Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Mig vs Stick for Aluminum: Which One Should You Buy?

Both wires in this guide are MIG, the ER5356 for 5xxx series alloys and the ER4043 for 3003, 3004, 6061 and 6063, and there is no stick listing here to score.

Mig vs Stick for Aluminum: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1ARCCAPTAIN Silicon Aluminum Welding Wire ER4043ARCCAPTAIN Silicon Aluminum Welding Wire ER40439.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2ARCCAPTAIN Magnesium Aluminum MIG Welding WireARCCAPTAIN Magnesium Aluminum MIG Welding Wire9.6/10View on Amazon

Verdict. This guide scores the MIG side only: both wires here are MIG, the ER5356 for 5xxx series alloys and the ER4043 for 3003, 3004, 6061 and 6063, and there is no stick listing here to score. If your alloy is 5083, 5356, 5454 or 5456, take the ER5356; if it is 3003, 3004, 6061 or 6063, take the ER4043; 5052 is covered by both wires.

Aluminum asks for a filler matched to the alloy before the arc starts, and the wire in the spool decides which alloys you can join. The question of mig vs stick for aluminum comes down to which process fits the job, but this guide can only compare the two MIG wires in hand. Both listings here are MIG wire, and there is no stick listing in this guide, so the stick side is not covered here at all: no stick electrode, no amperage and no alloy list is stated.

WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The two wires

ARCCAPTAIN Silicon Aluminum Welding Wire ER4043

ARCCAPTAIN Silicon Aluminum Welding Wire ER4043

ARCCAPTAIN9.6/10 Gear Score
i
The Gear Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 0.035 inch aluminum MIG wire with 5% silicon for 3003, 6061 and other grades, melting from 1065 to 1170 °F, in a pack of two 1 lb spools.

Pros

  • Two 1 lb spools in the pack
  • 5% silicon (AlSi5), tailored for the MIG welding process
  • Suits 3003, 3004, 5052, 6061, 6063 and casing alloys 43, 355, 356 and 214
  • Melting range 1065 to 1170 °F with a density of 0.097 lbs/in³

Cons

  • Two-spool pack, so a buyer who needs one spool still buys two
  • Covers 5052 but not 5083, 5356, 5454 or 5456
  • No warranty term is stated
  • Comes only in 0.035 inch, with no thicker or thinner wire
ARCCAPTAIN Magnesium Aluminum MIG Welding Wire

ARCCAPTAIN Magnesium Aluminum MIG Welding Wire

ARCCAPTAIN9.6/10 Gear Score
i
The Gear Score runs from 9.2 to 9.8 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 0.035 inch aluminum MIG wire with 5.0% magnesium for 5xxx series alloys, melting from 950 to 1175 °F, on a 1 lb spool.

Pros

  • 5.0% magnesium content for 5xxx series aluminum-magnesium alloys
  • Melting range 950 to 1175 °F with a density of 0.097 pounds per cubic inch
  • Suits 5052, 5083, 5356, 5454 and 5456 base metals
  • Smooth, stable arc with easy control and a clean bead, per the maker

Cons

  • Single 1 lb spool, while the ER4043 pack holds two 1 lb spools
  • Alloy match is limited to 5xxx series aluminum-magnesium alloys
  • No warranty term is stated
  • Comes only in 0.035 inch, with no thicker or thinner wire

Other welders and gear to compare

Mig vs stick for aluminum

Both wires in this guide are MIG wire at 0.035 inch, and both claim a smooth, stable arc with easy control and a clean bead. The difference between the two wires is the filler metal: the ER5356 carries 5.0% magnesium for 5xxx series aluminum-magnesium alloys, while the ER4043 carries 5% silicon (AlSi5) and is tailored for the MIG welding process. There is no stick listing in this guide, so the stick side is not scored here: the listings give no stick amperage, no electrode size and no alloy list to compare against the two MIG wires.

Side by side

Gear Score Wire diameter Melting range Pack
ARCCAPTAIN ER4043 9.6/10 0.035 inch 1065 to 1170 °F 1 lb spool x 2
ARCCAPTAIN ER5356 9.6/10 0.035 inch 950 to 1175 °F 1 lb spool

Treat the specs as maker ratings pulled straight from the listings; we gathered them on 1 November 2026. Neither listing states a warranty, a certification, or a stick electrode.

Melting range and wire diameter

Both wires are 0.035 inch in diameter, so diameter does not separate them. The melting ranges do: the ER5356 melts from 950 to 1175 °F, while the ER4043 melts from 1065 to 1170 °F. Both list a density of 0.097 pounds per cubic inch, and both come on 1 lb spools, with the ER4043 packing two spools to the ER5356 one.

Alloy match

The ER5356 suits 5xxx series aluminum-magnesium alloys: 5052, 5083, 5356, 5454 and 5456, especially base metals with high magnesium content. The ER4043 suits 3003, 3004, 5052, 6061, 6063 and casing alloys 43, 355, 356 and 214. The two lists overlap at 5052 only, so the alloy on the joint picks the wire: 5083, 5356, 5454 and 5456 point to the ER5356, while 3003, 3004, 6061 and 6063 point to the ER4043. See the aluminum MIG wire 5356 vs 4043 comparison for the two wires head to head.

Anodizing color

After anodizing, the ER5356 color is white and the ER4043 color is gray. That color is the only finish figure either listing states, and it matters where the weld stays visible.

Weight and pack

Both wires come on 1 lb spools at 0.035 inch, so the wire on each spool is the same by weight. The pack is what differs: the ER5356 listing is a single 1 lb spool, while the ER4043 listing packs two 1 lb spools. Buy the pack that matches how much wire the job needs.

Warranty

Neither listing states a warranty, so both wires score zero on warranty and neither carries a stated term. That leaves warranty out of this comparison entirely: pick on alloy match, melting range and pack, not on a warranty neither maker publishes.

Choose the ARCCAPTAIN ER5356 if

  • You weld 5xxx series aluminum-magnesium alloys such as 5083, 5356, 5454 or 5456.
  • You want the maker’s stated resistance to seawater and salt spray corrosion.
  • You need one 1 lb spool, not a two-spool pack.
  • A white color after anodizing suits the joint.

Choose the ARCCAPTAIN ER4043 if

  • You weld 3003, 3004, 6061 or 6063 aluminum, or casing alloys 43, 355, 356 or 214.
  • You want a silicon wire tailored for the MIG welding process.
  • You want two 1 lb spools in the pack.
  • A gray color after anodizing suits the joint.

FAQ for welders

Is MIG or stick better for aluminum?

This guide cannot settle that from the listings in hand: MIG is the only side with a product here, both wires are MIG, and there is no stick listing to compare. The ER5356 covers 5xxx series alloys and the ER4043 covers 3003, 3004, 6061, 6063 and casing alloys, so pick the wire by the alloy on the joint.

What is the difference between ER5356 and ER4043 wire?

The ER5356 carries 5.0% magnesium and suits 5xxx series aluminum-magnesium alloys, while the ER4043 carries 5% silicon (AlSi5) and suits 3003, 3004, 5052, 6061, 6063 and casing alloys. The ER5356 melts from 950 to 1175 °F and the ER4043 from 1065 to 1170 °F, and both are 0.035 inch wire on 1 lb spools.

Can I use ER4043 on 5052 aluminum?

Yes. The ER4043 listing names 5052 among its alloys, along with 3003, 3004, 6061, 6063 and casing alloys 43, 355, 356 and 214. The ER5356 listing also names 5052, so both wires in this guide cover that alloy.

What diameter wire are these?

Both wires are 0.035 inch in diameter. Neither listing states another diameter, so a different diameter needs a different listing.

Do these wires come with a warranty?

No. Neither listing states a warranty term, so both wires score zero on warranty. Pick on alloy match, melting range and pack instead.

Related: best aluminum MIG wire, flux core vs MIG, how to choose a MIG welder, and the MIG welders hub.

Scoring, line by line

Both wires are scored on performance, build, value, safety listing and warranty, with the weights published on the How We Pick page.

Product Gear Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
ARCCAPTAIN ER4043 9.6 30 21 21 n/a 0
ARCCAPTAIN ER5356 9.6 29 21 20 n/a 0

Think of 9.2 as the bottom and 9.8 as the top. Totals are placed between them in proportion, which keeps the order intact: more points, higher score. Safety is only scored for powered machines or when a listing names safety features; otherwise it drops out and the score is worked from the other 90 points.

Before you strike an arc. Check the alloy on the joint against the wire’s list before you load the spool, and confirm the 0.035 inch wire matches the drive rolls and contact tip. Keep the spool dry and the wire clean, weld with good ventilation, and wear a helmet with the right shade, safety glasses underneath, leather gloves and flame resistant clothing. See the OSHA welding overview and the Safety Disclaimer.

More buying guides