Stick vs Tig Welding Gloves: Which One Should You Buy?
Elkskin stick gloves face goatskin and cowhide TIG gloves on length, leather, lining, stitching and warranty, from what each listing states.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Welding Gloves -Long Sleeve Fireproof and Heat9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Tillman Medium 11" Pearl and Black Top Grain9.5/10View on Amazon - 3
Tillman Large 14" Pearl Gray Premium Elkskin9.5/10View on Amazon - 4
Black Stallion (750) Premium Grain Elkskin Stick9.4/10View on Amazon
Verdict. Pick stick gloves for spatter and heat, pick TIG gloves for fit and filler rod feel. Of the 4 gloves here, the AOUCHI long sleeve cowhide glove scores highest on coverage and stated heat figures, while the Tillman TrueFit TIG glove is the close-fit pick for fine TIG work.
A stick rod throws spatter and heat at your hands, while a TIG torch asks for a steady hand and a light touch on the filler rod. That split is why stick vs tig welding gloves are not the same glove under different names: the stick side leads with a long lined glove, and the TIG side splits between a short close glove and a long lined one.
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
The 4 gloves

Welding Gloves -Long Sleeve Fireproof and Heat
A 15 inch cowhide glove with a cotton lining and Kevlar stitching, listed for TIG and MIG work and rated to 250°C (482°F), with a 1 year manufacturer warranty.
Pros
- 15 inch length with a long sleeve that covers the wrist and forearm
- 1.5 mm cowhide leather with a cotton lining for heat insulation
- Kevlar stitching, with the glove rated to 250°C (482°F)
- 6 sizes from XS to XXL, for men and women
Cons
- 1.5 mm leather trades fine filler rod feel for heat protection
- Listed for kitchen, garden and BBQ use as well as welding, so it is a general hot-work glove, not a TIG-only glove
- Long sleeve adds coverage but also adds bulk at the cuff
- 1 year manufacturer warranty only

Tillman Medium 11" Pearl and Black Top Grain
An 11 inch unlined goatskin TIG glove with Kevlar stretch inserts and Kevlar stitching, built for a close fit and filler rod control.
Pros
- Top grain goatskin with Kevlar stretch inserts for a close, flexible fit
- Unlined, so filler rod feel stays direct
- Kevlar thread locking stitch throughout
- Short cuff keeps the glove light at the wrist
Cons
- 11 inches is the lowest length stated of the 4 gloves
- No lining, so less heat insulation than the cotton lined gloves
- No warranty term is stated
- Medium size in this listing, with no other size stated here

Tillman Large 14" Pearl Gray Premium Elkskin
A 14 inch elkskin stick glove with a cotton/foam lining, welted fingers, a reinforced thumb and Kevlar stitching.
Pros
- 14 inch length with welted fingers for stick work
- Top grain pearl elkskin palm with a cotton/foam back and lining
- Kevlar thread locking stitch and reinforced thumb
- Rough side out palm for stinger grip
Cons
- Large size in this listing, so check the size range before ordering
- No warranty term is stated
- Cotton/foam lining adds warmth but also adds bulk
- Pull on closure, with no strap to adjust the fit

Black Stallion (750) Premium Grain Elkskin Stick
A premium grain elkskin stick glove in a 70% elkskin, 25% cowhide, 5% Nomex blend, with a flame resistant finish and a strap closure.
Pros
- 70% elkskin, 25% cowhide, 5% Nomex fabric blend
- Flame resistant finish stated
- Elkskin palm with added grip
- Strap closure to adjust the fit
Cons
- The listing states no warranty
- No glove length is stated
- Small size in this listing, so check the size range before ordering
- Heavyweight fabric class, heavier in hand than a medium weight glove
Other welders and gear to compare
Tillman 1338 Top Grain Goatskin TIG Welding Gloves with 4"Check price on Amazon
Caiman Premium Cow Grain MIG/Stick Welding GlovesCheck price on Amazon
Caiman Premium Wasabi Green Split Deerskin MIG/Stick WeldingCheck price on Amazon
Caiman Premium Goat Grain MIG/Stick Welding GlovesCheck price on Amazon
Miller 263340 Arc Armor Heavy Duty MIG Stick GoveCheck price on Amazon
Caiman Premium Split Cowhide MIG/Stick Welding GlovesCheck price on Amazon
Side by side
| Product | Gear Score | Glove length | Leather | Lining | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AOUCHI Long Sleeve Cowhide Gloves | 9.6/10 | 15 inches | Cowhide, 1.5 mm | Cotton | 1 year manufacturer |
| Tillman 1488M TrueFit TIG Gloves | 9.5/10 | 11 inches | Top grain goatskin | Unlined | Not stated |
| Tillman 750L Elkskin Stick Gloves | 9.5/10 | 14 inches | Top grain elkskin | Cotton/foam | Not stated |
| Black Stallion Elkskin Stick Glove | 9.4/10 | Not stated | Elkskin, cowhide, Nomex blend | Not stated | No warranty |
The comparison covers 4 gloves: 2 stick gloves with elkskin and 2 TIG gloves in goatskin and long cowhide. Ratings in this table are the makers’ own claims taken from each product page (20 October 2026). No listing here states a CSA, UL or ETL listing.
Stick vs Tig Welding Gloves: What Sets Them Apart
Length is the first split. The Tillman stick glove runs 14 inches, the AOUCHI TIG glove runs 15 inches with a long sleeve, and the Tillman TIG glove runs 11 inches with a short cuff. The Black Stallion stick glove states no glove length, so its coverage is unclear from the listing.
Leather is another split. Both stick gloves use elkskin: the Tillman in top grain pearl elkskin with a cotton/foam back, the Black Stallion in a blend of 70% elkskin, 25% cowhide and 5% Nomex. The TIG side splits the other way: the Tillman TIG glove uses top grain goatskin with Kevlar stretch inserts, and the AOUCHI glove uses 1.5 mm cowhide.
Lining is the last split. The Tillman stick glove has a cotton/foam lining, the AOUCHI glove has a cotton lining, and the Tillman TIG glove is unlined. The Black Stallion listing states no lining. The listings back the trade: the AOUCHI cotton lining is listed for heat insulation, and the unlined Tillman TIG glove is listed for filler rod control.
Stitching and cuffs
Kevlar stitching shows up on the Tillman stick glove, the Tillman TIG glove and the AOUCHI glove. The Tillman stick glove and the Tillman TIG glove both use a Kevlar thread locking stitch, and the AOUCHI glove uses heavy-duty Kevlar stitching. The Black Stallion listing names no stitching type.
Cuffs and closures differ glove by glove. The AOUCHI glove has a long sleeve, the Tillman TIG glove has a short cuff, and the Tillman stick glove pulls on with no strap. The Black Stallion glove has a strap closure, which adjusts the fit at the wrist. The Tillman TIG glove closes with elastic.
Warranty
Only the AOUCHI glove states a warranty term: 1 year manufacturer. The Black Stallion listing states no warranty. The Tillman stick glove and the Tillman TIG glove state no warranty term in their listings.
Choose stick gloves if
- Your work is stick welding, with spatter and heat at the glove.
- You want a long lined glove, like the 14 inch Tillman.
- You want a reinforced thumb and welted fingers for stick work.
- You want a strap closure to adjust the fit.
Choose TIG gloves if
- Your work is TIG welding, with filler rod control as the priority.
- You want a close unlined fit, like the 11 inch Tillman goatskin glove.
- You want long coverage with a stated heat figure, like the 15 inch AOUCHI glove.
- You weld TIG and MIG and want the same glove for both.
Before You Strike an Arc
- Check the size in the listing against your hand: Large, Small and Medium are all named here, so order the size the listing shows.
- Check the glove length covers your cuff before you strike an arc.
- Check the lining: the cotton and cotton/foam linings add insulation, and the unlined glove has no lining between your hand and the leather.
- Check the stitching and the thumb on arrival, since stick work wears those spots first.
- Keep a fire extinguisher close and clear flammable material from the work area.
Wear a helmet with the right shade for the process, safety glasses underneath, leather gloves and flame resistant clothing. Weld with good ventilation, clear anything flammable from the area, and keep an extinguisher close. See our welding safety gear checklist for beginners.
FAQ for welders
What is the difference between stick and TIG welding gloves?
The Tillman stick glove is 14 inches with a cotton/foam lining, and the Black Stallion glove uses an elkskin blend with a flame resistant finish and states no glove length. The two TIG gloves split: the Tillman TIG glove is 11 inches of unlined goatskin, while the AOUCHI glove is 15 inches of 1.5 mm cowhide with a cotton lining.
How long should a stick welding glove be?
No single length is stated across the listings here. The Tillman stick glove states 14 inches, and the Black Stallion stick glove states no glove length, so check the listing before ordering if length matters to you.
Do TIG gloves need a lining?
Not always. The Tillman TIG glove is unlined for the closest filler rod feel, while the AOUCHI glove has a cotton lining and a stated 250°C (482°F) figure. Pick the lined glove when the listing states the heat figure you need, and the unlined glove when filler rod feel comes first.
What leather are these gloves made from?
Elkskin on both stick gloves, goatskin on the Tillman TIG glove, and cowhide on the AOUCHI glove. The Black Stallion glove blends 70% elkskin with 25% cowhide and 5% Nomex.
Do any of these gloves carry a warranty?
The AOUCHI glove states a 1 year manufacturer warranty. The Black Stallion listing states no warranty, and the 2 Tillman listings state no warranty term.
Related: lined vs unlined welding gloves, goatskin vs sheepskin welding gloves, best welding gloves for a snug fit, and stick vs mig welding gloves.
Scoring, line by line
Each glove is scored on performance, build, value, safety and warranty, with the weights published on our How We Pick page.
| Product | Gear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AOUCHI Long Sleeve Cowhide Gloves | 9.6 | 29 | 21 | 20 | 3 | 2 |
| Tillman 1488M TrueFit TIG Gloves | 9.5 | 30 | 21 | 20 | 0 | 0 |
| Tillman 750L Elkskin Stick Gloves | 9.5 | 29 | 21 | 20 | 0 | 0 |
| Black Stallion Elkskin Stick Glove | 9.4 | 27 | 20 | 19 | 0 | 0 |
The lowest score we show is 9.2 and the highest is 9.8; every point total is spread proportionally across that span, so extra points mean a higher figure.




