Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Pure Tungsten vs Thoriated Tungsten: Which Electrode?

Pure tungsten vs thoriated tungsten: AC vs DC use and arc starts, with two green-band pure EWP 10-packs from the listings.

Pure Tungsten vs Thoriated Tungsten: Which Electrode?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1ARCCAPTAIN TIG Welding Tungsten Electrode 10-Pack 1/8" x 7"ARCCAPTAIN TIG Welding Tungsten Electrode 10-Pack 1/8" x 7"View on Amazon
  2. 2ARCCAPTAIN TIG Welding Tungsten Electrode 10-Pack 1/16"x 7"ARCCAPTAIN TIG Welding Tungsten Electrode 10-Pack 1/16"x 7"View on Amazon
  3. 3Midwest Tungsten Service Green 3/32" TIG Tungsten ElectrodesMidwest Tungsten Service Green 3/32" TIG Tungsten ElectrodesView on Amazon
  4. 4Arc-Zone Amplify Tungsten Electrode for TIG WeldingArc-Zone Amplify Tungsten Electrode for TIG WeldingView on Amazon
  5. 5Pure TIG Welding Tungsten Electrodes 3/32? x 7? 10-PackPure TIG Welding Tungsten Electrodes 3/32? x 7? 10-PackView on Amazon
  6. 6Tungsten Cube 10mmTungsten Cube 10mmView on Amazon

This pure tungsten vs thoriated tungsten guide compares the two classic TIG electrode families: green-band pure tungsten (EWP), which the two listings here stock in 1/8 inch and 3/32 inch, and red-band thoriated tungsten, the old DC workhorse. One side has no thorium and runs AC beautifully; the other starts easier on DC.

Other welders and gear to compare

WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Verdict: pick pure tungsten for AC aluminum and magnesium work, where the listings here rate it for heavy-load AC conditions. Pick thoriated for DC steel and stainless if you value easy arc starts. The two listings in this guide are both pure tungsten: the ARCCAPTAIN 1/8 inch by 7 inch 10-pack and the Midwest Tungsten Service 3/32 inch 10-pack, both pure EWP tungsten.

Pure tungsten vs thoriated tungsten: compare the two

Green-band pure tungsten (EWP) is the AC electrode: both listings here rate it for aluminum, magnesium and heavy-load AC work, with 99.9 percent purity and AWS adherence stated. Red-band thoriated is the DC electrode: easier arc starts and higher current capacity on steel.

Electrode Band Best current Listed sizes AWS stated
ARCCAPTAIN pure EWP Green AC 1/8 in x 7 in, 10-pack A5.12M/A5.12:2009
Midwest pure EWP Green AC 3/32 in, 10-pack A5.12M/A5.12:2036
Thoriated (general) Red DC Not in listings Not stated

20 October 2026

These numbers are the manufacturer’s ratings exactly as each listing gives them, recorded on 20 October 2026. Thoriated electrodes are described from general welding knowledge; the two listings in this guide are both pure tungsten.

The products in this guide

Both listings here are pure tungsten, green-band EWP, sold as 10-packs. The ARCCAPTAIN pack is 1/8 inch by 7 inch, 3.2 by 175 mm, 10.5 ounces, vacuum packed, with 100 percent traceability stated and adherence to AWS A5.12M/A5.12:2009 and DIN EN 26848 stated. The Midwest Tungsten Service pack is 3/32 inch, 6.4 ounces, 99.9 percent pure, made in the United States with a free materials safety data sheet and certificate of conformance linked, adhering to AWS A5.12M/A5.12:2036 per the listing. Neither listing states a warranty term.

The ARCCAPTAIN listing states the pure electrode resists thermal shock for fast arc striking with a low burn-off rate, does not split under heavy amps even on thick aluminum plate, and offers good electrical conductivity suitable for AC welding under heavy-load conditions. The Midwest listing calls pure tungsten exceptional for AC applications and for welding magnesium alloy or aluminum alloys. Both position pure tungsten as the beginner-to-professional AC electrode.

What pure tungsten is

Pure tungsten, green band, EWP, is 99.9 percent tungsten with no added oxides, per the Midwest listing. It balls cleanly on AC, which is why it is the traditional choice for aluminum and magnesium. The ARCCAPTAIN listing states it suits AC welding under heavy-load conditions and resists thermal shock, with fast arc striking and a low burn-off rate. Its weakness is DC: pure tungsten wanders on DC and carries less current than oxide-doped electrodes, so it is not the pick for steel.

Pure tungsten is the side of this comparison with no added oxides, per the Midwest listing. For a home TIG setup running aluminum, the 1/8 inch ARCCAPTAIN and 3/32 inch Midwest packs both state AWS adherence, and the ARCCAPTAIN adds DIN EN 26848 with 100 percent traceability stated.

Size choice follows amperage: the ARCCAPTAIN 1/8 inch pack at 10.5 ounces suits higher amps and thicker plate, while the Midwest 3/32 inch pack at 6.4 ounces suits general work. Both are 10-packs. Keep the vacuum or sealed packing intact until use.

What thoriated tungsten is

Thoriated tungsten, red band, is tungsten doped with a small amount of thorium oxide. The thorium lowers the work function, which makes arc starts easier and lets the electrode carry more current on DC than pure tungsten. That is why thoriated became the default for DC TIG on steel and stainless. It does not ball on AC the way pure tungsten does, so it is a poor AC electrode.

Many shops now switch to lanthanated or ceriated electrodes for the same DC performance. Neither listing in this guide sells thoriated tungsten; both are pure.

If your shop already stocks thoriated, label the red-band tubes clearly and keep them away from the green pure stock. The two packs in this guide are green band only, so a beginner starting with pure tungsten has no mix-up risk.

AC vs DC: the real decision

The current type decides the electrode. AC for aluminum and magnesium calls for pure tungsten, which the listings here rate for heavy-load AC and for magnesium and aluminum alloys. DC for steel and stainless calls for thoriated, lanthanated or ceriated, which hold a point and start easier. Running pure tungsten on DC wastes its strength; running thoriated on AC wastes yours, since it will not form the balled tip that stabilizes the AC arc.

If you weld both, keep both on the bench. The two pure packs here cover the AC side in the two most common sizes: 1/8 inch for higher amps and thicker aluminum, 3/32 inch for general work. Match the diameter to the amperage and the torch collet, and keep the electrodes in their vacuum or sealed packing until use so they stay oxidation free.

Polarity matters on DC: thoriated runs electrode negative for steel, while pure tungsten on AC uses the machine’s AC balance to clean the aluminum oxide. Set the balance per your welder’s manual; the electrode choice only does its job when the machine settings match.

Grinding and handling

Grind tungsten lengthwise, not across, so the grind marks run with the current flow; cross-grinding can cause arc wander. The ARCCAPTAIN pack arrives vacuum packed with no oxidation stated, and the Midwest pack links a free materials safety data sheet, which is worth reading before you grind. For thoriated electrodes, the extra step is keeping the red-band stock labelled apart from the green pure stock.

Store electrodes by color band so you never mix a red thoriated rod into a green pure set. Both listings here are green band only, so there is no mix-up risk inside these packs, but a mixed drawer is where mistakes happen. Label the tubes.

Inspect the tip before each session: a split or contaminated tip, which the ARCCAPTAIN listing says its electrodes resist under heavy amps, means regrind or replace. A clean tip starts cleaner and keeps the arc stable.

Choosing for your welder

For an AC/DC TIG welder running aluminum, start with pure tungsten: the ARCCAPTAIN 1/8 inch 10-pack for heavier work or the Midwest 3/32 inch 10-pack for general work, both stated pure EWP with AWS adherence. For a DC-only machine on steel and stainless, thoriated or its alternatives are the easier start. For a beginner buying one pack, pure tungsten is the simpler first buy: excellent on AC aluminum, and both listings state it serves beginner, intermediate and professional welders.

Both listings sell 10-packs: the ARCCAPTAIN 1/8 inch pack and the Midwest 3/32 inch pack. Add the other size only when your amperage range demands it.

[wgl_safety kind=”tool”]

FAQ for welders

Can I use pure tungsten on DC?

You can, but it is not its strength. The listings rate pure tungsten for AC welding under heavy-load conditions and for aluminum and magnesium alloys. On DC it wanders and carries less current than thoriated or lanthanated electrodes.

What is the tradeoff with thoriated tungsten?

Thoriated tungsten is the DC electrode with easier arc starts, but it does not ball on AC the way pure tungsten does. Neither listing in this guide sells thoriated tungsten; both are pure.

What size tungsten do I need?

The two listings here cover the common sizes: 1/8 inch for higher amps and thick aluminum, 3/32 inch for general work. Match the diameter to your amperage and your torch collet.

Does pure tungsten need a special grinder?

No, but grind lengthwise so the marks run with the current flow. The ARCCAPTAIN pack arrives vacuum packed with no oxidation stated; the Midwest pack links a free safety data sheet worth reading first.

Which adheres to AWS standards?

Both: the ARCCAPTAIN states AWS A5.12M/A5.12:2009 and DIN EN 26848 with 100 percent traceability, and the Midwest states AWS A5.12M/A5.12:2036 with a certificate of conformance linked.

More welding guides

Related: browse our TIG welding guides for more electrode and torch picks.

More buying guides