gauge, stated at 0.06 inches thick, in low carbon steel with a smooth clean surface. Check price on Amazon
- Deburred Edges KickFry 12 x 9: A 12 x 9 inch mild carbon steel sheet with deburred precision edges and a stated rust-resistant treatment. Check price on Amazon
- Pre-Drilled Holes WENHUALI 12 x 6 Pre-Drilled: 2 sheets at 12 x 6 inches in 20 gauge low carbon steel, each with 4 pre-drilled holes for mounting. Check price on Amazon
The machines

4 Pcs 12" x 16" Sheet Metal 18 Gauge Cold Rolled
Four 12 x 16 inch sheets of 18 gauge cold rolled carbon steel, stated with smooth burr-free surfaces that can be welded, cut, bent and painted without pre-treatment.
Pros
- 4 sheets in the pack, the highest count here
- 12 x 16 inch sheets give a large working area per sheet
- Stated burr-free surfaces, ready to weld, cut, bend and paint
- Uniform thickness stated across all sheets in the pack
Cons
- Carbon grade stated only as carbon steel, with no high carbon grade named
- Pack weight stated at 10.0 lb, the heaviest here to handle
- No warranty term is stated
- 18 gauge is thinner stock than the 16 gauge sheet in this roundup

Yaocom 1 Pcs 12" x 18" 16 Gauge Sheet Metal
A 12 x 18 inch sheet of 16 gauge cold rolled steel plate, stated at 0.06 inches and 1.5 mm thick, in low carbon steel with easy formability and a smooth clean surface.
Pros
- 12 x 18 inch sheet, the largest single sheet here
- 16 gauge stock with thickness stated at 0.06 inches and 1.5 mm
- Easy formability and a smooth, clean surface stated
- Good plasticity and weldability stated by the maker
Cons
- Stated as low carbon steel, not a high carbon grade
- Single sheet per pack, so larger jobs need repeat orders
- Weight is not stated
- No warranty term is stated

KickFry 12" x 9" Steel Sheet Metal
A 12 x 9 inch cold rolled mild carbon steel sheet with deburred precision edges, stated compatible with welding, cutting, drilling, bending and painting.
Pros
- Deburred precision edges stated, with no sharp burrs
- Stated compatible with welding, cutting, drilling, bending and painting
- Rust-resistant treatment stated, with no additional coatings needed
- Weight stated at 1.8 lb for a single sheet
Cons
- Stated as mild carbon steel, not a high carbon grade
- 12 x 9 inch sheet is smaller than the 12 x 16 and 12 x 18 sheets here
- Gauge is not stated
- Single sheet per pack

20 Gauge 12 x 6 Steel Sheet Metal 2 Pcs
Two 12 x 6 inch sheets of 20 gauge cold rolled low carbon steel with a smooth even surface, clean-cut edges and 4 pre-drilled holes in each plate for mounting.
Pros
- 4 pre-drilled holes in each plate for easy mounting
- 2 sheets in the pack at 12 x 6 inches
- Smooth, even surface with clean-cut edges stated
- Can be wiped clean and directly welded, cut, drilled, bent, shaped or painted
Cons
- Stated as low carbon steel, not a high carbon grade
- 12 x 6 inch sheets suit small parts, not large panels
- 20 gauge is the thinnest stock stated in this roundup
- Maker advises applying a finish or coating after use to avoid rusting

2 Pcs 20 Gauge Steel Sheet Metal
Two 12 x 6 inch plates of 20 gauge cold rolled carbon steel with a flat smooth surface, finely cut edges and a protective oil coating.
Pros
- 2 plates in the pack at 12 x 6 inches
- Flat and smooth surface with finely cut edges stated
- Supports welding, cutting, drilling, bending and painting
- Protective oil coating stated to prevent rusting
Cons
- Carbon grade stated only as carbon steel, with no high carbon grade named
- 12 x 6 inch plates suit small parts, not large panels
- 20 gauge is the thinnest stock stated in this roundup
- No pre-drilled holes, so mounting holes are your own work
Other welders and gear to compare
Lenslux 304 Stainless Steel Sheets MetalCheck price on Amazon
Wensilon(300pcs)#8×3/4”for Sheet Metal Self-Tapping ScrewsCheck price on Amazon
WensilonCheck price on Amazon
Wensilon(200pcs)#8×1”for Sheet Metal Self-Tapping Screws 410Check price on Amazon
Anfrere 10 Sizes Step Drill Bit for Metal SheetCheck price on Amazon
Spec sheet comparison
| Model | Gear Score | Size | Gauge | Pack | Carbon grade stated | Weight | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| XIOBTQT 12 x 16 18 Gauge | 9.7/10 | 12 x 16 in | 18 gauge | 4 | Carbon steel | 10.0 lb | Not stated |
| Yaocom 12 x 18 16 Gauge | 9.6/10 | 12 x 18 in | 16 gauge | 1 | Low carbon steel | Not stated | Not stated |
| KickFry 12 x 9 | 9.6/10 | 12 x 9 in | Not stated | 1 | Mild carbon steel | 1.8 lb | Not stated |
| WENHUALI 12 x 6 Pre-Drilled | 9.5/10 | 12 x 6 in | 20 gauge | 2 | Low carbon steel | Not stated | Not stated |
| WENHUALI 12 x 6 | 9.5/10 | 12 x 6 in | 20 gauge | 2 | Carbon steel | Not stated | Not stated |
Treat the specs as maker ratings pulled straight from the listings; we gathered them on 20 November 2026.
Buying guide: choosing the best high carbon steel sheet metal for your bench
Carbon grade, stated plainly
Read the grade each maker actually states. The KickFry sheet is stated as mild carbon steel. The Yaocom sheet and the pre-drilled WENHUALI plates are stated as low carbon steel. The XIOBTQT sheets and the plain WENHUALI plates are stated as carbon steel with no grade named. No pick here states a high carbon grade, so match the stated grade to your project and confirm with the maker when the grade matters.
Size and pack count
Sizes here run from 12 x 6 inches to 12 x 18 inches. The Yaocom sheet is the largest single piece at 12 x 18 inches. The XIOBTQT pack holds four sheets at 12 x 16 inches, the KickFry sheet measures 12 x 9 inches, and both WENHUALI packs hold two plates at 12 x 6 inches. Lay your cut list against the stated size before you order, and count pack quantity against the parts you plan to cut.
Gauge and thickness
Stated gauges here are 16 gauge, 18 gauge and 20 gauge. The Yaocom 16 gauge sheet states thickness at 0.06 inches and 1.5 mm. The KickFry sheet states 0.06 inches in its dimensions with no gauge named. The pre-drilled WENHUALI plates state 0.04 inches in 20 gauge. The XIOBTQT sheets state 18 gauge and the plain WENHUALI plates state 20 gauge, with no inch thickness named. Pick the stated gauge that suits your part, and check the thickness figure where the maker gives one.
Surface, edges and rust protection
Surface claims differ by maker. The XIOBTQT sheets state smooth, burr-free surfaces ready to weld, cut, bend and paint. The KickFry sheet states deburred precision edges and a rust-resistant treatment. Both WENHUALI packs state a protective oil coating, and the pre-drilled plates state clean-cut edges with 4 pre-drilled holes per plate. The Yaocom sheet states a smooth, clean surface. Wipe oil-coated sheet clean before welding, as the maker of the pre-drilled plates describes.
Use as directed. Wear eye protection when cutting and drilling sheet, clamp the work before you cut or drill, and keep hands clear of sharp edges on cut pieces. Store sheet flat and dry, and apply a finish or coating after use where the maker advises it. See the OSHA welding overview and our Safety Disclaimer.
Before You Strike an Arc
- Confirm the stated sheet size and gauge against your cut list before you order; the Yaocom maker advises confirming size before purchase.
- Wipe protective oil coating off the weld area first; the pre-drilled WENHUALI plates are stated to wipe clean and weld directly.
- Check the stated carbon grade for your project: mild carbon steel, low carbon steel, or carbon steel with no grade named.
- Plan mounting around the 4 pre-drilled holes on the pre-drilled WENHUALI plates, or mark your own holes on plain sheet.
- Apply a finish or coating after use where the maker advises it to avoid rusting.
FAQ for welders
Are these sheets actually high carbon steel?
No maker here states a high carbon grade. The KickFry sheet is stated as mild carbon steel, the Yaocom sheet and the pre-drilled WENHUALI plates are stated as low carbon steel, and the XIOBTQT sheets and plain WENHUALI plates are stated as carbon steel with no grade named. Check the grade with the maker if your project needs a named high carbon grade.
What gauge sheet metal is stated here?
Stated gauges are 16 gauge on the Yaocom sheet, 18 gauge on the XIOBTQT sheets and 20 gauge on both WENHUALI packs. The KickFry sheet names no gauge and states 0.06 inches in its dimensions. Match the stated gauge and thickness figure to the part you are making.
Can I weld, cut and bend these sheets?
Each maker states its own processes. The KickFry sheet states compatibility with welding, cutting, drilling, bending and painting. The XIOBTQT sheets state they can be welded, cut, bent and painted. Both WENHUALI packs state welding, cutting, drilling, bending and painting, and the Yaocom sheet states easy formability with welding and cutting.
How do I keep cold rolled sheet from rusting?
Both WENHUALI packs state a protective oil coating, and the maker of the pre-drilled plates advises applying a finish or coating after use to avoid rusting. The KickFry sheet states a rust-resistant treatment with no additional coatings needed. Store sheet flat and dry between jobs.
What size sheet should I order?
Stated sizes run from 12 x 6 inches on both WENHUALI packs to 12 x 18 inches on the Yaocom sheet, with the KickFry sheet at 12 x 9 inches and the XIOBTQT sheets at 12 x 16 inches. Lay your largest part against the stated size, and count the pack quantity stated for each pick.
Related: best circular saw blade for sheet metal, how to flux core weld sheet metal, sheet metal weight calculator, and the knife making and casting hub.
Scoring, line by line
Each sheet is scored on performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty, with the weights published on our How We Pick page. Sheet metal has no electrical safety listing to state, and no maker here states a warranty term, so every sheet scores zero on those criteria; the ranking comes from performance, build and value.
| Product | Gear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| XIOBTQT 12 x 16 18 Gauge | 9.7 | 30 | 21 | 22 | n/a | 0 |
| Yaocom 12 x 18 16 Gauge | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
| KickFry 12 x 9 | 9.6 | 28 | 20 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
| WENHUALI 12 x 6 Pre-Drilled | 9.5 | 27 | 20 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
| WENHUALI 12 x 6 | 9.5 | 27 | 19 | 19 | n/a | 0 |
Think of 9.2 as the bottom and 9.8 as the top. Totals are placed between them in proportion, which keeps the order intact: more points, higher score. Safety is only scored for powered machines or when a listing names safety features; otherwise it drops out and the score is worked from the other 90 points.




