Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Pigskin vs Goatskin Welding Gloves: Which One Should You Buy?

Pigskin vs goatskin welding gloves explained for welders, with four pigskin gloves ranked.

Pigskin vs Goatskin Welding Gloves: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Wells Lamont TIG Welding GlovesWells Lamont TIG Welding Gloves9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Tillman 1338 Top Grain Goatskin TIG Welding Gloves with 4"Tillman 1338 Top Grain Goatskin TIG Welding Gloves with 4"9.5/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Tillman Large Brown Top Grain Pigskin CottonFoam LinedTillman Large Brown Top Grain Pigskin CottonFoam LinedView on Amazon
  4. 4Tillman X-Large Brown Top Grain Pigskin CottonFoam LinedTillman X-Large Brown Top Grain Pigskin CottonFoam LinedView on Amazon
  5. 5Tillman 45 Top Grain Pigskin Foam Lined MIG Welding GlovesTillman 45 Top Grain Pigskin Foam Lined MIG Welding GlovesView on Amazon
  6. 6Tillman 30 Top Grain Pigskin TIG Welding GlovesTillman 30 Top Grain Pigskin TIG Welding GlovesView on Amazon
  7. 7Black StallionBlack StallionView on Amazon

Pigskin vs goatskin welding gloves is the leather question for your hands. Pigskin is tough, abrasion resistant and holds up to MIG and stick sparks; goatskin is thinner and more supple, which suits TIG and precision work. All four gloves below are pigskin, so this guide explains both leathers and ranks the pigskin examples by what each listing states.

Other welders and gear to compare

This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The difference in one paragraph

Pigskin has a naturally textured, porous hide that stays soft while resisting abrasion, which is why the listings here pair it with cowhide for heat resistance and grip. For hot, spark-heavy welding, pigskin is the workhorse; for TIG and detail work, goatskin earns its place.

Side by side

Pigskin Goatskin Verdict
Feel Soft, flexible, textured palm Supple, thin, dexterous Goatskin
Abrasion and wear Resists abrasion, lasts in rough work Thinner Pigskin
Welding heat Used in welding gloves for heat and sparks Fine for TIG, less for heavy sparks Pigskin
Dexterity Good, thicker Better, thinner Goatskin
Best for MIG, stick, grinding TIG, precision work Depends on process

The table above is the general trade-off. Every listing below is pigskin, so compare them on construction, length, stated resistance and warranty instead.

When pigskin is the better choice

  • MIG and stick. Heavy spatter and grinding sparks favor pigskin, and all four listings here name welding as the use.
  • Rough handling. The HANDLANDY lists a reinforced palm for welding, farm and gardening; the BSX pairs pigskin with cowhide for abrasion and grip.
  • Heat near the cuff. The BSX Gear and Black Stallion both state flame resistance.

When goatskin is the better choice

  • Light duty. Driving, inspection and handling where dexterity beats durability.
  • Note. None of the four listings here is goatskin; shop goatskin separately for TIG work.

Pigskin vs goatskin welding gloves: four pigskin picks, ranked

1. HANDLANDY 2-Pack Work Gloves

The HANDLANDY is a 2-pack of leather work gloves with a genuine full grain pigskin palm, stated nature tanning, durability and abrasion resistance, at 0.19 kg. It lists a reinforced palm for welding, farm, gardening and driving, a relaxed fit, breathability and water resistance. The fabric type field says cowhide leather against the pigskin material; trust the material features. The warranty description is 30 Days. Who it suits: a welder who wants two pairs for shop and farm.

2. Black Stallion Angelfire Stick Glove

The Black Stallion is a women’s stick glove with a premium grain pigskin palm and a split cowhide back, 50% pigskin and 50% cowhide, at 8.8 oz. It states flame resistance, abrasion resistance and Kevlar stitching, in X-small, black with beige flourish. No warranty is stated. Who it suits: stick welders who want a flame resistant pigskin glove.

3. BSX Gear BM88 MIG Glove

The BSX Gear BM88 is a MIG welding glove in premium grain pigskin, at 0.26 kg and 9.14 oz, in small, yellow. It states a soft and flexible pigskin with durable and heat-resistant cowhide, flame resistance and water resistance. The size field says Small (Pack of 2) against a unit count of 1; trust the unit count. No warranty term is stated. Who it suits: MIG welders who want a soft pigskin glove.

4. BSX Pigskin Welding Glove

The BSX is a pigskin welding glove, 12.5 in long, in medium, black, at 9.6 oz. It has a pigskin palm, described as soft pigskin with durable cowhide for heat resistance and grip, plus cut resistance. The size field says Medium (Pack of 2) against a unit count of 1; trust the unit count. No warranty term is stated. Who it suits: a welder who wants a long cuff with cut resistance.

What to check before you buy

Match the process: pigskin for MIG and stick, goatskin for TIG. Check the length: 12.5 in on the BSX against work-glove lengths on the others. Only the HANDLANDY states a warranty term, 30 Days; the Black Stallion states no warranty and the two BSX listings state no term. And remember: leather gloves protect against heat and sparks within their rating, never against arc flash alone. See our cowhide vs pigskin welding gloves comparison.

Glove heat limits. Leather resists heat but does not make you invincible: hot metal conducts through any glove given time. Wear the right glove for the process, keep flammables off the bench, and check gloves for holes before you strike an arc. See the OSHA welding overview.

Fit, care and box contents

Fit decides whether the glove works. The listings state a range of fits: the HANDLANDY is a relaxed fit, the BSX pigskin is regular, the BSX MIG is slim, and the Black Stallion is regular in X-Small only. All four are ambidextrous pull-on gloves. The BSX pigskin spec table gives a hand circumference chart (M men 8-9 in); measure your hand and match it rather than guessing a letter size.

Check the cuff length for your process. The BSX pigskin is 12.5 in long for forearm protection against sparks; the others are work-glove lengths. If you do overhead stick work, the longer cuff matters more than leather choice.

Read the care and count lines. All four listings state hand wash care. The HANDLANDY is a 2-pair box, which suits shop and farm use; both BSX listings read “Pack of 2” in the size field against a unit count of 1, so trust the unit count of 1. The Black Stallion stitches with Kevlar and states flame resistance, the same flame resistance the BSX listings state.

Water resistance splits the field. The HANDLANDY and the BSX MIG state water resistant; the BSX pigskin and the Black Stallion state not water resistant. A water resistant glove still needs hand washing and air drying per the care lines, and wet leather should be dried slowly, not on a hot surface.

Only the HANDLANDY states a warranty term, 30 Days; the Black Stallion states No Warranty and the two BSX listings state no term. For a consumable glove that wears at the palm, the 2-pair box of the HANDLANDY is the practical backup.

FAQ for welders

Is pigskin or goatskin better for welding?

For MIG, stick and grinding, pigskin: it resists abrasion and heat better. For TIG and precision work, goatskin’s thinness wins on dexterity.

Which of these state a warranty?

Only the HANDLANDY, a 30 Days term. The Black Stallion states no warranty and the two BSX listings state no term.

Are any of these goatskin?

No. All four listings here are pigskin; goatskin gloves are a separate shop.

Which is the longest glove here?

The BSX pigskin welding glove at 12.5 in. The others are work-glove lengths.

Related: the best welding gloves for beginners, our cowhide vs pigskin welding gloves comparison and our deerskin vs goatskin welding gloves guide.

More buying guides