Stick vs Mig Welding Gloves: Which One Should You Buy?
Black Stallion stick gloves meet Lincoln and Superior MIG gloves on leather, liners, cuffs and levels, with the verdict up front on which side fits which job.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Lincoln Electric DynaMIG HD Professional MIG9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Black Stallion 750 Premium Grain Elkskin Stick9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Black Stallion9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Superior Glove Endura 399GKGL5 Leather MIG Work9.5/10View on Amazon
Verdict. In stick vs mig welding gloves, pick a stick glove for stick work where spatter, radiant heat and heavy leather matter, and pick a MIG glove for wire work where trigger control and dexterity matter, and pick the Superior when a stated cut or arc level matters. The stick gloves here lean on heavy leather with a lined back or a padded liner, while the MIG gloves here lean on dexterity features, with stated cut and arc levels on the Superior only.
A farm repair with a stick welder throws spatter and radiant heat at the hands, while a MIG job on sheet metal wants a steady trigger finger and a glove that lets the fingers work. That split is what stick vs mig welding gloves comes down to: stick gloves in these listings use heavy leather with a lined back or a padded liner, and MIG gloves use dexterity features, with stated cut and arc levels on the Superior only. This comparison puts the four listings side by side on leather, liner, cuff, stitching and levels.
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same.
The four gloves

Lincoln Electric DynaMIG HD Professional MIG
A Large MIG glove with a grain leather palm, seamless trigger finger, 3-layer FlameSoft top liner and 2-layer cotton bottom liner, plus a 4-inch split leather cuff.
Pros
- Grain leather palm with seamless trigger finger for dexterity
- 3-layer FlameSoft liner on top, 2-layer cotton liner underneath
- Foam padded liner gives cushioned knuckle protection
- Twill cotton cuff liner absorbs moisture; 4-inch split leather cuff resists heat and abrasion
Cons
- Large size only in this listing
- No cut level stated
- No arc flash level stated
- Warranty statement gives no term length

Black Stallion 750 Premium Grain Elkskin Stick
A Large stick glove in extra-thick grain elkskin with a Nomex-lined back, reversed grain palm, thumb strap and Kevlar stitching.
Pros
- Extra-thick grain elkskin resists heat, flame and abrasion
- Nomex-lined back shields against radiant heat and sparks
- Reversed grain palm improves grip with a softer feel
- Thumb strap strengthens a high-stress area; Kevlar stitching resists heat
Cons
- Warranty description reads No Warranty
- Large size only in this listing
- No cut level stated
- No arc flash level stated

Black Stallion
A Small stick glove in thick side split cowhide with a CushionCore foam padded liner, Kevlar thread and reinforced wear patches.
Pros
- Thick side split cowhide resists heat and abrasion
- CushionCore foam liner insulates and cushions with less hand fatigue
- Kevlar thread is heat- and cut-resistant at high-stress seams
- Reinforced patches and welted seams at high wear areas
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- Small size only in this listing
- No arc flash level stated

Superior Glove Endura 399GKGL5 Leather MIG Work
A Medium MIG glove in high tensile-strength goatskin with a ParaActiv yarn liner, extended gauntlet cuff, wing thumb, ASTM cut-level 4 and arc flash level 3.
Pros
- Goatskin gives outstanding abrasion resistance
- ASTM cut-level 4 with ParaActiv yarn liner for 360-degree cut protection
- Arc flash-rated level 3 with ATPV of 36 cal/cm²
- Extended gauntlet cuff and wing thumb for coverage and durability
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- Medium size only in this listing
- No Kevlar stitching stated
- No thermal liner described in the listing
Other welders and gear to compare
SAFEGEAR XX-Large Cowhide Leather Welding GlovesCheck price on Amazon
Caiman Premium Cow Grain MIG/Stick Welding GlovesCheck price on Amazon
Black Stallion Revco 850S FR Nomex Premium Stick WeldingCheck price on Amazon
Tillman 850 Gold Elk Skin Premium Welding Gloves-LCheck price on Amazon
Mechanix Wear Flux MIG Welding Gloves Leather Brown X-LargeCheck price on Amazon
Caiman Premium Wasabi Green Split Deerskin MIG/Stick WeldingCheck price on Amazon
Side by side
| Lincoln DynaMIG HD | Black Stallion 750 | Black Stallion 320 | Superior Endura 399 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gear Score | 72 | 71 | 70 | 68 |
| Side | MIG | Stick | Stick | MIG |
| Leather | Top grain and split leather | Extra-thick grain elkskin | Thick side split cowhide | High tensile-strength goatskin |
| Liner | 3-layer FlameSoft top, 2-layer cotton bottom | Nomex-lined back | CushionCore foam padded | ParaActiv yarn liner |
| Cuff | 4-inch split leather | Not stated | Not stated | Extended gauntlet |
| Stitching | Kevlar thread | Kevlar stitching | Kevlar thread | Not stated |
| Stated level | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | ASTM cut-level 4, arc level 3 |
| Size | Large | Large | Small | Medium |
| Weight | 0.25 Pounds (spec table) | 0.6 Pounds (spec table) | Left unclear (spec table lists 33.08 Pounds) | 0.44 Pounds (spec table) |
| Warranty | No term stated | No Warranty | No term stated | No term stated |
Ratings in this table are the makers’ own claims taken from each product page (3 November 2026). Where a listing leaves a figure unclear, the cards below say so.
Stick vs Mig Welding Gloves: What Separates the Two Sides
The stick side here is Black Stallion leather: extra-thick grain elkskin on the 750 and thick side split cowhide on the 320, with a Nomex-lined back on the 750 and a CushionCore foam padded liner on the 320. Both stick listings state Kevlar stitching or thread. The MIG side here splits two ways: the Lincoln leans on a grain leather palm, a seamless trigger finger and layered liners, while the Superior leans on goatskin plus stated cut and arc levels. Neither side wins on leather alone, since the listings share no leather measure; compare the leather words each listing uses, not a side label.
Liners tell the same story. The stick liners are about heat and padding: a Nomex-lined back against radiant heat and sparks, and a foam padded liner for cushioned comfort. The MIG liners are about hand work: a 3-layer FlameSoft top liner with a 2-layer cotton bottom liner on the Lincoln, and a ParaActiv yarn liner on the Superior. See the elkskin vs cowhide welding gloves comparison for the leather pair at the center of the stick side.
Liners and Dexterity
Dexterity features appear on both sides. The Lincoln pairs a grain leather palm with a seamless trigger finger, foam padded knuckle protection and an elastic top hand for a form fit, and its bottom hand liner is 2-layer cotton for dexterity. The Superior adds a wing thumb for durability and comfort. On the stick side, the 320 names dexterity directly: its CushionCore liner aims at improved dexterity for precision stick welding. The 750 instead stresses grip, with a reversed grain palm that gives a softer feel and improves grip. See the best welding gloves for dexterity roundup for more dexterity-first options.
Cuffs, Stitching and Levels
Cuff coverage is stated clearly only on the MIG side. The Lincoln has a 4-inch split leather cuff over a twill cotton cuff liner, and the Superior has an extended gauntlet cuff. Neither stick listing states a cuff length, so the comparison leaves cuff length unclear for the stick side rather than awarding it. Stitching follows a similar pattern: the 750, the 320 and the Lincoln all state Kevlar stitching or thread, while the Superior states no stitching; it describes a ParaActiv yarn liner. Levels belong to one glove only: the Superior states ASTM cut-level 4 and arc flash-rated level 3 with an ATPV of 36 cal/cm², while the other listings state heat and abrasion resistance in words, not levels.
Choose a stick glove if
- You weld stick and want heavy leather with a lined back or a padded liner.
- Radiant heat and spatter are the main hazards in your work.
- You want a Nomex-lined back or a CushionCore foam liner.
- Large or Small from these listings fits your hand.
Choose a MIG glove if
- You weld wire and want dexterity features: a trigger finger and form fit on the Lincoln, or a wing thumb on the Superior.
- A stated cut level matters for your work (the Superior states cut-level 4).
- A stated arc level matters for your work (the Superior states arc level 3).
- Medium or Large from these listings fits your hand.
FAQ for welders
Can stick gloves be used for MIG welding?
The listings do not address cross-process use: each listing names its own process, stick or MIG. Stick gloves here use heavy leather with a lined back or a padded liner for spatter and radiant heat, while MIG gloves here add dexterity features, with cut and arc levels stated on the Superior only. Match the glove to the process you weld most, and check the size, since the listings state Large, Small, Large and Medium.
What leather do these gloves use?
The 750 uses extra-thick grain elkskin, the 320 uses thick side split cowhide, the Lincoln uses top grain and split leather, and the Superior uses high tensile-strength goatskin. Each listing states its own leather, and no listing shares a leather measure with another.
Which gloves have Kevlar stitching?
The 750, the 320 and the Lincoln state Kevlar stitching or thread. The Superior states a ParaActiv yarn liner instead of Kevlar stitching.
Do any of these gloves carry a cut or arc level?
The Superior states ASTM cut-level 4 and arc flash-rated level 3 with an ATPV of 36 cal/cm². The other listings state heat and abrasion resistance in words and give no cut or arc level.
What sizes do these gloves come in?
The 750 is Large, the 320 is Small, the Lincoln is Large, and the Superior is Medium. Each listing states a single size, so check the size before ordering.
Related: best stick welding gloves, best MIG welding gloves, elkskin vs cowhide welding gloves, and the welding safety gear hub.
Scoring, line by line
All four gloves are scored on performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty.
| Product | Gear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lincoln DynaMIG HD | 9.6 | 32 | 21 | 20 | 8 | 0 |
| Black Stallion 750 | 9.6 | 30 | 21 | 20 | 8 | 0 |
| Black Stallion 320 | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | 8 | 0 |
| Superior Endura 399 | 9.5 | 28 | 20 | 19 | 9 | 0 |
The lowest score we show is 9.2 and the highest is 9.8; every point total is spread proportionally across that span, so extra points mean a higher figure.
Before you strike an arc. Wear a helmet with the right shade for the process and amperage, safety glasses underneath, leather gloves and flame resistant clothing. Weld with good ventilation, clear anything flammable from the area, and keep an extinguisher close.
- Check the listed size before ordering: the listings state Large, Small, Large and Medium across the four gloves.
- Check the stitching and reinforced areas on arrival.
- Check that the cuff covers the wrist gap for the process you weld.
- Check that the glove matches the process, stick or MIG, before striking an arc.




