Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Mig vs Stick for Mild Steel: Which One Should You Buy?

MIG and stick both weld mild steel, but they differ on shielding, wind, cleanup and thin sheet work, and the right pick depends on the job on the bench.

Mig vs Stick for Mild Steel: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1035" V Groove Drive Roll Kit Compatible with Miller035" V Groove Drive Roll Kit Compatible with Miller9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2ARCCAPTAIN MIG Welding Wire ER70S-6 .045" 2LB x 1 Smooth WireARCCAPTAIN MIG Welding Wire ER70S-6 .045" 2LB x 1 Smooth WireView on Amazon
  3. 3ER70S-6ER70S-6View on Amazon
  4. 433 lb Roll ER70S-6 0.035" Mild Steel Mig Welding Wire33 lb Roll ER70S-6 0.035" Mild Steel Mig Welding WireView on Amazon
  5. 5MIG Solid Welding WireMIG Solid Welding WireView on Amazon
  6. 6Hot Max 22082 .025-Inch Mild Steel MIG WireHot Max 22082 .025-Inch Mild Steel MIG WireView on Amazon
  7. 7BIG RED Solid MIG Welding Wire: ER70S-6 .030" 11LBSBIG RED Solid MIG Welding Wire: ER70S-6 .030" 11LBSView on Amazon

A mild steel repair on the bench, a gate frame or a trailer bracket, usually comes down to a question asked before any arc is struck: which process suits this joint, this metal and this place. For mig vs stick for mild steel, the short answer is that MIG suits clean, thin and indoor work, while stick suits outdoor, dirty and thicker work, and the rest of this guide shows why.

Other welders and gear to compare

This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The difference in one paragraph

Molten steel reacts with oxygen and nitrogen in the air, which makes a porous, weak weld. MIG protects the puddle with shielding gas from a cylinder, fed through the gun around solid wire that feeds continuously. Stick protects the puddle with flux coated on the rod itself, which burns to make shielding gas and leaves a layer of slag on the bead. No cylinder, no hose, no regulator, but slag to chip after every pass.

Side by side

MIG Stick Mild steel note
Shielding Gas from a cylinder around solid wire Flux coating on the rod Both shield the puddle from air
Gear beyond the welder Wire, cylinder, regulator, gas hose Electrodes and an electrode holder MIG needs a gas supply; stick needs rods
Wind and outdoor work Gas blows away, needs shelter Tolerates a breeze Outdoor fence and gate work favors stick
Dirty or rusty steel ER70S-6 tolerates moderate rust, oil or mill scale More forgiving Stick tolerates worse prep
Thin sheet Easier, cleaner small beads Harder, more heat and burn through Thin panels favor MIG
Spatter and cleanup No slag, less spatter Slag to chip, more spatter Visible work favors MIG
Fumes Less smoke More smoke Ventilation matters for both
Wire in this guide ER70S-6 solid wire, 0.023 to .045 inch Flux-coated electrodes Wire sizes in this guide

Gas choice and wire size follow the machine manual. The wires in this guide are ER70S-6 in .035 and .045 inch, and SÜA also lists 0.023 and 0.030 inch diameters.

When MIG is the better choice

  • Thin sheet and auto body. Lower heat and cleaner small beads make thin panels easier with less burn through.
  • Looks and cleanup. No slag to chip and less spatter to grind, which matters on visible work and furniture.
  • Indoor shop work. Less smoke than stick, though you still need ventilation.
  • Sheet metal and plate with moderate rust, oil or mill scale. SÜA ER70S-6 suits sheet metal and structural plate with moderate rust, oil or mill scale, with 100% CO2 and CO2/Argon mix shielding gases.

Our how to choose a MIG welder guide covers machines for this kind of work.

When stick is the better choice

  • Outdoor work. Fence posts, gates, trailers and equipment in a field. A breeze that ruins gas shielding affects stick less.
  • Rusty, painted or mill scale steel. Stick tolerates less than perfect prep better than solid wire.
  • No cylinder. You avoid buying or renting a cylinder and regulator, and there is nothing to refill.
  • Thicker steel. Stick suits heavier sections, where flux-coated rods handle thick joints without a gas supply.

mig vs stick for mild steel: the MIG wires in this guide

The top picks in this guide are the four solid ER70S-6 wires below, ranked from the fullest listing to the thinnest: the SÜA first, then ARCCAPTAIN, HIZONE and HYW.

SÜA ER70S-6, .045 inch, 44 lb

SÜA lists a copper-plated, layer wound ER70S-6 wire in .045 inch on a 44 lb spool, with 0.023, 0.030 and .035 inch diameters and 33 lb spools also listed. The listing names 100% CO2 and CO2/Argon mix shielding gases and the highest combination of manganese and silicon deoxidizers, and suits sheet metal, structural plate with moderate rust, oil or mill scale, construction work, farm implement fabrication, tanks, steel castings and forgings.

ARCCAPTAIN ER70S-6, .045 inch, 2 lb

ARCCAPTAIN lists a .045 inch ER70S-6 wire on a 2 lb spool with TÜV certification stated, manganese and silicon deoxidizers, smooth feeding, a stable arc, low spatter and clean weld beads for mild steel fabrication.

HIZONE ER70S-6, .035 inch, 2 lb

HIZONE lists a .035 inch ER70S-6 solid wire on a 2 lb spool for all position welding, including T-joints, butt welds and lap welds, individually vacuum packed and compatible with gas MIG welders. The spec table lists a tensile strength of 40000 psi. It is solid wire for mild steel, so there is no slag to chip.

HYW ER70S-6, .035 inch, 33 lb

HYW lists a 33 lb roll of .035 inch ER70S-6 wire that conforms to AWS A5.18-05, with a yield strength of 450 MPa and 30% elongation.

Can one machine do both?

Yes, on a multi-process machine that lists both MIG and stick, and that is the usual answer for a home shop that welds both thin indoor work and outdoor repairs. Check the listing for both processes before buying, since a machine sold as a MIG welder may run gas MIG, flux core or both, and a stick-only machine will not feed wire. See our best welder for beginners guide for starter machines.

MIG and stick smoke and slag. Both processes make smoke and fumes, and stick leaves hot slag that can flick off when you chip it. Weld with good ventilation or outdoors with your head out of the plume, wear safety glasses under the helmet when chipping, and clear dry grass and anything flammable from the area. Chain gas cylinders upright.

FAQ for welders

Is MIG or stick better for mild steel?

Neither wins everywhere. MIG wins on thin, clean and indoor work with less cleanup, while stick wins outdoors, on dirty metal and on thicker sections. Match the process to the joint, the metal and the place, not to a brand.

Can I weld mild steel with ER70S-6 wire?

Yes. All four wires in this guide are ER70S-6 solid wire for mild steel, in .035 and .045 inch, with the SÜA listing also naming 0.023 and 0.030 inch. ER70S-6 is the common copper-coated mild steel MIG wire for single or multiple pass welding.

Does MIG work outdoors in wind?

Poorly without shelter, because the shielding gas blows away from the puddle. Stick tolerates a breeze better, and self-shielded flux core is the gasless wire option for outdoor work. If the job must stay outside, shelter the arc or pick stick.

What wire size should I start with?

The wires in this guide come in .035 and .045 inch, and the SÜA listing also names 0.023 and 0.030 inch. Thinner wire suits thinner sheet, thicker wire suits heavier sections, and the machine manual and door chart give the starting range for each size. Check the spool size against the machine before ordering.

Do I need gas for MIG on mild steel?

Yes for solid wire. The SÜA listing names 100% CO2 and CO2/Argon mix shielding gases for ER70S-6. Gasless welding means self-shielded flux core wire instead, which needs a machine that lists flux core and leaves slag to chip.

Related: how to choose a MIG welder, best welder for beginners, best flux core welder, the MIG welders hub and the stick welders hub. Also see our welding consumables guides.

More buying guides