Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Quick Clamp vs Spring Clamp: Which One Should You Buy?

Quick clamps and spring clamps hold work in different ways, and the quick-clamp listings in this guide show load, opening and spreader use.

Quick Clamp vs Spring Clamp: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1WORKPRO Mini Bar Clamps for WoodworkingWORKPRO Mini Bar Clamps for Woodworking9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Amazon Basics 14-Piece Nylon Spring Clamp Set for PhotographyAmazon Basics 14-Piece Nylon Spring Clamp Set for Photography9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3WORKPRO 6-Pack Bar Clamps for WoodworkingWORKPRO 6-Pack Bar Clamps for WoodworkingView on Amazon
  4. 4Jorgensen 8-Inch Bar Clamp SetJorgensen 8-Inch Bar Clamp SetView on Amazon
  5. 5HORUSDY 6-Pack Wood Clamps for WoodworkingHORUSDY 6-Pack Wood Clamps for WoodworkingView on Amazon
  6. 6IRWIN QUICK-GRIP Bar Clamps for WoodworkingIRWIN QUICK-GRIP Bar Clamps for WoodworkingView on Amazon
  7. 7IRWIN QUICK-GRIP Bar ClampIRWIN QUICK-GRIP Bar ClampView on Amazon
  8. 812 inch Bar Clamps for Woodworking12 inch Bar Clamps for WoodworkingView on Amazon

A quick clamp locks with a trigger or ratchet and stays put without holding the handle, while a spring clamp holds with spring force that closes the jaws when released. That difference is what quick clamp vs spring clamp comes down to: pick a quick clamp when the work must stay clamped under a locked hold while both hands do other work, and pick a spring clamp for light holding that releases with a squeeze. No spring-clamp listing is featured in this set, so spring-clamp figures are not given here, and the quick-clamp listings below show what a locking clamp states.

Other welders and gear to compare

This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The difference in one paragraph: quick clamp vs spring clamp

Quick clamps in this set include bar and F clamps and a table and guide-rail clamp, with a trigger, ratchet or sliding head that advances the jaw and holds it in place. A spring clamp has no trigger or ratchet in its name: the spring itself closes the jaws, so the holding force ends when the spring is opened or removed. That is why a quick clamp suits fit-up and glue-up where the clamp must stay put, while a spring clamp suits holding a part in place for a step and then letting go with a squeeze.

Side by side

Quick clamp Spring clamp What the listings show
Holding method Trigger, ratchet or sliding head that locks in place Spring that closes the jaws when released Trigger and ratchet clamps listed
One-handed use Trigger clamps in this set are one-handed Squeeze open with one hand, release to hold One-handed trigger clamps listed
Spreader use Some bar clamps in this set reverse into a spreader No spring-clamp listing in this set states a spreader use WORKPRO and Jorgensen name spreader use
Locking Ratchet or trigger holds pressure without holding the handle Holding force comes from the spring, not a lock Ratchet holds without holding the handle, per listings
Suits Fit-up and glue-up where the clamp must stay put Light holding that releases with a squeeze Glue-up named in listings

A figure in pounds and a figure in pounds per square inch are different units, so do not rank those two figures against each other. Check the unit on the listing before comparing load figures.

When a quick clamp is the better choice

  • Fit-up that must stay put. A trigger or ratchet clamp holds the joint while both hands weld, grind or glue, without holding the handle.
  • Glue-up and repair. The Jorgensen listing names glue-up and repair, and the Jorgensen and WORKPRO listings name non-marring pads that protect the work surface.
  • Spreader work. Some bar clamps in this set reverse into a spreader, so one clamp covers both holding and spreading.
  • Table and rail work. A clamp made for a table system or guide rail holds a workpiece for cutting, sanding or routing on that system.

See best quick clamps for metal for more locking clamps.

When a spring clamp is the better choice

  • Light holding. A spring clamp comes on and off fast, which suits a part that only needs light holding for one step.
  • Work that moves often. When the clamp moves often, a spring jaw opens with a squeeze for repositioning.
  • Small parts. A spring jaw suits small work that needs only light holding.

No spring-clamp listing is featured in this set, so no spring-clamp load, opening or size figure is given here. See best spring clamps for spring-clamp sets.

Gear examples, ranked

Jorgensen E-Z Hold bar clamps. Ranked first in this set for stated load. The listing gives a 4-pack of 6 inch bar clamps with a maximum opening capacity of 6 inches, a throat depth of 2-3/8 inches from the bar top of the pad, and a normal load limit of 200 lbs. The bullets also say clamping forces up to 300 lbs, while the spec table gives a tensile strength of 150 pounds, so those three figures do not agree and should be checked before relying on a single load figure. The clamps convert to a spreader, two clamps can be joined for more than double the opening capacity of a single clamp, and the bar is 1/8 inch by 1/2 inch plated, round-edge, high-carbon steel with glass-filled nylon advancing handles and soft plastic pads.

WORKPRO bar clamps. Ranked second for pack size and spreader range. The set contains 4 pieces of 6 inch bar clamps and 2 pieces of 12 inch bar clamps, with up to 150 lbs of clamping force, a reinforced nylon body and hardened steel bars, and a metal ratcheting mechanism. The 6 inch clamps convert to spreaders of sizes up to 11-9/64 inches and the 12 inch clamp converts to a spreader with sizes up to 17-21/64 inches. The set weighs 5.3 pounds, with dimensions of 17.13 by 12.2 by 2.48 inches, and non-marring removable and replaceable pads.

Festool quick clamp. Ranked third for system fit and stated warranty, with a single clamp. The listing gives a clamping thickness of 6 5/8 inches (168mm), a ratcheting mechanism for locking and quick release, and fit with holes and channels of the MFT table and the bottom t-slot of guide rails. The spec table gives a 3-Year Limited Warranty, alloy steel material, and dimensions of 10.63 by 5.71 by 1.97 inches. The listing names compatibility with KAPEX KS 120, MFT/3, TS 55, TSC 55 and TS 75. No load limit is stated for this clamp.

IRWIN Quick-Grip clamps. Ranked fourth, with a warranty contradiction noted and pressure stated in psi. The 8-piece set gives mini bar clamps that exert up to 150 psi of clamping pressure, with quick-release triggers and high-tech reinforced resin construction. The set names 12 inch and 6 inch mini one-handed bar clamps among its components. The bullets end after the words IRWIN Lifetime with no term completed, while the spec table gives a manufacturer warranty description of No Warranty, so no warranty term is counted here. The item weight is 16 ounces, with dimensions of 21.3 by 15.6 by 2.3 inches.

How to tell what a clamp supports

Look for the mechanism first: a trigger, ratchet or sliding head means a locking quick clamp, while a spring jaw means spring holding. Then check the opening and throat depth on the listing, the load figure and its unit, whether the listing names spreader conversion, and whether a warranty term is stated in full. If a listing gives two different load figures, or a bullet that ends before a warranty term, treat that figure as unsettled and check the listing before ordering.

FAQ for welders

Is a quick clamp stronger than a spring clamp?

That cannot be answered from this set, because no spring-clamp listing is featured here and no spring-clamp load figure is given. Quick-clamp listings in this set state their own loads, so compare a stated quick-clamp load with a stated spring-clamp load from a spring-clamp listing, not with the clamp type name alone.

Can a bar clamp work as a spreader?

Yes, for the listings that name that use. The WORKPRO and Jorgensen listings both name clamp and spreader use, with the WORKPRO listing naming jaw reversal. A listing that does not name spreader use should not be assumed to spread.

What does 150 psi mean against 150 lbs?

Those figures use different units, so they are not directly comparable. The IRWIN listing states 150 psi of clamping pressure, while the WORKPRO listing states 150 lbs of clamping force. Check the unit on each listing before ranking clamps by load.

Which quick clamp in this set states a warranty term?

Only the Festool listing states a warranty term in full, a 3-Year Limited Warranty. The IRWIN spec table states No Warranty, and the WORKPRO and Jorgensen listings state no warranty term in the data given here.

Can one clamp do both holding and spreading?

Yes, for the WORKPRO and Jorgensen listings, which both name clamp and spreader use. The Festool and IRWIN listings in this set do not name spreader use, so spreading should not be assumed for those clamps.

Related: best spring clamps, toggle clamp vs spring clamp, and the welding tables and carts hub.

More buying guides

Welding Tables and Carts ·

Best Small Spring Clamps: 3 Sets for the Shop

Three small spring clamp sets compared on what each listing states: sizes, jaw openings, materials, pack counts and warranties, for the shop and bench.