1.5 vs 2 Percent Tungsten: Which One Should You Buy?
1.5 vs 2 percent tungsten compared through gold WL15 packs, with current type, metals, size, and a replacement claim covered.

On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
ARCCAPTAIN TIG Tungsten9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Midwest Tungsten Service Purple 3/32" TIG Tungsten Electrodes9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
Midwest Tungsten Service Red 1/8" TIG Tungsten Electrodes9.6/10View on Amazon
A TIG job comes down to the arc, the puddle, and the electrode in the torch. When the choice turns on lanthanated content, the question is plain: what do the listings state for the 1.5 percent packs, and what does the replacement claim for 2 percent rest on? This guide covers 1.5 vs 2 percent tungsten using the 1.5 percent lanthanated packs featured here as the working examples, and the replacement claim one listing states for 2 percent.
This guide links to our product roundups, where WeldGearLab gets a commission on purchases made through links on this page, and your price stays the same. Read our affiliate disclosure.
1.5 vs 2 percent tungsten in plain terms
The percent in the name states the lanthanated share of the electrode. Both packs featured in this guide are 1.5 percent lanthanated, gold, WL15 electrodes. That shared starting point keeps the comparison honest: the diameter, the pack count, and the color code match, so the differences that matter sit in current type, metals named, stated length, and the replacement claim.
No 2 percent pack is featured in this guide. The 2 percent side is covered through a claim MELTSTAR states for its WL15 electrodes, not through a separate 2 percent listing. Readers who want a 2 percent electrode should compare that claim against the listing wording for the electrode they buy, rather than treating this guide as a review of a 2 percent pack.
Side by side
| Midwest Gold 1.5 percent lanthanated | MELTSTAR Gold WL15 1.5 percent | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electrode diameter | 1/16 inch | 1/16 inch | Both list the same diameter |
| Electrode length | Not stated | 7 inch, stated as 175 mm | Only MELTSTAR lists a length |
| Pack count | 10-pack | 10-pack | Both list a 10-pack |
| Color code | Gold | Gold | Both carry a gold color code |
| Current type stated | AC and DC | Mainly DC, AC also named | Wording differs by listing |
| Metals named | Titanium, copper, nickel alloys, non-corrosive steel | Carbon steel, stainless steel, nickel, titanium alloys | Nickel and titanium alloys overlap |
| Standard cited | AWS A5.12M/A5.12 | AWS A5.12M/A5.12 | Both cite the same standard |
| 2 percent replacement claim | Not stated | Can replace 2 percent red tungsten | Only MELTSTAR states this claim |
Both listings cite AWS A5.12M/A5.12 conformance, both use a gold color code, both come as a 10-pack, and both list a 1/16 inch diameter. Those shared facts make the table above a fair side by side: the packs agree on size and pack count, and they differ on current wording and metals named.
The electrodes in this guide
Midwest Tungsten Service Gold. The Midwest listing gives a 1/16 inch, 10-pack of 1.5 percent lanthanated electrodes. It states AC and DC applications, and it names titanium alloys, copper alloys, nickel alloys, and non-corrosive steel among the metals covered. The listing also notes United States based manufacturing, a free materials safety data sheet, and a certificate of conformance. Midwest pitches the pack to students and to industrial and artistic users alike.
MELTSTAR Gold WL15. The MELTSTAR listing gives a 1/16 inch by 7 inch electrode, also stated as 1.6 mm by 175 mm, in a 10-pack. It lists mainly DC welding, with AC welding also named. It names carbon steel, stainless steel, nickel alloys, and titanium alloys among the metals covered. MELTSTAR lists arc starting, burn-off rate, arc stability, and re-ignition characteristics as strengths of the electrode. MELTSTAR also states that its WL15 electrodes can replace 2 percent red tungsten and have no radiation.
How to pick between 1.5 percent and 2 percent
Start with current type. The Midwest listing states AC and DC use, while the MELTSTAR listing states mainly DC use with AC welding also named. Match that wording to the current type the job calls for, and check the machine manual for the setting the job needs.
Next, check the metals named. Nickel alloys and titanium alloys appear in both listings. Copper alloys and non-corrosive steel appear in the Midwest listing, while carbon steel and stainless steel appear in the MELTSTAR listing. Pick the listing whose metals list covers the metal on the bench.
Then check size and pack count. Both packs here are 1/16 inch in diameter and both come as a 10-pack, so neither diameter nor pack count separates them. The MELTSTAR listing adds a 7 inch length figure, stated as 175 mm, which is the only length figure stated.
Finally, weigh the replacement claim for what it is: a listing statement, not a separate pack in this guide. MELTSTAR states its WL15 can replace 2 percent red tungsten. The Midwest listing states no replacement claim. When a replacement claim decides the purchase, confirm it against the listing wording before ordering.
FAQ for welders
Can 1.5 percent lanthanated tungsten replace 2 percent tungsten?
MELTSTAR states that its WL15 electrodes can replace 2 percent red tungsten. The Midwest listing states no replacement claim. Treat the claim as one listing statement, and compare it against the listing wording for any electrode under consideration.
What does the gold color code mean on these electrodes?
In these listings, gold marks the 1.5 percent lanthanated WL15 electrodes. Both packs in this guide carry the gold color code. The color code helps identify the electrode type at a glance in the shop.
Can these electrodes weld on AC and DC?
The Midwest listing states AC and DC applications. The MELTSTAR listing states mainly DC welding, with AC welding also named. Check the listing wording for the pack being bought, since the two listings word current type differently.
What size are the electrodes in this guide?
Both packs are 1/16 inch in diameter. The MELTSTAR listing also gives a 7 inch length, with the full size stated as 1.6 mm by 175 mm. The Midwest listing gives a 1/16 inch diameter with no length figure stated.
Which metals do these 1.5 percent electrodes cover?
The Midwest listing names titanium alloys, copper alloys, nickel alloys, and non-corrosive steel. The MELTSTAR listing names carbon steel, stainless steel, nickel alloys, and titanium alloys. Nickel alloys and titanium alloys appear in both listings, while the other metals named differ by listing.
Related: best lanthanated tungsten electrodes and best tungsten welding electrode.




