Best Soapstone Holder (2026): 5 Picks for Marking Steel
Five soapstone holders for welders, compared on flat and round soapstone, refills, holder material, pocket clips and warranty.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Best OverallVASTOOLS Soapstone Holder Set9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Most PiecesJOYFUL&HOPEFUL Round Soapstone Holder Set9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Best Round SetGutimore Round Soapstone Holder Pack9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Steel Holder PickForney 70802 Soapstone Holder9.5/10View on Amazon
A weld mark has to survive the heat. A soapstone holder keeps the stick of soapstone from snapping in a pocket or a toolbox, and it lets a welder put a clear white line on steel, aluminum or cast iron before the arc starts. This guide compares holders for the best soapstone holder, from flat and round sets with refills to a single steel holder with a pocket clip.
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
Quick picks
- Best Overall VASTOOLS Soapstone Holder Set: Flat and round holders in one set with 5 flat and 5 round refills, aluminum holders, and marks that stay clear through welding heat. Check price on Amazon
- Most Pieces JOYFUL&HOPEFUL Round Soapstone Holder Set: Three round holders plus 12 round refills, 15 pieces in all, with a threaded collar and a pocket clip. Check price on Amazon
- Best Round Set Gutimore Round Soapstone Holder Pack: Two round holders with 12 refills of 1/4 inch round, 5 inch soapstone in CNC aluminum holders that resist rust. Check price on Amazon
- Steel Holder Pick Forney 70802 Soapstone Holder: A single flat steel holder with a pocket clip, an adjustable channel, and the only stated warranty here, 90 days. Check price on Amazon
The machines

VASTOOLS Soapstone Holder Set
A flat and round holder set with 5 flat and 5 round soapstone refills, aluminum holders, and marks that stay clear through welding heat.
Pros
- Flat and round holders in one set, for different marking jobs
- 5 flat and 5 round refills included, 10 in all
- Aluminum holders, with soapstone that resists high temperature and water
- #1 grade soapstone with white, clear, removable marks
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- No pocket clip for carrying
- Two holders to keep track of, flat and round
- Flat and round refills each fit only their own holder

JOYFUL&HOPEFUL Round Soapstone Holder Set Pack
Three round holders with 12 round soapstone refills, 15 pieces in all, with a threaded collar and a pocket clip.
Pros
- Three round holders and 12 refills, 15 pieces in all
- 1/4 inch round soapstone, 5 inches long
- Threaded collar tightens the stone in place for adjustment
- Pocket clip for carrying and storage
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- Round holders only, no flat holder in the set
- No flat soapstone refills included
- Three holders and 12 refills to keep track of in the shop

Gutimore Soapstone Holder Pack of 14
Two round holders with 12 round soapstone refills in CNC aluminum holders, 1/4 inch round and 5 inches long.
Pros
- Two round holders and 12 refills, 14 pieces in all
- 1/4 inch round soapstone, 5 inches long
- Aluminum holders made by CNC process, rustproof
- Thread texture tightens the stone and helps prevent breakage
Cons
- Round holders only, no flat holder for flat plate
- No pocket clip for carrying
- No flat soapstone refills in the pack
- The pack holds 14 pieces, so spares need a pouch or box

Forney 70802 Flat Steel Soapstone Holder, Silver
A single flat steel holder with a pocket clip and an adjustable channel, and the only stated warranty here at 90 days.
Pros
- Flat steel holder with a pocket clip
- Adjustable channel design
- Weighs 0.4 lb
- 90 day warranty against manufacturer defects
Cons
- Only one holder in the pack
- No soapstone refills included
- Flat holder only, no round holder for round stock
- A single holder means no spare if it is lost

Gutimore Flat Soapstone Holder 2pcs with 12pcs
Two flat holders with soapstone refills in CNC aluminum, with a thumb slider and a brass button for adjusting the stone.
Pros
- Two flat holders in one purchase
- Aluminum holders made by CNC process
- Push thumb slider for easy movement and refilling
- Brass button adjusts the stone length with a thumb press
Cons
- Flat holders only, no round holder for round stock
- No pocket clip for carrying
- No round soapstone refills included
- Two holders to keep track of in the shop
Other welders and gear to compare
guti-more Gutimore Soapstone Holder Set Flat and Round HolderCheck price on Amazon
Gutimore Thin Flat Soapstone Holder 2pcsCheck price on Amazon
Soapstone Holder 4 Pcs Soapstone Pencil with 12 PcsCheck price on Amazon
Hobart 770087 Soapstone Holder with 4 RefillsCheck price on Amazon
Forney 70806 Soapstone HolderCheck price on Amazon
Spec sheet comparison
| Model | Gear Score | Holders | Refills | Soapstone size | Holder material | Pocket clip | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| VASTOOLS Soapstone Holder Set | 9.7/10 | 1 flat, 1 round | 10 | Not stated | Aluminum | Not stated | Not stated |
| JOYFUL&HOPEFUL Round Soapstone Holder Set | 9.6/10 | 3 round | 12 | 1/4 in round, 5 in long | Not stated | Yes | Not stated |
| Gutimore Round Soapstone Holder Pack | 9.6/10 | 2 round | 12 | 1/4 in round, 5 in long | Aluminum | Not stated | Not stated |
| Forney 70802 Soapstone Holder | 9.5/10 | 1 flat | Not stated | Not stated | Steel | Yes | 90 days |
| Gutimore Flat Soapstone Holder | 9.5/10 | 2 flat | 12 | Not stated | Aluminum | Not stated | Not stated |
All specs here repeat what the maker rates and the listing prints, copied down 18 November 2026.
Buying guide: the best soapstone holder
Flat or round soapstone
Flat soapstone suits flat plate and wide marks, while round soapstone suits round stock and tighter lines. The VASTOOLS set is the only one here with both a flat and a round holder. The Gutimore flat set and the Forney holder are flat only, and the JOYFUL&HOPEFUL set and the Gutimore round pack are round only. Match the shape to the stock marked most.
Holder material and grip
Three holders here are aluminum: the VASTOOLS set and both Gutimore sets, with the Gutimore holders made by a CNC process and described as rustproof, with a clear thread texture. The Forney holder is steel, with a pocket clip and an adjustable channel. A threaded collar on the JOYFUL&HOPEFUL set tightens the stone in place, and its holders have a pocket clip.
Refills and pack size
Refills decide how long a set lasts before another order. The VASTOOLS set includes 5 flat and 5 round refills, the JOYFUL&HOPEFUL set includes 12 round refills, and the Gutimore round pack includes 12 round refills. The Gutimore flat set includes 12 flat refills. The Forney holder is sold as a single holder with no refills listed. Count the holders and the refills together before choosing.
Marks that survive the weld
Soapstone marks have to stay visible through heat and still come off after. The VASTOOLS, Gutimore flat and JOYFUL&HOPEFUL sets all list #1 grade soapstone with white, clear, removable marks that resist high temperature and water and will not burn off during welding. The Gutimore round pack lists #1 Select Natural Grade soapstone with the same white, clear, removable marks. Check the mark against the metal and the heat of the job.
Weight and pocket carry
A holder rides in a pocket or a toolbox, so weight and a clip matter. The VASTOOLS set weighs 0.51 lb and the Forney holder weighs 0.4 lb. The Forney and JOYFUL&HOPEFUL holders have a pocket clip for carrying and storage. A clip keeps the holder in a pocket instead of loose in a toolbox.
Use as directed. Mark the work before striking an arc, and keep hands clear of the weld zone while marking. Wear eye protection when grinding or cutting near the mark, and keep the holder away from hot metal after the weld. See the OSHA welding overview and our Safety Disclaimer.
Before You Strike an Arc
- Check the holder against the soapstone shape, flat or round, before marking the work.
- Make sure the stone is tight in the holder, using the threaded collar, brass button or thumb slider.
- Mark a scrap piece of the same metal first, to check the line before marking the workpiece.
- Keep a spare refill in the toolbox, since a snapped stone stops the layout work.
- Check that the holder and the soapstone fit the job: flat plate takes a flat holder, round stock takes a round holder.
FAQ for welders
What is a soapstone holder?
A soapstone holder is a metal sleeve that grips a stick of soapstone for marking steel, aluminum and cast iron before welding or cutting. The holder keeps the soapstone from snapping and lets the welder adjust how much stone sticks out. Holders come in flat and round shapes to match flat and round soapstone.
Flat or round soapstone: which holder should I pick?
Pick the shape that matches the stock and the soapstone. Flat holders suit flat plate, and round holders suit round stock and tighter lines. The VASTOOLS set is the only one here with both shapes, while the other sets are flat only or round only.
Do soapstone marks come off after welding?
Yes. The marks here are listed as white, clear and removable, and the soapstone resists high temperature and water, so the marks stay visible through the weld and come off after. Wipe the mark off once the metal has cooled.
How do you adjust the soapstone in the holder?
It depends on the holder. The Gutimore flat set uses a push thumb slider and a brass button that adjusts the stone length with a thumb press. The JOYFUL&HOPEFUL set uses a threaded collar that tightens the stone in place, and the Gutimore round pack uses a thread texture for fastening.
Will a soapstone holder fit in a pocket?
Two holders here have a pocket clip: the Forney holder and the JOYFUL&HOPEFUL holders. The Forney holder measures 5.75 inches by 0.63 inches by 0.5 inches and weighs 0.4 lb. Check the holder size against the pocket before relying on the clip.
Related: layout tools, layout fluid vs soapstone, metal scribe vs soapstone marker, and best metal scribe. Also see our best scratch awl. Also see our center finder head. Also see our number and letter punch set. Also see our pipe layout tools. Also see our layout fluid blue. Also see our center finder punch. Also see our digital protractor tool.
Scoring, line by line
Each holder is scored out of 10 on performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty, with the weights published on the How We Pick page. Soapstone holders have no electrical safety listing to state, so every holder here scores zero on that criterion; the ranking comes from the other four.
| Product | Gear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| VASTOOLS Soapstone Holder Set | 9.7 | 30 | 22 | 21 | n/a | 0 |
| JOYFUL&HOPEFUL Round Soapstone Holder Set | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 22 | n/a | 0 |
| Gutimore Round Soapstone Holder Pack | 9.6 | 28 | 21 | 21 | n/a | 0 |
| Forney 70802 Soapstone Holder | 9.5 | 24 | 20 | 19 | n/a | 2 |
| Gutimore Flat Soapstone Holder | 9.5 | 27 | 20 | 20 | n/a | 0 |
A pick’s weighted total decides where it lands between a 9.2 floor and a 9.8 ceiling, and a bigger total never produces a smaller number. Safety points apply to gear that runs on power or lists safety features. Without either, we score out of 90 instead of 100.




