Pull on vs Lace Up Welding Boots: Which One Should You Buy?
Pull-on boots step on fast and come off fast, while lace-ups let you tune the fit; 4 pull-on boots from Ariat, TAERDUN and Georgia Boot, compared for shop and farm work.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
GLANOUDUN Steel Toe Boots for Men High Top Safety Welding9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
SAFETOE Welding Boots for Men Composite Toe Safety Boots Fire9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Steel Toe Work Boots for Men Slip-on Welding Work Shoes Slip9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Ariat Men’s Groundbreaker Pull On Work BootView on Amazon - 5
CAT Men's Revolver Pull-on Steel Toe Construction BootView on Amazon - 6
TAERDUN Steel Toe Work Boots for Men Slip-on Chelsea BootView on Amazon - 7
Georgia Boot Men's Georgia Giant Pull-On Work BootsView on Amazon - 8
Georgia Boot Farm and Ranch Pull On Work BootView on Amazon - 9
Georgia Boot Men's Athens Pull-On Work BootsView on Amazon
Pull on vs lace up welding boots comes down to how the boot goes on and how it holds your foot through a shift. A pull-on boot steps on fast and comes off fast, with no laces to catch sparks or come undone. A lace-up boot takes longer to put on, but the laces let you pull the fit snug around the foot and ankle. This guide covers pull-on boots only, with no lace-up boot in the lineup, so the lace-up side comes from what the closure itself gives you, and the pull-on side comes from the boots below.
Other welders and gear to compare
Ariat Men’s Groundbreaker Pull On Work BootCheck price on Amazon
CAT Men's Revolver Pull-on Steel Toe Construction BootCheck price on Amazon
TAERDUN Steel Toe Work Boots for Men Slip-on Chelsea BootCheck price on Amazon
Georgia Boot Men's Georgia Giant Pull-On Work BootsCheck price on Amazon
Georgia Boot Farm and Ranch Pull On Work BootCheck price on Amazon
Georgia Boot Men's Athens Pull-On Work BootsCheck price on Amazon
This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
Side by side
| Model | Closure | Toe | Weight | Water |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Georgia Boot G5353 Giant Pull-On | Pull-On | Steel Toe | 5.3 pounds | Not Water Resistant |
| TAERDUN 414 Steel Toe Chelsea | Slip-On | Steel Toe | Not stated | Water Resistant |
| Ariat Groundbreaker Pull On | Pull-On | Round Toe | 2 pounds | Water Resistant |
| Georgia Boot G4432 Farm and Ranch Pull On | Pull-On | Soft Toe | 1.5 pounds | Not Water Resistant |
The boots in this guide are all pull-on, so the table above lists the pull-on side only, and the lace-up advice comes from the closure, not from a lace-up boot in the lineup. Pull-on boots win on speed: step in, pull up, and go. Lace-up boots win on fit: laces tune the boot around the foot and the ankle.
The gear
Georgia Boot G5353 Giant Pull-On. Steel toe, wedge heel and electrical-hazard protection, with a leather upper, a rubber sole and soft insole cushioning at a moderate level. It weighs 5.3 pounds, stands mid-calf, and states Not Water Resistant.
TAERDUN 414 Steel Toe Chelsea. Steel toe, slip-on Chelsea, leather upper and a thermoplastic polyurethane sole. It is an ASTM safety boot, stated as lightweight, with a mid-top ankle shaft.
Ariat Groundbreaker Pull On. Round toe, leather upper, rubber sole and block heel, with a faux leather lining and an 11.5 inch shaft. It weighs 2 pounds, stands mid-calf, and states Water Resistant.
Georgia Boot G4432 Farm and Ranch Pull On. Soft toe, leather upper, rubber sole and foam insole, with an 11 inch shaft and a 15 inch shaft circumference. It weighs 1.5 pounds, stands mid-calf, and states Not Water Resistant.
Pull on vs lace up welding boots: which one should you buy
Buy pull-on if the boot comes off between jobs: stepping out of the shop, driving home, or kicking the boots off at the door. Buy lace-up if the fit matters more than the speed: long shifts on uneven ground, a narrow foot, or an ankle that needs a snug hold. The steel toe choice sits apart from the closure: the G5353 and the TAERDUN 414 state a steel toe, while the Ariat Groundbreaker is a round toe and the G4432 is a soft toe. For welding work with falling metal, pick a steel toe; for farm and ranch chores without that risk, a soft toe saves weight.
When pull-on is the better choice
- Fast on and off. Step in and go, with no laces to tie, retie or replace.
- Dirty work. No laces to cake with mud, slag or grease.
- Short jobs. In and out of the boots between the shop and the truck.
- Wide calves. The Ariat and the G4432 state a 15 inch shaft circumference, the widest stated here.
When lace-up is the better choice
- Snug fit. Laces pull the boot tight around the foot and ankle, which cuts heel slip on ladders or uneven ground.
- Long shifts. A fit you can tune through the day beats a fixed shaft when the boot stays on for hours.
- Ankle support. Laces hold the ankle snug on rough ground and stairs.
- Narrow feet. Laces take up the slack a fixed pull-on shaft cannot.
How to pick your size
Check the heel-to-toe figure for your size before ordering: each size has its own figure, and the same size runs longer in one boot than in another. Pull-on boots need a shaft that fits the calf, so check the shaft circumference too: the Ariat and the G4432 state 15 inches. A boot that fits the foot but pinches the calf will sit in the closet.
FAQ for welders
Do pull-on welding boots stay on while you work?
Yes, when the shaft fits the calf: the Ariat and the G4432 state a 15 inch shaft circumference, and the G5353 uses an elastic strap to hold the fit. A loose shaft slips at the heel, so check the circumference before ordering.
Are steel toe boots required for welding?
No rule in this guide requires one, but the G5353 and the TAERDUN 414 state a steel toe, and the G5353 adds electrical-hazard protection. The Ariat Groundbreaker is a round toe and the G4432 is a soft toe. Match the toe to the work: falling metal calls for steel, while farm chores suit a soft toe.
What is the difference between a steel toe and a soft toe?
A steel toe guards the toes against falling metal, while a soft toe has no steel cap and weighs less. The G5353 and the TAERDUN 414 state a steel toe; the G4432 states a soft toe and weighs 1.5 pounds, and the Ariat Groundbreaker states a round toe and weighs 2 pounds.
Are these boots water resistant?
The Ariat Groundbreaker states Water Resistant, and the TAERDUN states water resistant as well. The G5353 and the G4432 state Not Water Resistant. Check before ordering, and keep leather uppers clean and dry.
How heavy are these boots?
The G4432 weighs 1.5 pounds, the Ariat Groundbreaker weighs 2 pounds, and the G5353 weighs 5.3 pounds. Weight varies by size, so check the figure for your size before ordering.
Related: steel toe vs soft toe welding boots, high top vs low top welding boots, leather vs rubber welding boots, and the welding safety boots guide.




