Mig vs Stick for Rusty Metal: Which One Should You Buy?
The ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro and the Metal Marlin E6011 rod take different routes to rusty metal, and the listing details decide which route fits a given repair.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro MIG Welder Machine 165A 120V9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
Metal Marlin E6011 Welding Rod 1/8″, 25 lb Pack9.4/10View on Amazon
Verdict. For mig vs stick for rusty metal, pick the MIG side when a single machine with wire welding modes fits the repair, and pick the stick side when electrodes for dirty metal fit the repair and a welder is already on hand. The machine example brings modes, controls and a stated warranty, while the rod example brings a pack made for rusty, painted, or oily metal.
Rusty metal on a farm gate, a trailer frame, or a piece of shop equipment puts a plain repair in a harder place, since paint, oil and rust sit between the arc and clean steel. This comparison answers mig vs stick for rusty metal with the listings as concrete examples, and it keeps each figure with the listing that states it.
WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same.
The Two Listings

ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro MIG Welder Machine 165A 120V
A 165A multiprocess welder with 120V/240V input with Gas MIG, Gasless MIG, MMA Stick, Lift TIG, Spot Welding and Spool Gun modes, synergy control for MIG, app control and a large LED screen.
Pros
- 165A output, with 120V/240V input, with Gas MIG, Gasless MIG, MMA Stick, Lift TIG, Spot Welding and Spool Gun modes
- Synergy control for MIG matches current and wire feed speed when wire diameter and gas material are selected
- Wire feed speed up to 560IPM, with inductance adjustment, burn-back adjustment and spot time settings
- Large LED screen, app control and remote setting adjustment, plus a 3-Year Manufacturer warranty
Cons
- Spool gun and Lift TIG torch need an extra purchase, so those modes are not ready from the box as listed
- No duty cycle is stated in the listing
- No safety standard is stated in the listing
- No rated thickness is stated in the listing

Metal Marlin E6011 Welding Rod 1/8″, 25 lb Pack
A 1/8 inch by 14 inch E6011 stick electrode in a 25 lb pack, for all-position stick welding on AC and DC, with a high cellulose potassium coating for rusty, painted, or oily metal.
Pros
- Deep penetration and a fast-freezing arc, for rusty, painted, or oily metal where cleanup is limited
- All-position use: flat, horizontal, vertical and overhead, with fast-freezing slag for out-of-position work
- Runs on AC and DC, including small AC buzz box welders, according to the listing
- High cellulose potassium coating for arc force, penetration and fusion on mild steel
Cons
- Electrodes only, with no machine stated in the listing
- No warranty term is stated in the listing
- No safety standard is stated in the listing
- Pack size is fixed at 25 lb in the listing, with no smaller pack stated
Other welders and gear to compare
Futelo 160A MIG WelderCheck price on Amazon
ARCCAPTAIN MIG145 Pro Flux Core MIG Welder 145A 120V 3-in-1Check price on Amazon
Side by side
| ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro | Metal Marlin E6011 Rod | Note | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gear Score | 68 | 56 | Machine example higher |
| Power | 120V/240V | AC and DC | Input voltage vs output type |
| Output | 165A | Not stated | Rod output not stated |
| Processes | Gas MIG, Gasless MIG, MMA Stick, Lift TIG, Spot Welding, Spool Gun | Stick, SMAW | Machine modes broader |
| Size | 14.9 Inches x 5.3 Inches x 9.7 Inches | 1/8″ x 14″ | Machine versus pack |
| Weight | 10.0 Pounds | 25 lb Pack | Machine versus pack |
| Rusty metal fit | Listing names rusty metal as a use | Listing names rusty, painted, or oily metal | Both name rusty metal |
| Warranty | 3-Year Manufacturer | Not stated | Machine term stated |
These numbers are the manufacturer’s ratings exactly as each listing gives them, recorded on 2 November 2026.
Mig vs Stick for Rusty Metal: What Separates the Sides
The sides differ in what is being bought. The ARCCAPTAIN example is a complete welding machine, with modes, controls, a screen and a stated warranty. The Metal Marlin example is a pack of electrodes, with a coating, a size and a pack weight, and it needs a welder that the listing does not name.
Power and Output
The ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro is rated at 165A, with 120V/240V input. The listing names Gas MIG, Gasless MIG, MMA Stick, Lift TIG, Spot Welding and Spool Gun modes for the machine. Synergy control for MIG matches current and wire feed speed when wire diameter and gas material are selected. Wire feed speed reaches up to 560IPM, and the wire feeding machine is rated at 30W in the listing.
The Metal Marlin E6011 Rod listing states no output figure. The listing states compatibility with AC and DC power sources, including small AC buzz box welders. Output for a stick rod depends on the welder used, and the rod listing does not name a welder, so no output comparison can be made from the listings.
Rusty Metal Fit
The ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro listing names rusty metal among its uses, alongside home DIY, garage work, outdoor repairs, farm and road equipment, and maintenance and repairs. No rated thickness is stated for the machine, so the listing does not show how thick a rusty section the machine is rated for.
The Metal Marlin E6011 Rod listing describes the rod as ideal for rusty, painted, or oily metal where cleanup is limited. The listing names a high cellulose potassium coating, a deep penetration arc and fast-freezing slag. All-position use covers flat, horizontal, vertical and overhead work, which matters for field repairs where position cannot be chosen.
Modes and Consumables
The ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro listing names 6 welding modes. Gas MIG and Gasless MIG cover wire work with and without gas, and MMA Stick covers stick work from the same machine. Lift TIG and Spool Gun modes cover other work, but the listing states that a Lift TIG torch and a spool gun need an extra purchase.
The Metal Marlin E6011 Rod listing names Stick and SMAW as the process for the rod. The rod size is 1/8 inch by 14 inch, and the pack weight is 25 lb. The listing names farm equipment, galvanized tanks, truck frames, pressure piping, rail cars and general maintenance and repair as uses.
Size and Weight
The ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro listing states dimensions of 14.9 Inches x 5.3 Inches x 9.7 Inches. The listing states an item weight of 10.0 Pounds. Those figures describe the machine’s size and weight, and the listing names outdoor repairs among its uses.
The Metal Marlin E6011 Rod listing states a rod size of 1/8 inch by 14 inch. The listing states a pack weight of 25 lb. Those figures describe electrodes in a pack, not a machine, so they do not compare directly with machine dimensions or machine weight.
Warranty and What Is Missing
The ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro listing states a 3-Year Manufacturer warranty. That stated term gives the machine example a clear warranty point in its favor, since a term with years is stated. The machine listing states no duty cycle and no rated thickness, and no safety standard is stated, so those points stay unclear.
The Metal Marlin E6011 Rod listing states no warranty term. The rod listing states no duty cycle, no output figure and no safety standard. Those gaps do not make the rod a weak electrode on its stated merits, but they leave a buyer without written cover or machine figures from the rod listing alone.
Choose the ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro if
- A single machine with Gas MIG, Gasless MIG and MMA Stick modes fits the work.
- Synergy control for MIG setup and app control for remote adjustment sound useful.
- A stated 3-Year Manufacturer warranty matters for the purchase.
- The work stays within the modes and settings the listing states, without needing a spool gun or Lift TIG torch from the box.
Choose the Metal Marlin E6011 Rod if
- A welder is already on hand, and electrodes are what the job needs.
- Rusty, painted, or oily metal with limited cleanup is the main condition.
- All-position work, including vertical and overhead positions, is part of the repair.
- AC and DC compatibility fits the welder on hand, including a small AC buzz box welder.
How the Listings Were Scored
Each listing is scored on performance, build, value, safety and warranty, from what the listing states. The machine example scores higher on warranty, since a 3-Year Manufacturer warranty is stated, while the rod example states no warranty term.
| Product | Gear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro | 9.5 | 29 | 20 | 20 | 0 | 4 |
| Metal Marlin E6011 Rod | 9.4 | 28 | 20 | 20 | 0 | 0 |
Displayed scores fall between 9.2 and 9.8: the weighted point total is mapped onto that band in a straight line, so earning more points always lifts the score.
Before You Strike an Arc
- For the ARCCAPTAIN example, confirm the power supply matches 120V/240V and that the mode selected matches the work, since spool gun and Lift TIG work need extra parts.
- For the Metal Marlin example, confirm the welder on hand runs AC or DC, since the rod listing states compatibility with AC and DC power sources.
- For the ARCCAPTAIN example, check consumables on arrival against the listing, and confirm that a spool gun or Lift TIG torch bought separately is the part needed for those modes.
- For the Metal Marlin example, check the pack seal on arrival, and confirm the rod size matches the work before opening a sealed pack.
- Clear flammable material from the work area, weld with ventilation, and wear a helmet, gloves and flame resistant clothing suited to the process.
FAQ for welders
Should you pick MIG or stick for rusty metal?
Pick the MIG side when a single machine with Gas MIG and Gasless MIG modes fits the repair. Pick the stick side when electrodes for rusty, painted, or oily metal fit the repair and a welder is already on hand.
Can the ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro weld rusty metal?
The ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro listing names rusty metal among its uses. No rated thickness is stated for the machine, so the listing does not show a thickness limit for rusty sections.
Can the Metal Marlin E6011 rod weld rusty metal?
The Metal Marlin E6011 Rod listing describes the rod as ideal for rusty, painted, or oily metal where cleanup is limited. All-position use covers flat, horizontal, vertical and overhead work.
Do you need a separate welder for the Metal Marlin rod?
The Metal Marlin E6011 Rod listing sells electrodes, not a machine. The listing states compatibility with AC and DC power sources, including small AC buzz box welders.
What warranty does each listing state?
The ARCCAPTAIN MIG165 Pro listing states a 3-Year Manufacturer warranty. The Metal Marlin E6011 Rod listing states no warranty term.
Related: how to stick weld rusty metal, best MIG wire for rusty metal, flux core welding vs stick welding, and mig vs stick for mild steel.




