Deerskin vs Pigskin Welding Gloves: Which Should You Buy? (2026)
Deerskin vs pigskin welding gloves explained: softness vs abrasion resistance, with three deerskin and cow grain gloves from the listings.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Wells Lamont TIG Welding Gloves9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
John Tillman and Co Tillman Large 14" Gold and Pearl Top9.5/10View on Amazon - 3
Caiman Premium Wasabi Green Split Deerskin MIG/Stick WeldingView on Amazon - 4
Caiman Premium Split Deerskin MIG/Stick Welding GlovesView on Amazon - 5
Black Stallion 25D-BLK Premium Deerskin TIG Welding GlovesView on Amazon - 6
Caiman Wasabi Green DeerskinView on Amazon
In the deerskin vs pigskin welding gloves debate, deerskin is softer and more flexible while pigskin is tougher and more abrasion-resistant. Pick deerskin for TIG and light MIG work where feel matters, and pick pigskin for heavy stick welding and grinding where the glove takes abuse. Both are leather, both burn eventually, and neither replaces a proper welding jacket and helmet.
Other welders and gear to compare
Caiman Premium Wasabi Green Split Deerskin MIG/Stick WeldingCheck price on Amazon
Caiman Premium Split Deerskin MIG/Stick Welding GlovesCheck price on Amazon
Black Stallion 25D-BLK Premium Deerskin TIG Welding GlovesCheck price on Amazon
Caiman Wasabi Green DeerskinCheck price on Amazon
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
What deerskin gives you
Deerskin is among the softest common glove leathers: it conforms to the hand, stays flexible when new and gives fine finger control for TIG torches and filler rod. The Caiman 1816-5 is split deerskin for MIG and stick with full sock-insulation in FR foam and fleece, a large pulse protector over the wrist and forearm, and Kevlar stitching. It is 10.4 oz in large, heavyweight class, water resistant, with a wing thumb and pull-on fit. The Tillman 25BM is pearl split deerskin at 5.6 oz, lightweight class, with a deerskin and cowhide cuff, straight thumb and pull-on fit. Both state ANSI/ISEA heat level 2 on the Caiman models.
What pigskin gives you
In general, pigskin is denser and more abrasion-resistant than deerskin. None of the three listings here is pigskin, so compare the deerskin examples against whatever a pigskin listing states. The trade is always the same: pigskin gives up some of deerskin’s softness for longer life under grinding sparks and rough handling.
Cow grain: the middle ground
The Caiman 1828 is cow grain leather for TIG and MIG: generally tougher than deerskin and more flexible than pigskin, at 6.4 oz with Kevlar stitching, a reinforced palm, padded vibration dampening and a hook-and-loop closure. It is unlined, medium weight class, with a straight thumb and a classic fit. For a welder who does both TIG and MIG, cow grain splits the difference between the two leathers in the keyword.
Heat, insulation and lining
Insulation matters more than leather choice for heat. The Caiman 1816-5 has full sock-insulation with FR foam and fleece plus a cotton and aerofoam liner; the 1828 is unlined; the Tillman 25BM lists no liner. The 1816-5 also states heat-resistant and cut-resistant material features with a double-stitched palm, wear patches and a pulse protector. Both Caiman models state ANSI/ISEA heat level 2. For hot stick work, pick the insulated glove; for TIG feel, pick the unlined one.
Fit and sizing
The Caiman 1816-5 uses a Kontour design with 3-dimensional pre-curved fingers for a form-fitting shape; the 1828 is a classic fit with good fit sentiment; the Tillman 25BM is regular fit with neutral sentiment. Sizes run 4XS to 2XL on the Caiman line; the 1816-5 here is large, the 1828 X-large, the Tillman medium. A glove that is too loose folds and catches; too tight and it splits at the seams. The Kevlar stitching on both Caiman models resists heat damage at the seams.
Glove advice for the listings
Fit and weight
Weight tracks thickness: the Caiman 1816-5 at 10.4 oz is the heaviest and most insulated, the Caiman 1828 at 6.4 oz is the middle ground, and the Tillman 25BM at 5.6 oz is the lightest. A glove that is too thick for TIG costs you arc control; a glove that is too thin for stick costs you burns. Try the size before buying if the listing offers sizing: leather stretches little, and a loose glove folds into the arc.
Insulation and heat
The Caiman 1816-5 states FR foam and fleece insulation plus a pulse protector: the only insulated glove here, and the pick for stick welding and cold shops. The Caiman 1828 is unlined; the Tillman 25BM is lightweight deerskin with a cowhide cuff. Unlined gloves give better feel; insulated gloves give longer heat protection. Match the insulation to the process: stick and MIG run hotter on the hands than TIG.
Stitching and reinforcement
Both Caiman models state Kevlar stitching; the Tillman states none. The Caiman 1828 adds a reinforced palm; the 1816-5 adds the pulse protector. Stitching is where gloves fail first: heat rots cotton thread, so the Kevlar stitching on the Caiman pair is a real durability feature, not decoration.
Leather care
All three are hand wash only. Leather gloves last longer when they dry away from direct heat: hang them, do not bake them on the welder. The Tillman 25BM weighs 5.6 oz and the Caiman 1816-5 weighs 10.4 oz with FR foam and fleece insulation. Both Caiman models state a 30 day limited warranty; the Tillman states no warranty term.
[wgl_safety kind=”ppe”]
Deerskin vs pigskin welding gloves: the gear in the listings
The Caiman 1816-5 (split deerskin, 10.4 oz, FR foam and fleece insulation, pulse protector, Kevlar stitching, 30 day limited warranty) is the heavy-duty deerskin pick for MIG and stick. The Caiman 1828 (cow grain, 6.4 oz, unlined, reinforced palm, Kevlar stitching, 30 day limited warranty) is the TIG and MIG middle ground. The Tillman 25BM (pearl split deerskin, 5.6 oz, lightweight, deerskin and cowhide cuff, no stated warranty term) is the light deerskin pick.
Warranty and care
Both Caiman models state a 30 day limited warranty; the Tillman gives only a generic warranty line, which is not a term. All three are hand wash only. Leather gloves last longer when they dry away from direct heat: hang them, do not bake them on the welder.
FAQ for welders
Is deerskin or pigskin better for TIG?
Deerskin: its softness gives the finger control TIG needs. The Tillman 25BM at 5.6 oz is the lightest deerskin here.
Which leather lasts longest?
Pigskin generally outlasts deerskin under abrasion, though none of the listings here is pigskin. Of the three, the insulated Caiman 1816-5 has the most reinforcement.
Do these gloves have Kevlar stitching?
Both Caiman models state Kevlar stitching; the Tillman 25BM states none.
Which of these states a warranty?
Both Caiman models state a 30 day limited warranty. The Tillman states no warranty term.
Related: our welding safety gear hub, the best TIG welding gloves and our best welding jacket for beginners guide.




