Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Mig vs Stick for Thick Steel: Which One Should You Buy?

A 6011 stick rod lists deep penetration on carbon steel; an ER70S-6 MIG wire lists construction and farm fabrication. Four listings compared for thick steel work.

Mig vs Stick for Thick Steel: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1035" V Groove Drive Roll Kit Compatible with Miller035" V Groove Drive Roll Kit Compatible with Miller9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Hobart 770460 6011 StickHobart 770460 6011 StickView on Amazon
  3. 3DEWALT 14 oz. Steel Mig Weld Hammer DWHT51138XDEWALT 14 oz. Steel Mig Weld Hammer DWHT51138XView on Amazon
  4. 4Mig Welding Wire ER70S-6 .030"Mig Welding Wire ER70S-6 .030"View on Amazon
  5. 5Stainless Steel 316L MIG Welding Wire 2 Ibs .035" 1 RollStainless Steel 316L MIG Welding Wire 2 Ibs .035" 1 RollView on Amazon
  6. 6ER70S-6 .023 In MIG Welding Wire 11 LBS Mild Steel MIG WireER70S-6 .023 In MIG Welding Wire 11 LBS Mild Steel MIG WireView on Amazon
  7. 7Millermatic® 211 PRO MIG Welder MachineMillermatic® 211 PRO MIG Welder MachineView on Amazon

Mig vs stick for thick steel comes down to what the consumable lists. A 6011 stick rod lists deep penetration on carbon steel at 60,000 PSI. An ER70S-6 MIG wire lists construction work and farm implement fabrication. This guide compares the stick and MIG consumables and the support gear listed with them, so you can see what each one actually states.

Other welders and gear to compare

This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Mig vs stick for thick steel: the short version

The listings give you one stick option and one MIG wire option for heavy work. The Hobart 6011 is a 1/8 inch stick electrode in a 10 pound box, listed for deep penetration on carbon steel, running on AC or DCEP. The Rumvita ER70S-6 is a .030 inch MIG wire on a 33 pound spool, listed for single or multi-pass welds with low splatter, used with 100% CO2 or a CO2/Argon mix. The other two listings are support gear: a 14 ounce steel MIG weld hammer and a practice kit for MIG, TIG and stick.

Side by side

Aspect Stick: Hobart 6011 MIG: Rumvita ER70S-6 Support gear listed
Consumable 1/8 in, 10 lb box .030 in, 33 lb spool DEWALT 14 oz hammer
Listed rating 60,000 PSI, deep penetration AWS A5.18, low splatter SONNLER kit, 1 yr warranty
Power / gas AC or DCEP 100% CO2 or CO2/Argon Not applicable
Listed uses Carbon steel Construction, farm, tanks Practice: MIG, TIG, Stick

When the stick listing fits

The Hobart 6011 lists “deep penetration on carbon steel” right in the title, with a 60,000 PSI rating. It runs on AC or DCEP, which the listing states. The 1/8 inch size in a 10 pound box is the only size the listing gives. The DEWALT listing titles it a “Steel Mig Weld Hammer”, 14 ounces, with an alloy steel head and handle.

Buying advice from the listing: the Hobart 6011 comes as model 770460, a 1/8 inch rod in a 10 pound box. The listing states it runs on AC or DCEP, so check that your machine offers one of those settings before you buy. The package measures 14.5 by 4.25 by 2.75 inches, which is the shipping box, not the rod length. The listing does not state a maximum steel thickness, so do not read the 60,000 PSI figure as a thickness rating. If your machine only runs DCEN, this rod is not listed for it.

When the MIG wire listing fits

The Rumvita ER70S-6 lists .030 inch wire on a 33 pound spool, conforming to AWS A5.18. The listing names applications: construction work, farm implement fabrication, shaft buildup, tanks, truck bodies and general shop applications “with poor fit-up or rusty, oily plates”. It lists higher manganese and silicon than other standard grades, and low splatter with little to zero post-weld cleanup. Shielding gas is 100% CO2 or a CO2/Argon mix, per the listing.

Buying advice from the listing: the wire is .030 inch (0.8 mm) on a 33 pound spool that measures 10 by 10 by 5 inches, so check that your welder accepts a spool that size before you order. The listing states the wire contains higher levels of manganese and silicon than other standard grades, which it ties to welding through rust and oil on poor fit-up. It lists 100% CO2 or a CO2/Argon mix for shielding gas but states no mix ratio, so confirm the ratio with your gas supplier. The listed applications, farm implement fabrication and shaft buildup, are the thick-steel jobs this wire is named for.

What the listings do not state

None of the four listings states a safety certification, so compare them on stated specs alone. The Hobart listing does not state a maximum thickness for the 6011 rod. The Rumvita listing does not state a CO2/Argon mix ratio. The DEWALT hammer listing does not describe its use beyond the title; the spec table lists “14OZ STL Nail Hammer” as an included component, which contradicts the “Steel Mig Weld Hammer” title, so the title is the safer read. The SONNLER spec table lists the material as Aluminum while the title says Stainless Steel; again, the title and bullets win. The practice kit states a warranty term: 1 year.

Gear for the job

Two consumables cover the two processes, with two support listings alongside them. The Hobart 6011 stick electrodes: a 1/8 inch rod in a 10 pound box, listed for deep penetration on carbon steel at 60,000 PSI, running AC or DCEP. The Rumvita ER70S-6 MIG wire: .030 inch on a 33 pound spool, AWS A5.18, listed for construction and farm fabrication with 100% CO2 or CO2/Argon. The SONNLER welding practice kit: 2.36 inch coupons listed for MIG, TIG, STICK and ARC training, with a 1 year warranty stated. The DEWALT 14 ounce MIG weld hammer: a steel hammer. None of the four lists a safety certification; the practice kit lists a warranty term.

On the support gear: the DEWALT 14 ounce hammer lists an alloy steel head and handle with a contoured grip, measuring 15 by 6.6 by 3.3 inches and weighing 14 ounces. The spec table lists 0.25 kg against the 14 ounce title; the title is the safer read. The listing does not state a chipping face, so read it as a general shop hammer rather than a dedicated slag hammer. The SONNLER practice kit lists 2.36 inch coupons and states it makes 1 dice and 1 cube for MIG, TIG, STICK and ARC training. It states a warranty term of 1 year.

FAQ for welders

What does the 6011 listing state for thick steel?

The Hobart listing states “deep penetration on carbon steel” with a 60,000 PSI rating, in 1/8 inch size. It runs on AC or DCEP. The listing does not state a maximum thickness.

What gas does the ER70S-6 wire need?

The Rumvita listing states 100% CO2 or a CO2/Argon mix. It does not state a ratio for the mix.

What does the DEWALT listing state?

The listing titles it a 14 ounce Steel Mig Weld Hammer with an alloy steel head and handle and a contoured grip. The listing does not describe its use.

What is the practice kit for?

The SONNLER listing is a practice kit with 2.36 inch coupons, listed for MIG, TIG, STICK and ARC training. The listing states a 1 year warranty. Note the spec table lists the material as Aluminum while the title says Stainless Steel; the title and bullets are the safer read.

What size spool does the Rumvita wire come on?

The listing states a 33 pound spool measuring 10 by 10 by 5 inches, wound with .030 inch (0.8 mm) wire. Check that your welder accepts a spool that size.

What does the Hobart 6011 box contain?

The listing states 1/8 inch stick electrodes in a 10 pound box, model 770460, listed for deep penetration on carbon steel at 60,000 PSI, running on AC or DCEP.

Related: flux core vs MIG for thick steel, best MIG wire for thick steel, MIG vs stick for pipe welding, flux core vs stick for farm repairs, and the MIG welders hub.

More buying guides