Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Tig vs Stick for Mild Steel: Which One Should You Buy?

TIG and stick both weld mild steel, but they differ on shielding, cleanup, outdoor work and the gear each needs, and the right choice follows the job.

Tig vs Stick for Mild Steel: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1YESWELDER 110V Tungsten Electrode SharpenerYESWELDER 110V Tungsten Electrode Sharpener9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Blue 0.040" TIG Tungsten ElectrodesBlue 0.040" TIG Tungsten ElectrodesView on Amazon
  3. 35-Lb ER70S-2 Mild Steel TIG Welding Rods 3/32"x36"5-Lb ER70S-2 Mild Steel TIG Welding Rods 3/32"x36"View on Amazon
  4. 45-Lb Mild Steel ER70S-6 TIG Welding Rods 0.045"x36"5-Lb Mild Steel ER70S-6 TIG Welding Rods 0.045"x36"View on Amazon
  5. 5PGN ER70S-6 Mild Steel 3/32" x 16" TIG Welding Rod 5 lbPGN ER70S-6 Mild Steel 3/32" x 16" TIG Welding Rod 5 lbView on Amazon
  6. 6ER70S-6 TIG Welding Rod 1/16" x 16"ER70S-6 TIG Welding Rod 1/16" x 16"View on Amazon
  7. 7ER70S-2 Mild Steel TIG Welding RodER70S-2 Mild Steel TIG Welding RodView on Amazon

A cracked mild steel bracket on a trailer gate, a thin sheet patch on a farm cart, and a pipe joint that needs a root pass all point to the same question: tig vs stick for mild steel. This guide compares the processes on mild steel, what each asks of the welder, and the gear that goes with each, so the choice fits the job on the bench.

Other welders and gear to compare

This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Tig vs Stick for Mild Steel in One Paragraph

TIG, also called GTAW in the rod listings, feeds filler rod by hand into a puddle shielded by gas, which gives fine control on thin work. Stick burns a coated electrode that shields the puddle with flux and leaves slag to chip, which suits work away from a gas cylinder. On mild steel the choice comes down to how clean the metal is, how thin the joint is, and whether the job sits indoors or out in the wind.

Side by Side

TIG Stick Mild steel note
Shielding Argon/CO2 gas from a cylinder Flux coating on the electrode TIG rod listings name Argon/CO2 gas
Filler metal ER70S-2 and ER70S-6 rods Coated stick electrode Rod listings name ER70S-2 and ER70S-6
Slag and cleanup No slag layer Slag to chip after welding ER70S-6 listing notes minimal post-weld grinding
Outdoor work Gas shielding is disturbed by wind Flux shielding tolerates wind better Wind affects gas shielding more than flux shielding
Dirty or rusty steel ER70S-6 deoxidizers suit dirty, oily or rusty steel Flux tolerates less clean metal ER70S-6 listing states dirty, oily, or rusty steel
Thin sheet and pipe Sheet metal and root pass pipe work named Practice kit covers stick on steel plates Rod listings name sheet metal and root pass pipe welding
Practice gear Glarks coupons suit TIG SONNLER kit suits stick Both kits suit more than one process

Polarity and gas choice follow the wire and rod label and the machine manual. The rod listings here name Argon/CO2 shielding gas for TIG, and the practice kits name the processes each plate suits, so check the listing before ordering filler or coupons for a job.

When TIG Is the Better Choice

  • Thin sheet and small pipe. The rod listings name sheet metal applications, small diameter pipe and tubing, and root pass pipe welding for ER70S-2 and ER70S-6 rods.
  • Clean, visible beads. ER70S-6 contains higher levels of manganese and silicon, and its listing notes a smoother bead appearance with minimal post-weld grinding.
  • All position work. ER70S-2 is a triple deoxidized wire for all position welding on mild and low alloy steel.
  • Dirty steel, with the right rod. ER70S-6 is a general purpose wire for fabrication of mild steel on dirty, oily, or rusty steel.

See the best TIG rod for mild steel roundup for more filler choices.

When Stick Is the Better Choice

  • Work away from gas. Stick needs no cylinder, hose, or regulator run to the joint, which helps on gates, fences, and equipment in a field.
  • Wind and outdoor jobs. A breeze that scatters shielding gas affects a flux shielded arc less than a gas shielded arc.
  • Practice on steel plates. The SONNLER kit suits stick along with TIG, MIG, gas, and arc welding, so one kit covers both processes for practice.
  • Rougher steel. Stick suits farm repair where prep is rough.

Gear for Mild Steel: Filler and Practice, Ranked

The four listings below cover the filler and practice side of this comparison, ranked from the most direct fit for mild steel work to the most project based pick.

  1. WeldingCity ER70S-6 TIG rods. A general purpose mild steel wire in a 5-lb pack of 0.045-inch rods, 36 inches long, conforming to AWS A5.18 and ASME SFA A5.18 for ER70S-6. Its higher manganese and silicon levels suit dirty, oily, or rusty steel, and the listing notes better wetting, a flatter bead shape, and minimal post-weld grinding. Shielding gas is Argon/CO2.
  2. WeldingCity ER70S-2 TIG rods. A triple deoxidized wire in a 5-lb pack of 3/32-inch rods, 36 inches long, conforming to AWS A5.18 and ASME SFA A5.18 for ER70S-2. The listing names repairs on mild and low alloy steel, small diameter pipe and tubing, sheet metal applications, and root pass pipe welding, with all position welding. Note the listing title says 5-lb while the spec table says 4.69 pounds; the title figure is the pack figure to use.
  3. Glarks welding coupons. Five mild steel plates, 2 inches by 6 inches and 1/8 inch thick, for MIG, TIG, arc, gas, and brazing practice. The plates suit households as well as workshops, and the listing notes smooth surfaces and edges free from burrs. For a welder learning either process, coupons give repeatable joints without cutting up project metal.
  4. SONNLER deer head practice kit. Fifteen mild steel plates that form a deer head project, suitable for TIG, MIG, gas, arc, and stick welding. The kit is a project rather than a stack of flat coupons, so it suits a welder who wants a finished piece at the end of practice. The listing describes precision cut plates that fit together for welding.

How to Choose Between Them

Start from the joint, not the machine. Thin sheet, a visible bead, or a root pass on pipe points to TIG with ER70S-2 or ER70S-6 filler. Outdoor work, rough farm steel, or a job far from a gas cylinder points to stick. When the answer is still unclear, practice both processes on coupons: the Glarks plates suit TIG and arc work, and the SONNLER kit suits stick as well, so a single practice order can cover the comparison. See the best welder for beginners guide and the TIG vs MIG for beginners comparison for machine choices.

Arc flash, fumes, and gas cylinders. TIG and stick both throw arc flash and fumes, so weld with ventilation or outdoors with your head out of the plume, wear a helmet and safety glasses when chipping slag, and clear flammable material from the area. Secure gas cylinders upright with a chain. See the OSHA welding overview.

FAQ for welders

Can TIG weld mild steel without filler rod?

Thin edge joints can fuse without filler, but filler rod adds metal and bridges gaps on joints that need it. The ER70S-2 and ER70S-6 rods in this guide are made for mild steel, and the listings name sheet metal and root pass pipe work where filler matters. For gaps or joints that need added metal, use filler rather than fusing the edges alone.

Is stick better than TIG for rusty mild steel?

Stick tolerates rough prep well, but TIG is not ruled out on dirty steel when the rod suits it. ER70S-6 is a general purpose wire for mild steel on dirty, oily, or rusty steel, with deoxidizers that help the puddle. Clean the joint when possible, and pick stick when the job is outdoors or the prep will stay rough.

Do I need shielding gas for both processes?

TIG needs shielding gas, and the rod listings here name Argon/CO2 for ER70S-2 and ER70S-6. Stick needs no gas cylinder, since the electrode coating shields the puddle. That difference matters on outdoor jobs where a cylinder is one more thing to haul and shelter.

Can I practice both processes on the same coupons?

Yes, with the right kit. Glarks coupons suit MIG, TIG, arc, gas, and brazing, while the SONNLER kit suits TIG, MIG, gas, arc, and stick. Buy plates that name both processes, and practice the same joint type under each process before moving to project metal.

Which filler rod should a beginner start with for mild steel?

ER70S-6 is the general purpose pick in this guide, made for fabrication of mild steel with a smoother bead and minimal post-weld grinding. ER70S-2 is the triple deoxidized choice for all position work on mild and low alloy steel. Either rod covers the sheet metal and pipe work named in the listings, so pick the one that matches the steel condition on the bench.

Related: stick welder vs MIG welder for farm repairs, best TIG rod for mild steel, TIG vs MIG for beginners, and the welders hub.

More buying guides